Thinking Tools4.4 Refining Ideas Into Practical SolutionsAlso known as Desk Crit, Studio Critique
From the studio critique of architecture and design schools, studied by Donald Schön (The Design Studio, 1985) and set out for product teams by Adam Connor and Aaron Irizarry (Discussing Design, 2015).
Runs feedback on work in progress in fixed turns, the maker stating intent and questions, then each reviewer describing, diagnosing, and suggesting, producing usable critique without ego fights.
Eight remarks from one checkout review, sorted by what each one does
The designer's goal: fewer shoppers quitting at the payment step. A useful remark describes what is there, diagnoses it against that goal, or suggests a change tied to the diagnosis; a reaction with no goal behind it is taste. One remark is placed as an example. Select each other remark, then the column it belongs in, and show the sort to compare. Illustrative.
Items (select one, then a box)
Not placedPlacedTasteDescribeDiagnoseSuggest
Not placedPlacedTasteDescribeDiagnoseSuggest
Not placedPlacedTasteDescribeDiagnoseSuggest
Not placedPlacedTasteDescribeDiagnoseSuggest
Not placedPlacedTasteDescribeDiagnoseSuggest
Not placedPlacedTasteDescribeDiagnoseSuggest
Not placedPlacedTasteDescribeDiagnoseSuggest
Not placedPlacedTasteDescribeDiagnoseSuggest
Remarks
The review
Taste
Describe
Diagnose
Suggest
ReactsDescribesDiagnosesSuggests
What the remark does
Promo box sits on top. "The promo code box is above the order total, and it's the first field on the page."Not placed yet.Promo box sits on top. "The promo code box is above the order total, and it's the first field on the page."Taste: A reaction tied to no goal. Ask the reviewer which goal it bears on; if none, the designer can let it go.Promo box sits on top. "The promo code box is above the order total, and it's the first field on the page."Describe: What the reviewer sees, stated so the designer can confirm it. It makes sure everyone is looking at the same thing.A plain account of the layout, with no judgment yet. The designer can say yes, that is what she meant.Promo box sits on top. "The promo code box is above the order total, and it's the first field on the page."Diagnose: Whether what is there helps or hurts the stated goal, and why. This is the critique the designer came for.Promo box sits on top. "The promo code box is above the order total, and it's the first field on the page."Suggest: A change that follows from a diagnosis. Offered last, so the designer can weigh it against the problem it answers.I don't love the green. "Honestly, I just don't love the green."Not placed yet.I don't love the green. "Honestly, I just don't love the green."Taste: A reaction tied to no goal. Ask the reviewer which goal it bears on; if none, the designer can let it go.A preference with no goal behind it. Asked which goal it bears on, the reviewer had none.I don't love the green. "Honestly, I just don't love the green."Describe: What the reviewer sees, stated so the designer can confirm it. It makes sure everyone is looking at the same thing.I don't love the green. "Honestly, I just don't love the green."Diagnose: Whether what is there helps or hurts the stated goal, and why. This is the critique the designer came for.I don't love the green. "Honestly, I just don't love the green."Suggest: A change that follows from a diagnosis. Offered last, so the designer can weigh it against the problem it answers.Promo box causes detours. "A code box at the top sends people off to search for codes, which works against fewer quits."Not placed yet.Promo box causes detours. "A code box at the top sends people off to search for codes, which works against fewer quits."Taste: A reaction tied to no goal. Ask the reviewer which goal it bears on; if none, the designer can let it go.Promo box causes detours. "A code box at the top sends people off to search for codes, which works against fewer quits."Describe: What the reviewer sees, stated so the designer can confirm it. It makes sure everyone is looking at the same thing.Promo box causes detours. "A code box at the top sends people off to search for codes, which works against fewer quits."Diagnose: Whether what is there helps or hurts the stated goal, and why. This is the critique the designer came for.Ties what is there to the goal and says why it hurts. This is the remark she needed.Promo box causes detours. "A code box at the top sends people off to search for codes, which works against fewer quits."Suggest: A change that follows from a diagnosis. Offered last, so the designer can weigh it against the problem it answers.Put promo behind a link. "Hide the code box behind a 'Have a code?' link under the total."Not placed yet.Put promo behind a link. "Hide the code box behind a 'Have a code?' link under the total."Taste: A reaction tied to no goal. Ask the reviewer which goal it bears on; if none, the designer can let it go.Put promo behind a link. "Hide the code box behind a 'Have a code?' link under the total."Describe: What the reviewer sees, stated so the designer can confirm it. It makes sure everyone is looking at the same thing.Put promo behind a link. "Hide the code box behind a 'Have a code?' link under the total."Diagnose: Whether what is there helps or hurts the stated goal, and why. This is the critique the designer came for.Put promo behind a link. "Hide the code box behind a 'Have a code?' link under the total."Suggest: A change that follows from a diagnosis. Offered last, so the designer can weigh it against the problem it answers.A change that answers the diagnosis about detours, offered after it.Shipping cost shows last. "Shipping cost first appears on the final step, after the card details."Not placed yet.Shipping cost shows last. "Shipping cost first appears on the final step, after the card details."Taste: A reaction tied to no goal. Ask the reviewer which goal it bears on; if none, the designer can let it go.Shipping cost shows last. "Shipping cost first appears on the final step, after the card details."Describe: What the reviewer sees, stated so the designer can confirm it. It makes sure everyone is looking at the same thing.A fact about the flow. Everyone now sees where the cost appears.Shipping cost shows last. "Shipping cost first appears on the final step, after the card details."Diagnose: Whether what is there helps or hurts the stated goal, and why. This is the critique the designer came for.Shipping cost shows last. "Shipping cost first appears on the final step, after the card details."Suggest: A change that follows from a diagnosis. Offered last, so the designer can weigh it against the problem it answers.Late cost, late surprise. "A cost that appears only at the last step is a surprise, and surprises at payment are when people quit."Not placed yet.Late cost, late surprise. "A cost that appears only at the last step is a surprise, and surprises at payment are when people quit."Taste: A reaction tied to no goal. Ask the reviewer which goal it bears on; if none, the designer can let it go.Late cost, late surprise. "A cost that appears only at the last step is a surprise, and surprises at payment are when people quit."Describe: What the reviewer sees, stated so the designer can confirm it. It makes sure everyone is looking at the same thing.Late cost, late surprise. "A cost that appears only at the last step is a surprise, and surprises at payment are when people quit."Diagnose: Whether what is there helps or hurts the stated goal, and why. This is the critique the designer came for.Links the late shipping cost to the quitting the goal is about.Late cost, late surprise. "A cost that appears only at the last step is a surprise, and surprises at payment are when people quit."Suggest: A change that follows from a diagnosis. Offered last, so the designer can weigh it against the problem it answers.Shipping on the cart. "Estimate shipping on the cart page from the zip code."Not placed yet.Shipping on the cart. "Estimate shipping on the cart page from the zip code."Taste: A reaction tied to no goal. Ask the reviewer which goal it bears on; if none, the designer can let it go.Shipping on the cart. "Estimate shipping on the cart page from the zip code."Describe: What the reviewer sees, stated so the designer can confirm it. It makes sure everyone is looking at the same thing.Shipping on the cart. "Estimate shipping on the cart page from the zip code."Diagnose: Whether what is there helps or hurts the stated goal, and why. This is the critique the designer came for.Shipping on the cart. "Estimate shipping on the cart page from the zip code."Suggest: A change that follows from a diagnosis. Offered last, so the designer can weigh it against the problem it answers.A fix for the late surprise, tied to a diagnosis already made.Feels cluttered to me. "It feels cluttered to me somehow."Not placed yet.Feels cluttered to me. "It feels cluttered to me somehow."Taste: A reaction tied to no goal. Ask the reviewer which goal it bears on; if none, the designer can let it go.A feeling with nothing to act on. Asked what in particular, the reviewer pointed at the promo box, which was already diagnosed.Feels cluttered to me. "It feels cluttered to me somehow."Describe: What the reviewer sees, stated so the designer can confirm it. It makes sure everyone is looking at the same thing.Feels cluttered to me. "It feels cluttered to me somehow."Diagnose: Whether what is there helps or hurts the stated goal, and why. This is the critique the designer came for.Feels cluttered to me. "It feels cluttered to me somehow."Suggest: A change that follows from a diagnosis. Offered last, so the designer can weigh it against the problem it answers.
Your sort matched 0 of 8.Your sort matched 1 of 8.Your sort matched 2 of 8.Your sort matched 3 of 8.Your sort matched 4 of 8.Your sort matched 5 of 8.Your sort matched 6 of 8.Your sort matched 7 of 8.Your sort matched 8 of 8.
Taste
A reaction tied to no goal. Ask the reviewer which goal it bears on; if none, the designer can let it go.
Describe
What the reviewer sees, stated so the designer can confirm it. It makes sure everyone is looking at the same thing.
Diagnose
Whether what is there helps or hurts the stated goal, and why. This is the critique the designer came for.
Suggest
A change that follows from a diagnosis. Offered last, so the designer can weigh it against the problem it answers.
The sort
Promo box sits on top: Describe. A plain account of the layout, with no judgment yet. The designer can say yes, that is what she meant.
I don't love the green: Taste. A preference with no goal behind it. Asked which goal it bears on, the reviewer had none.
Promo box causes detours: Diagnose. Ties what is there to the goal and says why it hurts. This is the remark she needed.
Put promo behind a link: Suggest. A change that answers the diagnosis about detours, offered after it.
Shipping cost shows last: Describe. A fact about the flow. Everyone now sees where the cost appears.
Late cost, late surprise: Diagnose. Links the late shipping cost to the quitting the goal is about.
Shipping on the cart: Suggest. A fix for the late surprise, tied to a diagnosis already made.
Feels cluttered to me: Taste. A feeling with nothing to act on. Asked what in particular, the reviewer pointed at the promo box, which was already diagnosed.
An example
A designer at an online pet-supply retailer brought a checkout redesign to a forty-minute critique with four colleagues. Earlier reviews of her work had produced a pile of opinions about colors and a long debate about the logo.
She opened with the brief: a third of carts were abandoned at payment, and the redesign aimed to cut that. Then she asked two questions. Did the shipping step read clearly? Did the promo code box distract? Each reviewer took a turn, describing what they saw, then judging it against the goal, then suggesting. One noticed that shipping cost first appeared after the card details and said a surprise at that step is when people quit. Another said the code box at the top sent shoppers off to hunt for codes. A comment about disliking the green was set aside when its author could not tie it to the goal.
She left with two changes: a shipping estimate on the cart page and the code box behind a link. In a two-week test, abandonment at payment fell from 31 to 26 percent.
Why it works
Open feedback fails because reviewers answer different questions: one reacts to taste, another redesigns the page, a third spots the real problem, and nothing tells the maker which is which. Fixing the turns and the order makes each remark answer the same question, whether this works for the stated goal.
The brief does the heavy lifting. Once the goal is on the table, a reaction has to be tied to it or it carries no weight, so arguments about preference end quickly. Describing before diagnosing means everyone agrees on what is there before arguing about whether it works. Suggesting last ties each fix to a diagnosis the maker has already heard, so she can judge whether the fix answers the problem. And the maker's silence while reviewers speak keeps her listening instead of defending.
The thinking behind it
Donald Schön Donald Schön, an MIT philosopher of professional practice, described how professionals reflect in action, thinking while they work, in The Reflective Practitioner (1983), and he used the architecture studio critique as a model of it: a student's design worked over in talk with a master. The Design Studio (1985), published by RIBA, examines the studio's traditions and potentials. The format on this page descends from that studio practice, which has no single author.
Adam Connor Adam Connor, a design director at the consultancy Mad*Pow, wrote Discussing Design (2015) with Aaron Irizarry. The book treats critique as analysis of a design against its objectives, distinct from a gut reaction and from a directive telling the designer what to do. It sets out how to give critique, how to receive it, and how to facilitate a session, and its subtitle frames critique as a way to improve communication and collaboration on a team.
How to run it
Set the frame. Fix the time, the reviewers, and one ground rule: every remark ties to the brief.
State the brief and the questions. The maker gives the goal, the constraints, and two or three questions she wants answered.
Take turns, one reviewer at a time. Each reviewer speaks in full before the next begins, so no one piles on.
Describe, then diagnose, then suggest. Say what you see, then whether it serves the goal and why, then what you would change.
Send taste back to the goal. When a remark is a preference, the facilitator asks which goal it bears on.
Keep the maker listening. She may ask what a reviewer meant, but does not explain or defend.
Close with her take. The maker says which remarks she will act on, and which she will not.
Where it goes wrong
The brief is skipped or vague. Without a stated goal, every reviewer substitutes their own, and the session reverts to taste. If the maker cannot say in one sentence what the work is for, the critique should wait.
Reviewers jump straight to solutions. A suggestion without a diagnosis asks the maker to adopt a fix for a problem she has not heard, and it hides disagreements about what the problem is. Ask the reviewer what the suggestion is solving.
The maker defends. Each explanation teaches reviewers that critique costs her something, and the next remarks get softer. Have her write things down instead, and answer at the end if at all.
When to use something else
Critical Response Process. When the work is early or personal and the maker needs to steer what feedback she gets, opinions coming only by permission.
Red Teaming. When the work is a plan that must survive an adversary, and the job is to attack it, not to improve it.