Grew from James W. Culliton's marketer as a mixer of ingredients (The Management of Marketing Costs, 1948), named the marketing mix by Neil H. Borden (The Concept of the Marketing Mix, 1964), cut to four Ps by E. Jerome McCarthy (Basic Marketing, 1960), and spread by Philip Kotler (Marketing Management, 1967).
Lays out a market offer as four linked decisions (product, price, place, and promotion) and checks that each one fits the others and the customer segment.
Four launch decisions for a premium dog food, checked against each other
It opens on the plan as four teams wrote it, and the lines under the rows flag the pairs that clash. Pick one option per row until the four fit each other and the buyer: an owner who takes the vet's advice and will pay for it. Illustrative.
Product
Price, 24-pound bag
Place
Promotion
- No clash flagged, but the four do not yet make one premium offer: check each against the buyer.Price against place: an $89 bag on a club pallet sits beside one at half the price, among shoppers there for the lowest unit cost.Promotion against product: coupons teach owners to wait for a deal on a food whose claim is that it is worth more.Price against product: nothing in the bag justifies twice the market leader's price.Price against product: the recipe costs more to make, and a low price makes owners doubt the vet's claim.Place against product: vets will not recommend an ordinary food, and the shelf there needs a reason.Promotion against product: vets will not hand out a food they have no reason to prefer.The four agree: a product with a reason to cost more, a price that signals it, shelves where owners take advice, and samples from the people they take it from.
- No clash flagged, but the four do not yet make one premium offer: check each against the buyer.Price against place: an $89 bag on a club pallet sits beside one at half the price, among shoppers there for the lowest unit cost.Promotion against product: coupons teach owners to wait for a deal on a food whose claim is that it is worth more.Price against product: nothing in the bag justifies twice the market leader's price.Price against product: the recipe costs more to make, and a low price makes owners doubt the vet's claim.Place against product: vets will not recommend an ordinary food, and the shelf there needs a reason.Promotion against product: vets will not hand out a food they have no reason to prefer.The four agree: a product with a reason to cost more, a price that signals it, shelves where owners take advice, and samples from the people they take it from.
- No clash flagged, but the four do not yet make one premium offer: check each against the buyer.Price against place: an $89 bag on a club pallet sits beside one at half the price, among shoppers there for the lowest unit cost.Promotion against product: coupons teach owners to wait for a deal on a food whose claim is that it is worth more.Price against product: nothing in the bag justifies twice the market leader's price.Price against product: the recipe costs more to make, and a low price makes owners doubt the vet's claim.Place against product: vets will not recommend an ordinary food, and the shelf there needs a reason.Promotion against product: vets will not hand out a food they have no reason to prefer.The four agree: a product with a reason to cost more, a price that signals it, shelves where owners take advice, and samples from the people they take it from.
- Price against place: an $89 bag on a club pallet sits beside one at half the price, among shoppers there for the lowest unit cost. (price: $89, place: Discount warehouse clubs)
- Promotion against product: coupons teach owners to wait for a deal on a food whose claim is that it is worth more. (prod: Vet-formulated recipe, promo: Coupons in the paper)
- Price against product: nothing in the bag justifies twice the market leader's price. (prod: Standard kibble, price: $89)
- Price against product: the recipe costs more to make, and a low price makes owners doubt the vet's claim. (prod: Vet-formulated recipe, price: $39)
- Place against product: vets will not recommend an ordinary food, and the shelf there needs a reason. (prod: Standard kibble, place: Vet clinics, pet stores)
- Promotion against product: vets will not hand out a food they have no reason to prefer. (prod: Standard kibble, promo: Samples from vets)
- The four agree: a product with a reason to cost more, a price that signals it, shelves where owners take advice, and samples from the people they take it from. (prod: Vet-formulated recipe, price: $89, place: Vet clinics, pet stores, promo: Samples from vets)
An example
A pet food maker was launching a premium dog food developed with veterinary nutritionists, and four teams had each planned one part of the launch. Product had the recipe and the bag. Finance had set the price at $89 for a 24-pound bag, about twice the market leader. Sales had won a listing with a chain of discount warehouse clubs, and marketing had booked newspaper coupons.
The general manager put the four plans on one page and read them against each other and against the buyer they were for: an owner who takes the vet's advice and will pay for it. Two pairs clashed. An $89 bag would sit on a club pallet next to one at half the price, among shoppers there for the lowest unit cost. And coupons would teach owners to wait for a deal on a food whose whole claim was that it was worth more.
The launch moved to vet clinics and independent pet stores, and the coupon budget paid for samples handed out by vets.
Why it works
Price, product, channel, and message are often decided by different people on different schedules, and each decision can look right on its own. The customer meets them all at once. A premium recipe, a premium price, a discount shelf, and a coupon add up to a confusing offer, and the weakest element sets what the buyer believes.
Laying the four decisions side by side forces the question each team skips: does my choice fit the other three, and the buyer we are aiming at? The method's value is in the checking of pairs. Most launch problems sit between the decisions: a price the channel undercuts, or a message the product cannot back up. Those show only when the four are read together.
The thinking behind it
Neil H. Borden Neil H. Borden, a Harvard Business School professor of advertising, is credited with coining the term marketing mix, which he used from the late 1940s and in his 1953 presidential address to the American Marketing Association, and wrote up in The Concept of the Marketing Mix (1964). He borrowed the image from his colleague James W. Culliton, whose 1948 study of marketing costs described the executive as a mixer of ingredients. Borden's own mix listed twelve elements.
E. Jerome McCarthy E. Jerome McCarthy, a marketing professor, reduced the marketing mix to four Ps, product, price, place, and promotion, in his textbook Basic Marketing: A Managerial Approach (1960). His four headings replaced Borden's longer list of twelve elements, and they are the form of the mix most managers know today. The idea of a mix itself goes back to Culliton and Borden at Harvard.
Philip Kotler Philip Kotler, a marketing professor, made the marketing mix, organized as the four Ps of product, price, place, and promotion, the standard frame of marketing teaching through his textbook Marketing Management: Analysis, Planning, and Control (1967). The credit for each part is distinct: Kotler popularized the four Ps, McCarthy proposed them in 1960, and Borden coined the name of the mix they belong to.
How to run it
- Name the buyer first. Describe the segment the offer is for, in terms of what they value and where they shop.
- Define the product. Write what is offered, its features and quality, and the reason it is worth buying.
- Set the price and terms. Give the list price, discounts, and payment terms, and what the price signals.
- Choose the channels. Name where the buyer will find it and who stands beside it on the shelf or the page.
- Plan the promotion. Say how the buyer will hear of it, from whom, and with what message.
- Check every pair. Read each of the four against the other three, and mark any pair that undercuts another.
- Check all four against the buyer. Ask whether this buyer, meeting all four at once, would believe the offer.
Where it goes wrong
Each team sets its own P and nobody reads them together. The mix looks complete on paper and confuses the buyer in the store. Put all four on one page before any is final, and have one owner sign the whole.
The biggest account sets the channel. A listing that brings volume is hard to refuse, even when its shoppers are the wrong buyers for the product. Ask who shops there and what they are looking for before taking the listing.
The mix is checked against the company's goals and not the buyer's. A price that meets the margin target may still be one the segment will not pay. Test the four with real buyers, in the places they shop.
When to use something else
- Jobs to Be Done. When the offer itself is uncertain because the team does not yet know what job the buyer is hiring the product to do.
- Blue Ocean Strategy Canvas. When the aim is to stand apart from rivals by raising, cutting, and dropping the factors the industry competes on.
- AIDA. When the work is the promotion alone: how a message moves a buyer from noticing to acting.
Where it sits in SOLVE eX
Go to the source
- The Management of Marketing Costs, Harvard Business School, 1948
- The Concept of the Marketing Mix, Journal of Advertising Research, 1964
- Basic Marketing: A Managerial Approach, Richard D. Irwin, 1960
- Marketing Management: Analysis, Planning, and Control, 1967