Consequentialism

Thinking Tools5.1 Defining the Evaluation CriteriaAlso known as Utilitarian Reasoning

From the utilitarianism of Jeremy Bentham (An Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation, 1789) and John Stuart Mill (Utilitarianism, 1861); the term was coined by Elizabeth Anscombe (Modern Moral Philosophy, 1958).

Judges an action by its outcomes, listing everyone affected, estimating gains and harms with their odds, and comparing the totals across options.

Closing the branch looks worth it until the long-run effect on trust is counted

A bank weighs closing its branch in a farm town of 2,400 customers. Each line is one group's expected gain or loss a year: its size times its odds. Set the cost to customers, the odds staff lose their jobs, and the odds the closing costs the bank deposits across the region: closing wins by a sliver at the opening values, and a modest chance of lost trust flips the total to keep. Illustrative.

$80
50%
10%
The bank: branch costs saved
$600K
Customers: 2,400 times the extra cost each
−$192K
Staff: six jobs at $60K, times the chance each is lost
−$180K
The town: a 30% chance the pharmacy next door closes, a $400K loss
−$120K
Trust: $800K of regional deposit margin, times its chance
−$80K
Expected total of closing, against keeping it open
$28K
Chance of lost trust across the regionExpected total, $K a year0%50%CloseKeepChance of lost trust across the regionExpected total, $K a year0%50%CloseKeep

On the totalsClose: across everyone affected, the expected gains outweigh the expected harms.Keep it open: across everyone affected, closing does more expected harm than good.

An example

A regional bank's branch in a farm town of 2,400 customers cost $600,000 a year more to run than it earned. Finance proposed closing it. The executive committee asked for the case to be redone with everyone the decision touched on one page, each effect given a size and a chance.

The page had five lines. The bank saved its $600,000 for certain. Customers would bear about $80 each a year in travel and lost time. Six staff faced an even chance of losing their jobs. The pharmacy next door, which lived on branch foot traffic, had perhaps a three in ten chance of closing. And there was the line finance had left out: the chance that closing the only branch in town would cost the bank deposits across the region, where it sold itself as the bank that stays. At a one in ten chance, closing still came out ahead by a thin margin; at fifteen percent it did not. The committee kept the branch open two days a week and put the regional survey first.

Why it works

Judging an action by its consequences sounds obvious; doing it honestly is not. Most business cases count the consequences that land on the decision maker and leave the rest as soft. Consequentialism makes the accounting complete: list everyone affected, put a size and a likelihood on what happens to each, and add them up. Expected values let a small chance of a large harm sit on the same scale as a certain small gain.

The discipline shows where the decision is fragile. If the total changes sign when one uncertain line moves a little, that line is where to spend the next week of work, here a survey of how regional customers would react. The long-term effects on trust and precedent deserve their own line because they are the easiest to omit and are often the largest.

The thinking behind it

Jeremy Bentham Jeremy Bentham, an English philosopher and legal reformer, is regarded as the founder of modern utilitarianism. In his 1789 Introduction, written as a basis for morals and for legislation alike, he held that actions and laws should be judged by their consequences for the greatest happiness, understood as the balance of pleasure over pain. That made the totals of a decision's effects, on everyone it reaches, the test of whether it was right, for a lawmaker as much as for a private person.

John Stuart Mill John Stuart Mill, a British philosopher and economist, defended the same standard in Utilitarianism, first published in Fraser's Magazine in 1861 and as a book in 1863: acts are judged by their consequences for happiness. His other work bears on the method too. On Liberty argues that a person does not know their own view until they know the strongest form of the opposing one, which is a fair test for any ledger of consequences drawn up by the side that wants the decision.

G. E. M. Anscombe G. E. M. Anscombe, an analytic philosopher who wrote on intention, action, logic, and ethics, coined the word consequentialism in Modern Moral Philosophy (Philosophy, 1958) for theories that judge acts by their outcomes. The same essay is credited with reviving virtue ethics, the tradition that asks what a person of good character would do. That is one reason a careful consequentialist check ends by setting the total beside rule-based and character-based questions.

How to run it

  1. Name the action and its alternative. Write both, since every consequence is a difference between doing it and not doing it.
  2. List everyone affected. Go past the obvious parties to suppliers, neighbors, and the people who hear about the decision later.
  3. Estimate the size of each effect. Use money where it fits and a rough scale where it does not, but put everything on one scale.
  4. Estimate the chance of each. A certain small effect and an unlikely large one both belong on the page.
  5. Total the expected effects. Multiply each size by its chance, add the lines, and compare the options.
  6. Add the long-run line. Count the effect on trust, reputation, and precedent, which a one-year case leaves out.
  7. Find the line that decides it. See which estimate flips the total when it moves a little, and work on that one next.

Where it goes wrong

The common failure is a partial ledger: the decision maker's gains in money and everyone else's losses in words, so the numbers always win. Put every line on the same scale, even roughly.

A second failure is false precision. Expected values built on guessed odds look exact and are not; show the range over which the answer holds, and say which estimate it depends on. The third is letting the total settle questions it cannot. A positive sum can hide a harm no total should excuse, such as breaking a promise to a group that relied on it. Set the result beside the rules and duties involved before acting.

When to use something else

  • Deontology. When the question is whether an action breaks a duty or a promise, whatever its totals.
  • Ethical Matrix. When the work is laying out what each group is owed, more than adding up the effects on them.
  • Decision Tree Analysis. When the consequences unfold in stages, with choices and chances in sequence.

Where it sits in SOLVE eX

Go to the source

  • An Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation, 1789
  • Utilitarianism, 1861
  • Modern Moral Philosophy, Philosophy 33, 1958

Back to the catalog