Burden of Proof Analysis

Thinking Tools5.1 Defining the Evaluation CriteriaAlso known as Standard of Proof

From the common-law evidence tradition, as set out by John Henry Wigmore (A Treatise on the System of Evidence in Trials at Common Law, 1904) and Charles T. McCormick (Handbook of the Law of Evidence, 1954).

Asks two questions of any disputed claim: who has to prove it, and to what standard, so the argument centers on what must be shown.

The same evidence can carry a small action and fail a large one

A manufacturer says its carton supplier shipped boxes weaker than the contract allows, so the burden of proof is the manufacturer's. Set how strongly the evidence shows the breach and what acting on it would do if the claim proved wrong: the line steps up from more likely than not (holding an invoice), to clear and convincing (ending the contract), to near certain (suing and saying so in public). The point must clear the step its action sits on. Illustrative.

65%
5
Standard the stakes call for
75%
Evidence against that standard
−10 points
Stakes if the claim is wrongStrength of the evidence, %Hold an invoiceSue, go publicBurden metNot yet shownStakes if the claim is wrongStrength of the evidence, %Hold an invoiceSue, go publicBurden metNot yet shown

The claim, at these stakesBurden met: the evidence clears the standard this action calls for, so act on it.Burden not met: gather more evidence, or pick an action with lower stakes that this evidence can carry.

An example

A maker of small appliances found that a run of shipping cartons from its packaging supplier crushed in the warehouse. Operations wanted the contract ended that week. The supplier said the cartons met spec and asked the manufacturer to prove they did not.

The head of procurement put two questions on the table. Who has to prove the breach? The manufacturer, since it is the one making the claim. To what standard? That depends on what the company does with the answer. The evidence so far was one failed lab test, warehouse photos, and a carton lot that matched the failures; the team judged it about two chances in three. That was enough to hold the open invoice while the claim was checked, a step that costs little if it turns out wrong. It was not enough to end a contract that supplied four plants. The team ordered tests on three more lots, and the decision to switch suppliers waited for the results.

Why it works

Arguments about disputed claims go in circles when neither side has agreed what would settle them. Burden of proof analysis settles that first. Putting the burden on whoever asserts the claim stops the familiar move of demanding that the other side disprove something never shown. Matching the standard to the stakes stops the opposite error, treating every claim as if it needed proof beyond doubt before anyone may act.

The insight is that the standard belongs to the action, not to the claim. The same evidence can justify a small, reversible step and fail to justify a large, costly one, and saying so out loud turns a fight about who is right into a plan: act now at the level the evidence supports, and say what further evidence would carry the bigger move.

The thinking behind it

John Henry Wigmore John Henry Wigmore, dean of Northwestern's law school and the leading American scholar of evidence, wrote A Treatise on the System of Evidence in Trials at Common Law (four volumes, 1904 to 1905). Known as Wigmore on Evidence, it is the classic statement of the law of proof, including who bears the burden of proving a claim. He also devised the Wigmore chart, a method for mapping how each item of evidence bears on the facts in dispute.

Charles T. McCormick Charles T. McCormick, a law professor and authority on evidence, damages, and federal procedure, wrote the Handbook of the Law of Evidence (1954), kept in print under later editors as a standard American treatise. It sets out the burdens of proof as the common-law tradition uses them. That tradition, which has no single author, separates the burden of producing evidence from the burden of persuading, and it sets three standards: more likely than not, clear and convincing, and beyond reasonable doubt.

How to run it

  1. State the claim precisely. Write what is said to have happened, when, and against which term or fact, in one sentence.
  2. Name who is asserting it. The person or team making the claim carries the burden unless there is a stated reason to shift it.
  3. Name the action the claim would justify. List what the organization would do if the claim held, from the smallest step to the largest.
  4. Set a standard for each action. Reversible, cheap steps need more likely than not; costly or public ones need clear and convincing evidence or better.
  5. Weigh the evidence against the standard. Judge how strongly it shows the claim, and say which actions it already carries.
  6. Refuse attempts to shift the burden. When the other side says prove it is false, bring the discussion back to what the claimant has shown.
  7. Say what would carry the next action. Name the further evidence that would clear the next standard, and who will gather it.

Where it goes wrong

The first failure is setting one standard for the whole dispute. Teams either demand near certainty before doing anything, which lets a real breach run on, or act on a hunch at full scale. Tie each standard to an action, and take the actions the evidence already supports.

A second failure is letting the burden slide. A confident speaker who says nobody has shown it is false has moved the burden without anyone noticing; restate who made the claim. The third is false precision: the standards describe degrees of confidence and courts do not put numbers on them. The percentages in the figure are a working aid for a team, and the judgment behind them still needs saying in words.

When to use something else

  • Toulmin Model. When the work is laying out the argument itself: the claim, the grounds, the warrant, and the rebuttals.
  • Bayesian Updating. When evidence arrives in pieces and the question is how much each one should move the confidence.
  • One-Way and Two-Way Doors. When the main question is whether the action can be undone, which sets how much proof it needs.

Where it sits in SOLVE eX

Go to the source

  • A Treatise on the System of Evidence in Trials at Common Law, Little, Brown, 1904
  • Handbook of the Law of Evidence, 1954

Back to the catalog