Causal Layered Analysis

Thinking Tools1.3 Framing the SituationAlso known as CLA

Originated by Sohail Inayatullah (Causal Layered Analysis: Poststructuralism as Method, 1998).

Works an issue down through four layers: the headline view, the systems behind it, the worldview that frames those systems, and the myth or metaphor underneath.

Eight things said about a city's traffic, sorted by how deep they go

A transport workshop collected what people said about congestion. Place each statement on its layer, from the headline at the top to the story underneath at the bottom; the deeper the layer, the longer a change there takes and the more it moves. The first statement is placed as an example. Illustrative.

Items (select one, then a box)
  • Not placedPlacedHeadlineSystemsWorldviewMyth and metaphor
  • Not placedPlacedHeadlineSystemsWorldviewMyth and metaphor
  • Not placedPlacedHeadlineSystemsWorldviewMyth and metaphor
  • Not placedPlacedHeadlineSystemsWorldviewMyth and metaphor
  • Not placedPlacedHeadlineSystemsWorldviewMyth and metaphor
  • Not placedPlacedHeadlineSystemsWorldviewMyth and metaphor
  • Not placedPlacedHeadlineSystemsWorldviewMyth and metaphor
  • Not placedPlacedHeadlineSystemsWorldviewMyth and metaphor

Depth

HeadlineSystemsWorldviewMyth and metaphor
Headline
Systems
Worldview
Myth and metaphor
Statements

The congestion debate, by layer

Commutes up 22 minutes. The regional survey: the average commute is 22 minutes longer than five years ago.Not placed yet.Commutes up 22 minutes. The regional survey: the average commute is 22 minutes longer than five years ago.Headline: The official, quantified view: what the news reports and the dashboard tracks. Answers here are quick fixes, such as a new lane.A number on the front page. It names the problem and explains nothing.Commutes up 22 minutes. The regional survey: the average commute is 22 minutes longer than five years ago.Systems: The economic, legal, and physical structures that produce the headline. Answers here are policies, and take years.Commutes up 22 minutes. The regional survey: the average commute is 22 minutes longer than five years ago.Worldview: The beliefs that make those structures look normal and fair. Change here needs argument and new coalitions.Commutes up 22 minutes. The regional survey: the average commute is 22 minutes longer than five years ago.Myth and metaphor: The story or image people feel more than think. Change it and every layer above is rewritten.Gridlock costs $1.2B. A business group's estimate of lost hours, priced and added up.Not placed yet.Gridlock costs $1.2B. A business group's estimate of lost hours, priced and added up.Headline: The official, quantified view: what the news reports and the dashboard tracks. Answers here are quick fixes, such as a new lane.Another headline: a cost with no cause attached.Gridlock costs $1.2B. A business group's estimate of lost hours, priced and added up.Systems: The economic, legal, and physical structures that produce the headline. Answers here are policies, and take years.Gridlock costs $1.2B. A business group's estimate of lost hours, priced and added up.Worldview: The beliefs that make those structures look normal and fair. Change here needs argument and new coalitions.Gridlock costs $1.2B. A business group's estimate of lost hours, priced and added up.Myth and metaphor: The story or image people feel more than think. Change it and every layer above is rewritten.Zoning: homes far off. Most new housing is permitted only on the edge of the region, far from jobs.Not placed yet.Zoning: homes far off. Most new housing is permitted only on the edge of the region, far from jobs.Headline: The official, quantified view: what the news reports and the dashboard tracks. Answers here are quick fixes, such as a new lane.Zoning: homes far off. Most new housing is permitted only on the edge of the region, far from jobs.Systems: The economic, legal, and physical structures that produce the headline. Answers here are policies, and take years.A rule that produces long trips every morning, whatever anyone believes.Zoning: homes far off. Most new housing is permitted only on the edge of the region, far from jobs.Worldview: The beliefs that make those structures look normal and fair. Change here needs argument and new coalitions.Zoning: homes far off. Most new housing is permitted only on the edge of the region, far from jobs.Myth and metaphor: The story or image people feel more than think. Change it and every layer above is rewritten.Parking is free at work. Nine in ten offices give staff a free space.Not placed yet.Parking is free at work. Nine in ten offices give staff a free space.Headline: The official, quantified view: what the news reports and the dashboard tracks. Answers here are quick fixes, such as a new lane.Parking is free at work. Nine in ten offices give staff a free space.Systems: The economic, legal, and physical structures that produce the headline. Answers here are policies, and take years.A price set at zero for driving, built into leases and benefits.Parking is free at work. Nine in ten offices give staff a free space.Worldview: The beliefs that make those structures look normal and fair. Change here needs argument and new coalitions.Parking is free at work. Nine in ten offices give staff a free space.Myth and metaphor: The story or image people feel more than think. Change it and every layer above is rewritten.Buses stuck in car lanes. Buses share every lane with cars, so they are as slow as the traffic.Not placed yet.Buses stuck in car lanes. Buses share every lane with cars, so they are as slow as the traffic.Headline: The official, quantified view: what the news reports and the dashboard tracks. Answers here are quick fixes, such as a new lane.Buses stuck in car lanes. Buses share every lane with cars, so they are as slow as the traffic.Systems: The economic, legal, and physical structures that produce the headline. Answers here are policies, and take years.A design choice in the street that makes the alternative no faster.Buses stuck in car lanes. Buses share every lane with cars, so they are as slow as the traffic.Worldview: The beliefs that make those structures look normal and fair. Change here needs argument and new coalitions.Buses stuck in car lanes. Buses share every lane with cars, so they are as slow as the traffic.Myth and metaphor: The story or image people feel more than think. Change it and every layer above is rewritten.Roads exist to move cars. Engineers and drivers alike judge a street by how many vehicles it carries.Not placed yet.Roads exist to move cars. Engineers and drivers alike judge a street by how many vehicles it carries.Headline: The official, quantified view: what the news reports and the dashboard tracks. Answers here are quick fixes, such as a new lane.Roads exist to move cars. Engineers and drivers alike judge a street by how many vehicles it carries.Systems: The economic, legal, and physical structures that produce the headline. Answers here are policies, and take years.Roads exist to move cars. Engineers and drivers alike judge a street by how many vehicles it carries.Worldview: The beliefs that make those structures look normal and fair. Change here needs argument and new coalitions.The belief behind the systems: it is why a bus lane reads as taking something away.Roads exist to move cars. Engineers and drivers alike judge a street by how many vehicles it carries.Myth and metaphor: The story or image people feel more than think. Change it and every layer above is rewritten.A yard is a good life. Success means a detached house with a yard and a drive.Not placed yet.A yard is a good life. Success means a detached house with a yard and a drive.Headline: The official, quantified view: what the news reports and the dashboard tracks. Answers here are quick fixes, such as a new lane.A yard is a good life. Success means a detached house with a yard and a drive.Systems: The economic, legal, and physical structures that produce the headline. Answers here are policies, and take years.A yard is a good life. Success means a detached house with a yard and a drive.Worldview: The beliefs that make those structures look normal and fair. Change here needs argument and new coalitions.The belief that makes edge-of-region zoning feel natural and fair.A yard is a good life. Success means a detached house with a yard and a drive.Myth and metaphor: The story or image people feel more than think. Change it and every layer above is rewritten.The car is freedom. The car as independence: going where you want, when you want.Not placed yet.The car is freedom. The car as independence: going where you want, when you want.Headline: The official, quantified view: what the news reports and the dashboard tracks. Answers here are quick fixes, such as a new lane.The car is freedom. The car as independence: going where you want, when you want.Systems: The economic, legal, and physical structures that produce the headline. Answers here are policies, and take years.The car is freedom. The car as independence: going where you want, when you want.Worldview: The beliefs that make those structures look normal and fair. Change here needs argument and new coalitions.The car is freedom. The car as independence: going where you want, when you want.Myth and metaphor: The story or image people feel more than think. Change it and every layer above is rewritten.The image underneath. While it holds, every layer above defends the car.

Your sort matched 0 of 8.Your sort matched 1 of 8.Your sort matched 2 of 8.Your sort matched 3 of 8.Your sort matched 4 of 8.Your sort matched 5 of 8.Your sort matched 6 of 8.Your sort matched 7 of 8.Your sort matched 8 of 8.

Headline
The official, quantified view: what the news reports and the dashboard tracks. Answers here are quick fixes, such as a new lane.
Systems
The economic, legal, and physical structures that produce the headline. Answers here are policies, and take years.
Worldview
The beliefs that make those structures look normal and fair. Change here needs argument and new coalitions.
Myth and metaphor
The story or image people feel more than think. Change it and every layer above is rewritten.

The sort

  • Commutes up 22 minutes: Headline. A number on the front page. It names the problem and explains nothing.
  • Gridlock costs $1.2B: Headline. Another headline: a cost with no cause attached.
  • Zoning: homes far off: Systems. A rule that produces long trips every morning, whatever anyone believes.
  • Parking is free at work: Systems. A price set at zero for driving, built into leases and benefits.
  • Buses stuck in car lanes: Systems. A design choice in the street that makes the alternative no faster.
  • Roads exist to move cars: Worldview. The belief behind the systems: it is why a bus lane reads as taking something away.
  • A yard is a good life: Worldview. The belief that makes edge-of-region zoning feel natural and fair.
  • The car is freedom: Myth and metaphor. The image underneath. While it holds, every layer above defends the car.

Change the story underneath, and each layer above it is rewritten

The same city under three stories. Select a story to see the headline, the systems, and the worldview that follow from it; the workshop's alternative futures came from the second and third. Illustrative.

The car is freedom

The headline
Commutes are too long
The systems
Widen the highway, add parking downtown, and permit homes wherever land is cheap.
The worldview
A good street moves cars fast, and a good life has a drive.

The street is a shared room

The headline
Too few people can walk to what they need
The systems
Bus lanes on every main road, priced parking, and shops allowed on the ground floor of homes.
The worldview
A good street is one people choose to spend time on.

The city is fifteen minutes wide

The headline
Too many daily needs are a drive away
The systems
Schools, clinics, and groceries permitted in every neighborhood, and homes built near them.
The worldview
Nearness is worth more than speed.

An example

A regional transport authority had widened two highways in ten years, and commutes were longer than ever. The board asked for a workshop that would produce something besides another lane.

The facilitator started where the debate already was: the 22 extra minutes of commuting and the $1.2 billion a business group said gridlock cost each year. Then it worked down. Under the headline sat the systems that produced it: housing permitted only at the edge of the region, free parking at nine offices in ten, and buses stuck in the same lanes as cars. Under those sat the beliefs that made the systems feel fair, that a road exists to move cars and that a good life has a yard and a drive. At the bottom the group named the image holding it all up: the car as freedom.

The second half of the day swapped that image for two others, the street as a shared room and the city fifteen minutes wide, and rewrote each layer above to match. Both went to public consultation beside the highway plan.

Why it works

Most analysis stays on the top two layers, the headline and the systems behind it, because that is where data lives. Solutions found there tend to repeat the problem's own logic: more lanes for a road built to move cars. The tool keeps going down, to the beliefs and the image people hold without stating them, because those decide which solutions look sensible at all.

Each layer moves at a different speed. A headline changes in a news cycle, a system in years, a worldview in a generation. Seeing all four at once shows why a fix at the top keeps failing. Changing the story at the bottom is the one move that rewrites every layer above it, which makes it the source of genuinely different futures.

The thinking behind it

Sohail Inayatullah Sohail Inayatullah, a futures researcher, set out causal layered analysis in Causal Layered Analysis: Poststructuralism as Method (1998, in Futures). It reads an issue at four layers: the litany of headline facts, the social and structural causes, the worldview that frames them, and the myth or metaphor underneath. The layers show that what counts as a problem, and as a solution, depends on what lies beneath it. His later Six Pillars article (2008) places the method within a wider approach to futures thinking.

How to run it

  1. Write the headline view. Collect the official numbers and the phrases used in the news and in meetings, without arguing with them yet.
  2. Map the systems behind it. Name the rules, prices, budgets, and physical designs that produce those numbers year after year.
  3. Name the worldview. Ask what someone would have to believe for these systems to look normal and fair, and write it as a plain sentence.
  4. Find the myth or metaphor. Look for the image or story people feel more than argue, often heard in slogans, jokes, and advertising.
  5. Swap the bottom layer. Choose one or two alternative images that the group can believe in, and state each as briefly as the original.
  6. Rewrite each layer upward. For each new image, write the worldview, the systems, and the headline that would follow from it.
  7. Carry the futures forward. Turn each rewritten stack into a scenario or a policy option, and test it with the people who live with the issue.

Where it goes wrong

The group stops at the systems layer. Discussion of zoning and pricing feels concrete, and the room resists naming beliefs, which feels personal. A facilitator who asks what someone would have to believe for this to seem right usually gets the group down.

The myth is a caricature. When the bottom layer is a cartoon of the other side's view, the people who hold it hear contempt and the work is dismissed. State the image in words its holders would accept.

The new metaphor is a slogan with nothing under it. A pleasant image with no rewritten systems is a campaign, not a future. If the layers above cannot be filled in, choose another image.

When to use something else

  • Futures Triangle. When the question is which forces pull an issue toward which future, instead of how deep its causes run.
  • Iceberg Model. When the issue is a pattern inside one organization and the goal is finding the structure that keeps producing it.
  • Scenario Planning. When the futures need numbers and early signs for a plan, not new stories about the present.

Where it sits in SOLVE eX

Go to the source

  • Causal Layered Analysis: Poststructuralism as Method, Futures, 1998

Back to the catalog