Opportunity Cost Reasoning

Thinking Tools5.1 Defining the Evaluation CriteriaAlso known as Opportunity cost

From the seen and unseen of Frédéric Bastiat (1850) and the alternative cost of Friedrich von Wieser (1889), named opportunity cost by David I. Green (1894).

Values a choice against the best other use of the same money, time, or people, with that alternative named and estimated.

The upgrade's real cost is what the same $2 million would earn elsewhere

A distributor can spend $2 million on a warehouse upgrade, on a larger sales team, or on neither and keep earning its 9 percent cost of capital. The line is the best the money earns without the upgrade: the sales team's return, or the cost of capital where that is higher. Set the three returns: the upgrade wins only when its point sits above the line, and when both fall below the cost of capital, doing nothing wins. Illustrative.

11%
13%
9%
The upgrade earns a year
$220K
The best other use of the same $2 million earns
$260K
The upgrade, after its opportunity cost
−$40K
The sales team, after its opportunity cost
$40K
Sales team's returnUpgrade's return, %0%20%Upgrade winsSomething else winsSales team's returnUpgrade's return, %0%20%Upgrade winsSomething else wins

The $2 millionDo the upgrade: it earns more than any other use of the $2 million, doing nothing included.Not the upgrade: the same money earns more in the sales team, or simply by staying put at the cost of capital.

An example

The operations director of a food distributor brought a $2 million warehouse upgrade to the capital committee: new racking and scanners that would cut picking errors and overtime, for a return of about 11 percent a year. Against the company's 9 percent cost of capital it cleared the bar, and in past years that would have been enough.

The CFO asked the committee to name the best other use of the same $2 million before voting. The sales director had one ready: eight more field reps in two growing regions, with a return estimated at 13 percent from the margins on the accounts they would bring in. Set against that, the upgrade's real cost was the $260,000 a year the sales team would have earned, and the upgrade fell $40,000 short of it. The committee funded the sales team and asked operations to come back with a smaller upgrade aimed at the overtime alone, which had the highest return of anything in its case.

Why it works

A proposal judged on its own always looks better than it is, because the comparison it implies is with nothing happening. Money, people, and attention are never idle. Spending them here means not spending them on the next best use, and what that use would have earned is the real cost of the choice, whether or not anyone writes it down.

Opportunity cost reasoning makes that cost explicit by naming the alternative and estimating it. Doing so changes the question from "is this good?" to "is this better than the best other thing?" It also gives doing nothing a fair place: the cost of capital is what the money earns if it stays put or goes back to the owners, so a proposal that cannot beat it should not go ahead, even when nothing else is on the table.

The thinking behind it

Frédéric Bastiat Frédéric Bastiat, a French economist and pamphleteer of the liberal school, made the point in his 1850 essay on what is seen and what is not seen. In its best-known part, the parable of the broken window, he argued that a good economist counts the visible effect of an act and also the effects that are not seen, such as what the money spent on the repair would otherwise have bought.

Friedrich von Wieser Friedrich von Wieser, an economist of the Austrian school, developed the idea in Natural Value (Der natürliche Werth, 1889). In his account the value of a use is set by the other uses forgone, the alternative cost doctrine, and he valued the means of production by the value of what they produce. He also gave the German term for marginal utility, Grenznutzen.

David I. Green David I. Green, an economist, wrote Pain-Cost and Opportunity-Cost (Quarterly Journal of Economics, 1894), the article credited as the first appearance of the term opportunity cost. He argued that what people insist on being paid for is, in general, the sacrifice of an opportunity, not the pain of labor, which moved the idea of cost from effort to forgone choice.

How to run it

  1. Name the resource being committed. Money, a team's quarter, or an executive's attention; be specific about how much and for how long.
  2. Name the single best alternative use. Pick the strongest real option, not a straw man, and include returning the money or keeping it in reserve.
  3. Estimate what the alternative would return. Use the same horizon and the same rules for both, so the two numbers compare.
  4. Subtract the alternative from the proposal. The difference is the proposal's value after its opportunity cost, which can be negative.
  5. Check both against the cost of capital. If neither beats it, the best choice is to do nothing and hold or return the money.
  6. Choose the higher value. Fund the winner, and send the loser back with the question of what would make it win.
  7. Record the alternative with the decision. Writing down what was given up makes the choice easy to review later.

Where it goes wrong

The common failure is comparing a proposal with nothing. Every proposal beats doing nothing at all if its return is positive, so the committee approves projects that a better use of the money would have beaten. Make naming the alternative a condition of the vote.

A second failure is a weak alternative chosen to make the proposal look good. The sponsor names a poor second option and wins by comparison. Ask someone outside the sponsor's team to name the best alternative. The third is forgetting time and people. A project that uses the best engineers for a year has an opportunity cost in what they would have built, even if its budget is small; count the scarce people as well as the money.

When to use something else

  • Capital Allocation. When there are many claims on the money at once and the work is ranking and funding them in order.
  • Sunk Cost Reasoning. When money already spent is pulling the comparison toward a project that would not win today.
  • Real Options Analysis. When waiting or staging the spend has value of its own, so the alternative includes deciding later.

Where it sits in SOLVE eX

Go to the source

  • Ce qu'on voit et ce qu'on ne voit pas (That Which Is Seen, and That Which Is Not Seen), 1850
  • Der natürliche Werth (Natural Value), 1889
  • Pain-Cost and Opportunity-Cost, Quarterly Journal of Economics 8(2), 1894

Back to the catalog