Developed by Sohail Inayatullah (Six Pillars: Futures Thinking for Transforming, 2008).
Maps three forces on a future-facing issue (the weight of history, the push of the present, and the pull of the future) to show which force is winning.
Three forces on a regional newspaper's move to digital: the weight of the past, the push of the present, the pull of a future
Score each force from 1 (faint) to 5 (decisive). Weight holds the paper where it is; push and pull move it. As set, the weight still wins by a little. Find the cheapest change that tips it: a weaker weight, a stronger push, or a clearer picture of the future. Illustrative.
An example
A family-owned regional newspaper had talked about going digital first for six years and was still a print company with a website. The publisher opened a strategy offsite by drawing a triangle and asking the editors and the commercial team to fill its corners.
The weight came easily: presses and trucks the company owned outright, print advertising still bringing in 60 percent of revenue, and a newsroom run to a nightly print deadline. The push was just as clear: readers arriving on phones, and newsprint and delivery costs rising every year. The pull corner stayed nearly empty. Asked what future the paper was moving toward, the room offered only a vague idea of a reader-funded local newsroom and a passing mention of a premium weekend edition.
That was the finding. The weight held slightly more than the push and the faint pull combined, and nothing pulled hard enough to tip it. Day two went to writing a concrete picture of the paper in five years: a membership price, a newsroom size, and print kept for weekends.
Why it works
Most discussions of change list pressures and obstacles and stop there, which leaves a tug of war between the past and the present. The triangle adds the third force people forget: the images of the future that the people involved hold, hope for, or fear. Those images pull, and a future nobody can picture exerts no pull at all.
Separating the forces also changes what to do. Weight is usually expensive to remove: assets, contracts, habits, and identities. Push is mostly outside anyone's control. The pull is the force an organization can strengthen fastest and most cheaply, by making a credible future concrete enough to want. When the triangle shows weight and push deadlocked, the next move is usually to work on the picture, not to push harder.
The thinking behind it
Sohail Inayatullah Sohail Inayatullah, a futures researcher, set out the futures triangle in Six Pillars: Futures Thinking for Transforming (2008), an article in the journal Foresight that builds a futures method around six concepts. The triangle maps a plausible future as the result of three forces: the weight of history, the push of present trends, and the pull of images of the future. He is also known for causal layered analysis, published in Futures (1998), which reads an issue from its headline facts down through its causes and worldview to the myth or metaphor beneath it.
How to run it
- Frame the issue as a question about the future. Ask where this is heading, for example what the paper will be in five years, so the forces have something to act on.
- List the weight. Name what holds things in place: owned assets, contracts, rules, revenue streams, habits, and the identity people defend.
- List the push. Name the trends acting now, such as technology, demographics, costs, and where money is moving, and keep to ones with evidence.
- List the pull. Write down the images of the future people actually hold, hoped for and feared, in their own words.
- Score each force and judge the balance. Rate each item from faint to decisive and see which corner is winning, and by how much.
- Find the cheapest shift. Ask whether weakening one weight, strengthening a push, or sharpening the pull would tip the balance soonest.
- Carry the result into scenarios or a plan. Use the forces as the drivers of scenarios, or as the first items on the change plan.
Where it goes wrong
The common failure is an empty pull corner that nobody notices, because the group treats the exercise as a list of pressures and obstacles. It shows up as a strong debate about push and weight that ends where it started. Ask outright what future people are moving toward, and treat a blank answer as the finding.
A second failure is mistaking a slogan for a pull. A vision statement that no one can picture in operational terms (a price, a size, a customer) pulls nothing. Make it concrete. A third is underrating the weight. Identity and revenue that still pay the bills are heavier than they look on a whiteboard; score them by what it would take to remove them.
When to use something else
- Force Field Analysis. When the change is already defined and the work is weakening the forces against it, with no question about which future to pursue.
- Causal Layered Analysis. When the issue needs digging below its trends into the worldviews and metaphors that hold it in place.
- Scenario Planning. When several futures are plausible and the organization needs plans that hold up across them.
Where it sits in SOLVE eX
Go to the source
- Six Pillars: Futures Thinking for Transforming, Foresight 10(1), 2008