Critical Response Process

Thinking Tools4.4 Refining Ideas Into Practical SolutionsAlso known as Liz Lerman's Critical Response Process

Developed by Liz Lerman at Dance Exchange (Toward a Process for Critical Response, 1993) and written up with John Borstel (Liz Lerman's Critical Response Process, 2003).

A four-stage feedback protocol: responders say what was meaningful, the maker asks questions, responders ask neutral questions, and opinions come only with the maker's permission.

Feedback on a draft plan, in the four stages and their order

A director shows peers her draft plan for a night nursing service. At each turn, pick the line that belongs at that stage; the other line is a common way the order breaks. The reply shows what each one does to the session. Illustrative.

Responders

Maker

Responders

Maker

Select a stage to read it, or play the sequence.The draft. A home-health agency's director walks five peers through a fourteen-slide draft: nurses on call overnight in two counties, priced per visit.Statements of meaning. Responders say what was meaningful, surprising, or memorable in the work. Pick the first line.Pick a move to see the reply.That's the reason I started on this. Good, it came through.In order: it tells her what is working, so she knows what to protect.Okay. I guess we're doing the numbers first.An opinion in stage 1: the session is now about the critic's concern, not her questions.The maker's questions. The maker asks about what she wants to know, and responders answer only that. Pick her question.Pick a move to see the reply.Well, the pricing, the branding, the second county, and the slide order...Too open: it invites every opinion at once, and her own questions never get asked.Not to me. I thought the second nurse was a backup.In order: a specific question, and the answer is a fix she can make.Neutral questions. Responders ask questions with no opinion inside them, to learn what she intended. Pick the question.Pick a move to see the reply.Both counties discharge patients through one hospital, so one referral desk covers both.Neutral: it draws out reasoning the slides never showed.I suppose. Should I cut one?An opinion dressed as a question: she starts defending, or folds.Her reasoning. The neutral question surfaced the reason for the scope. The responder who doubted it now knows why it is there.Opinions, by permission. Responders may now give opinions, each one only after asking whether she wants it. Pick the line.Pick a move to see the reply.That's a different service. Mine was night visits.Unasked: three opinions she did not request, one of them a redesign.Yes, that one I want.In order: she chose to hear it, so she will use it.What she takes. She leaves with two fixes she asked for, the staffing slide and the price, and declines a note on the service's name.

Lines in order: 0 of 4Lines in order: 1 of 4Lines in order: 2 of 4Lines in order: 3 of 4Lines in order: 4 of 4

  1. The draft (Maker). A home-health agency's director walks five peers through a fourteen-slide draft: nurses on call overnight in two counties, priced per visit.
  2. Statements of meaning (Responders). Responders say what was meaningful, surprising, or memorable in the work. Pick the first line.
    • What stayed with me: the families who call 911 at 2 a.m. because nobody else answers. That's the reason I started on this. Good, it came through. In order: it tells her what is working, so she knows what to protect.
    • Honestly, the numbers don't work below 300 patients. Okay. I guess we're doing the numbers first. An opinion in stage 1: the session is now about the critic's concern, not her questions.
  3. The maker's questions (Maker). The maker asks about what she wants to know, and responders answer only that. Pick her question.
    • So, overall, what did everyone think? Well, the pricing, the branding, the second county, and the slide order... Too open: it invites every opinion at once, and her own questions never get asked.
    • Did the staffing slide make it clear why each shift needs two nurses? Not to me. I thought the second nurse was a backup. In order: a specific question, and the answer is a fix she can make.
  4. Neutral questions (Responders). Responders ask questions with no opinion inside them, to learn what she intended. Pick the question.
    • What led you to start in two counties at once? Both counties discharge patients through one hospital, so one referral desk covers both. Neutral: it draws out reasoning the slides never showed.
    • Wouldn't it be safer to start in one county? I suppose. Should I cut one? An opinion dressed as a question: she starts defending, or folds.
  5. Her reasoning (Maker). The neutral question surfaced the reason for the scope. The responder who doubted it now knows why it is there.
  6. Opinions, by permission (Responders). Responders may now give opinions, each one only after asking whether she wants it. Pick the line.
    • Here's what I'd change: one county, a monthly fee, and a new name. That's a different service. Mine was night visits. Unasked: three opinions she did not request, one of them a redesign.
    • I have an opinion about the per-visit price. Do you want it? Yes, that one I want. In order: she chose to hear it, so she will use it.
  7. What she takes (Maker). She leaves with two fixes she asked for, the staffing slide and the price, and declines a note on the service's name.

An example

A home-health agency's director had a draft plan for an overnight nursing service and two weeks before it went to her board. The last time she had shown a draft to peers, the first comment was about pricing and the hour never left it.

This time a colleague facilitated, and the five peers kept to the order. They opened with what had struck them: the slide on families who call emergency services at 2 a.m. because no one else picks up. She asked her own questions, the first about whether the staffing slide explained why each shift needs two nurses (it did not). They asked neutral questions, and one drew out why she had chosen two counties at once: both discharge through one hospital, so a single referral desk covers them. Only then did anyone offer an opinion, each asked for first.

She took two of the four opinions offered. The board version had a rebuilt staffing slide, a new price, and the same two counties.

Why it works

Feedback usually starts with the critic's agenda, and the first opinion sets the topic for the rest of the session. The process reverses who steers. Starting with what was meaningful tells the maker what works, so it survives the revision, and lowers the guard she brings to everything after. Letting her ask first puts her real doubts on the table before anyone else's.

The neutral-question stage does the hardest work. A responder who has to ask without an opinion inside the question often learns the reason behind a choice that looked like a mistake, and the opinion dissolves. The opinions that survive to the last stage are fewer and better, and because the maker agreed to hear each one, she listens to it as advice, not as an attack.

The thinking behind it

Liz Lerman Liz Lerman, a choreographer, founded the Dance Exchange in 1976 and devised the Critical Response Process in the early 1990s as a way to give and receive useful feedback on work still being made. She first described it in Toward a Process for Critical Response (1993). The method's four steps, statements of meaning, the artist's questions, neutral questions, and permissioned opinions, were made for creative work still in progress, at a stage when the artist can act on what she hears.

John Borstel John Borstel, Liz Lerman's long-term collaborator, co-wrote both books on the process. The first, a short primer published by the Dance Exchange in 2003, set out the four steps for work well beyond dance, or in the words of its subtitle, from dance to dessert. The second, Critique Is Creative: The Critical Response Process in Theory and Action (2022), from Wesleyan University Press, is a study of the process, the ideas under each step as well as the practice of running it.

How to run it

  1. Name the roles. Pick a maker, a few responders, and a facilitator whose only job is to keep the order.
  2. Show the work. The maker presents the draft as it stands, without apologizing for what is unfinished.
  3. Start with meaning. Each responder says what struck them, specifically: a slide, a phrase, a number.
  4. Let the maker ask. She asks what she wants to know, and responders answer only that question.
  5. Ask neutral questions. Responders ask about intent, and the facilitator stops any question with an opinion folded inside it.
  6. Offer opinions by permission. A responder names the topic first, "I have an opinion about the price", and the maker says yes or no.
  7. Close with the maker's take. She says what she will use, which tells responders their time counted.

Where it goes wrong

The most common break is the disguised opinion: "Have you thought about starting smaller?" is a recommendation with a question mark. The maker hears it as one and defends. The facilitator's fix is to ask the responder to rephrase it so it has no answer in it, or to hold it for stage four.

The second is a toothless last stage. Responders who have been kind for three stages can let the real concern go unsaid. The facilitator should ask directly whether anyone is holding an opinion they have not offered.

The third is using it where the work is finished. The process serves a maker who can still change things; on a decision already made, it becomes a polite way to vent.

When to use something else

  • Design Critique. When the work is a product or design judged against stated goals, and reviewers need to diagnose and suggest, not only respond.
  • Murder Board. When the work must survive a hostile audience next week, and gentle feedback would leave its weak points hidden.
  • Six Thinking Hats. When a group needs to look at a proposal from several angles in turn, with no single maker in charge of it.

Where it sits in SOLVE eX

Go to the source

  • Toward a Process for Critical Response, Alternate Roots, Fall 1993, 1993
  • Liz Lerman's Critical Response Process: A Method for Getting Useful Feedback on Anything You Make, from Dance to Dessert, 2003

Back to the catalog