Scenario Planning

Thinking Tools3.4 Facts About the FutureAlso known as Shell Scenario Method, Scenario Analysis

Developed by Herman Kahn (The Year 2000, with Anthony J. Wiener, 1967), Pierre Wack at Shell (Scenarios: Uncharted Waters Ahead, 1985), and Peter Schwartz (The Art of the Long View, 1991).

Builds a small set of distinct, internally consistent futures from the two most uncertain forces, then tests a strategy against each of them.

Six forces that will decide whether a regional airline's jet order pays off

First move: select a force, then the box for how much it matters and how uncertain it is. Only the two in the top right become the scenario axes; the next figure crosses them. Show the sort to compare yours. Illustrative.

Items (select one, then a box)
  • Not placedPlacedScenario axesSame in every futureWatch itSet it aside
  • Not placedPlacedScenario axesSame in every futureWatch itSet it aside
  • Not placedPlacedScenario axesSame in every futureWatch itSet it aside
  • Not placedPlacedScenario axesSame in every futureWatch itSet it aside
  • Not placedPlacedScenario axesSame in every futureWatch itSet it aside
  • Not placedPlacedScenario axesSame in every futureWatch itSet it aside

Impact on the airline

LargeSmall
Same in every future
Scenario axes
Set it aside
Watch it
PredictableUncertain

Uncertainty

Jet fuel price.Not placed yet.Jet fuel price.Scenario axes: Large and truly unknown: the strongest two of these become the axes the futures are built on.Moves the cost per seat more than anything else, and nobody can call it five years out.Jet fuel price.Same in every future: Large but predictable: write it into every scenario as a given.Jet fuel price.Watch it: Uncertain but small: track it, and look again if it grows.Jet fuel price.Set it aside: Small and predictable: background detail for the stories.Business travel returns.Not placed yet.Business travel returns.Scenario axes: Large and truly unknown: the strongest two of these become the axes the futures are built on.Decides whether the front cabins fill, and the forecasts disagree by half.Business travel returns.Same in every future: Large but predictable: write it into every scenario as a given.Business travel returns.Watch it: Uncertain but small: track it, and look again if it grows.Business travel returns.Set it aside: Small and predictable: background detail for the stories.Pilot retirements.Not placed yet.Pilot retirements.Scenario axes: Large and truly unknown: the strongest two of these become the axes the futures are built on.Pilot retirements.Same in every future: Large but predictable: write it into every scenario as a given.Large, but the age profile says exactly how many leave each year.Pilot retirements.Watch it: Uncertain but small: track it, and look again if it grows.Pilot retirements.Set it aside: Small and predictable: background detail for the stories.Population of the region.Not placed yet.Population of the region.Scenario axes: Large and truly unknown: the strongest two of these become the axes the futures are built on.Population of the region.Same in every future: Large but predictable: write it into every scenario as a given.Population of the region.Watch it: Uncertain but small: track it, and look again if it grows.Population of the region.Set it aside: Small and predictable: background detail for the stories.Growing slowly and steadily; it shapes the stories but not the choice.A rival's new route.Not placed yet.A rival's new route.Scenario axes: Large and truly unknown: the strongest two of these become the axes the futures are built on.A rival's new route.Same in every future: Large but predictable: write it into every scenario as a given.A rival's new route.Watch it: Uncertain but small: track it, and look again if it grows.May or may not happen, and it touches two routes of thirty.A rival's new route.Set it aside: Small and predictable: background detail for the stories.Airport fee changes.Not placed yet.Airport fee changes.Scenario axes: Large and truly unknown: the strongest two of these become the axes the futures are built on.Airport fee changes.Same in every future: Large but predictable: write it into every scenario as a given.Airport fee changes.Watch it: Uncertain but small: track it, and look again if it grows.Under review, but small next to fuel and demand.Airport fee changes.Set it aside: Small and predictable: background detail for the stories.

Your sort matched 0 of 6.Your sort matched 1 of 6.Your sort matched 2 of 6.Your sort matched 3 of 6.Your sort matched 4 of 6.Your sort matched 5 of 6.Your sort matched 6 of 6.

Scenario axes
Large and truly unknown: the strongest two of these become the axes the futures are built on.
Same in every future
Large but predictable: write it into every scenario as a given.
Watch it
Uncertain but small: track it, and look again if it grows.
Set it aside
Small and predictable: background detail for the stories.

The sort

  • Jet fuel price: Scenario axes. Moves the cost per seat more than anything else, and nobody can call it five years out.
  • Business travel returns: Scenario axes. Decides whether the front cabins fill, and the forecasts disagree by half.
  • Pilot retirements: Same in every future. Large, but the age profile says exactly how many leave each year.
  • Population of the region: Set it aside. Growing slowly and steadily; it shapes the stories but not the choice.
  • A rival's new route: Watch it. May or may not happen, and it touches two routes of thirty.
  • Airport fee changes: Watch it. Under review, but small next to fuel and demand.

The two uncertain forces crossed into four futures, and the signs that point to each

Second move: each box is one future, with how the six-jet plan fares in it. Select a sign the airline might see, then the future it points to. Show the sort to compare yours. Illustrative.

Items (select one, then a box)
  • Not placedPlacedLeisure SkiesBoom YearsShrinking MapPremium Squeeze
  • Not placedPlacedLeisure SkiesBoom YearsShrinking MapPremium Squeeze
  • Not placedPlacedLeisure SkiesBoom YearsShrinking MapPremium Squeeze
  • Not placedPlacedLeisure SkiesBoom YearsShrinking MapPremium Squeeze
  • Not placedPlacedLeisure SkiesBoom YearsShrinking MapPremium Squeeze
  • Not placedPlacedLeisure SkiesBoom YearsShrinking MapPremium Squeeze

Jet fuel price

ExpensiveCheap
Shrinking Map
Premium Squeeze
Leisure Skies
Boom Years
Stays lowComes back

Business travel

Oil falls, events full.Not placed yet.Oil falls, events full.Leisure Skies: Cheap fuel, few business travelers: vacation routes and low fares win. The six new jets fill, at thin margins.Oil falls, events full.Boom Years: Cheap fuel and full front cabins: everyone expands. The six jets pay off, and rivals add seats too.Exercise the option on the next four jets.Oil falls, events full.Shrinking Map: Costly fuel and empty front cabins: thin routes close. The six jets become a burden the airline cannot fill.Oil falls, events full.Premium Squeeze: Costly fuel and strong business demand: fewer flights at higher fares. Smaller, thriftier jets beat the plan's.Cheap fuel, beaches full.Not placed yet.Cheap fuel, beaches full.Leisure Skies: Cheap fuel, few business travelers: vacation routes and low fares win. The six new jets fill, at thin margins.Shift seats to vacation routes and hold the fares down.Cheap fuel, beaches full.Boom Years: Cheap fuel and full front cabins: everyone expands. The six jets pay off, and rivals add seats too.Cheap fuel, beaches full.Shrinking Map: Costly fuel and empty front cabins: thin routes close. The six jets become a burden the airline cannot fill.Cheap fuel, beaches full.Premium Squeeze: Costly fuel and strong business demand: fewer flights at higher fares. Smaller, thriftier jets beat the plan's.Oil falls, offices empty.Not placed yet.Oil falls, offices empty.Leisure Skies: Cheap fuel, few business travelers: vacation routes and low fares win. The six new jets fill, at thin margins.Fly the two jets on leisure routes and let the option wait.Oil falls, offices empty.Boom Years: Cheap fuel and full front cabins: everyone expands. The six jets pay off, and rivals add seats too.Oil falls, offices empty.Shrinking Map: Costly fuel and empty front cabins: thin routes close. The six jets become a burden the airline cannot fill.Oil falls, offices empty.Premium Squeeze: Costly fuel and strong business demand: fewer flights at higher fares. Smaller, thriftier jets beat the plan's.Oil up, video calls stay.Not placed yet.Oil up, video calls stay.Leisure Skies: Cheap fuel, few business travelers: vacation routes and low fares win. The six new jets fill, at thin margins.Oil up, video calls stay.Boom Years: Cheap fuel and full front cabins: everyone expands. The six jets pay off, and rivals add seats too.Oil up, video calls stay.Shrinking Map: Costly fuel and empty front cabins: thin routes close. The six jets become a burden the airline cannot fill.Let the option lapse and close the thinnest routes early.Oil up, video calls stay.Premium Squeeze: Costly fuel and strong business demand: fewer flights at higher fares. Smaller, thriftier jets beat the plan's.Fuel spikes, rivals quit.Not placed yet.Fuel spikes, rivals quit.Leisure Skies: Cheap fuel, few business travelers: vacation routes and low fares win. The six new jets fill, at thin margins.Fuel spikes, rivals quit.Boom Years: Cheap fuel and full front cabins: everyone expands. The six jets pay off, and rivals add seats too.Fuel spikes, rivals quit.Shrinking Map: Costly fuel and empty front cabins: thin routes close. The six jets become a burden the airline cannot fill.Hold cash, and pick up the slots rivals give back.Fuel spikes, rivals quit.Premium Squeeze: Costly fuel and strong business demand: fewer flights at higher fares. Smaller, thriftier jets beat the plan's.Oil up, firms fly again.Not placed yet.Oil up, firms fly again.Leisure Skies: Cheap fuel, few business travelers: vacation routes and low fares win. The six new jets fill, at thin margins.Oil up, firms fly again.Boom Years: Cheap fuel and full front cabins: everyone expands. The six jets pay off, and rivals add seats too.Oil up, firms fly again.Shrinking Map: Costly fuel and empty front cabins: thin routes close. The six jets become a burden the airline cannot fill.Oil up, firms fly again.Premium Squeeze: Costly fuel and strong business demand: fewer flights at higher fares. Smaller, thriftier jets beat the plan's.Swap the option for smaller jets and raise business fares.

Your sort matched 0 of 6.Your sort matched 1 of 6.Your sort matched 2 of 6.Your sort matched 3 of 6.Your sort matched 4 of 6.Your sort matched 5 of 6.Your sort matched 6 of 6.

Leisure Skies
Cheap fuel, few business travelers: vacation routes and low fares win. The six new jets fill, at thin margins.
Boom Years
Cheap fuel and full front cabins: everyone expands. The six jets pay off, and rivals add seats too.
Shrinking Map
Costly fuel and empty front cabins: thin routes close. The six jets become a burden the airline cannot fill.
Premium Squeeze
Costly fuel and strong business demand: fewer flights at higher fares. Smaller, thriftier jets beat the plan's.

The sort

  • Oil falls, events full: Boom Years. Exercise the option on the next four jets.
  • Cheap fuel, beaches full: Leisure Skies. Shift seats to vacation routes and hold the fares down.
  • Oil falls, offices empty: Leisure Skies. Fly the two jets on leisure routes and let the option wait.
  • Oil up, video calls stay: Shrinking Map. Let the option lapse and close the thinnest routes early.
  • Fuel spikes, rivals quit: Shrinking Map. Hold cash, and pick up the slots rivals give back.
  • Oil up, firms fly again: Premium Squeeze. Swap the option for smaller jets and raise business fares.

An example

A regional airline's board was about to approve six new jets on a single forecast: steady fuel prices, and business travel back to its old level within two years. The head of planning asked for six weeks first.

Her team listed the forces that would decide whether the jets paid off and ranked each by impact and by how uncertain it was. Pilot retirements mattered a great deal but were known from the age profile, so they went into every future as a given. Fuel price and the return of business travel were both large and truly unknown, so they became the two axes. Crossing them gave four futures, each written as a short story of the next five years. The six-jet order paid off in one, scraped by in another, and lost money in the other two. The board approved two jets, an option on four more, and a list of signs that would tell them which future was arriving.

Why it works

A single forecast hides its own assumptions, and when it is wrong, the plan built on it fails all at once. Scenarios replace the one forecast with a few futures, each plausible and consistent, chosen to differ on the forces that matter and that nobody can predict. A strategy tested against all of them shows where it is robust, where it is fragile, and what it is betting on without saying so.

The ranking keeps the exercise honest. Forces that are important but predictable go into every scenario, so they cannot pose as uncertainty, and forces that are uncertain but minor stay out, so the futures differ where it counts. The stories make each future vivid enough that people take the unwelcome ones seriously.

The thinking behind it

Herman Kahn Herman Kahn, a RAND Corporation strategist who cofounded the Hudson Institute in 1961, is often named with Pierre Wack as a father of scenario planning. The Year 2000: A Framework for Speculation on the Next Thirty-Three Years (1967), written with Anthony J. Wiener, built alternative futures for the rest of the century: several accounts of what might happen, set side by side.

Pierre Wack Pierre Wack, a French planner at Royal Dutch Shell in London, led its scenario work in the 1970s, when the scenarios helped the company prepare for the oil shocks. He described the practice in a two-part series in the Harvard Business Review in 1985, beginning with Scenarios: Uncharted Waters Ahead. The series told how a planning team inside a large company had used scenarios to get it ready before the shocks arrived.

Peter Schwartz Peter Schwartz led scenario planning at Shell from 1982 and cofounded Global Business Network in 1988. The Art of the Long View (1991) is his practitioner's account of the Shell approach: write a few plausible stories of how the future could unfold, then test decisions against each of them. The book set the approach out for managers well beyond the oil industry.

How to run it

  1. Set the focal question and the horizon. One decision and a date: should we buy six jets for the next five years?
  2. List the forces that shape the answer. Economic, technical, social, political, and competitive; twenty is a good start.
  3. Rank each by impact and by uncertainty. Keep the two questions apart; what matters and what is unknown overlap less than people expect.
  4. Cross the two strongest uncertainties. Pick two large, unknown, and unconnected forces, and give each axis two ends.
  5. Write each future as a story. A page per quadrant, with a name, events in order, and how customers and rivals behave in it.
  6. Test the strategy in each future. Ask how the current plan fares, what it would need, and which moves pay off in every future.
  7. Choose the signs to watch. For each future, name two or three early indicators and who will report them.

Where it goes wrong

The axes are not uncertain enough. Teams pick forces that feel important but are predictable, and the four futures differ only in detail. If one quadrant is plainly the likeliest, the axes are wrong.

One future becomes the official forecast. Leaders pick the scenario they like and plan for it, which undoes the method. Present the futures as equally serious, and judge the strategy by how it does across all of them.

The scenarios are written and shelved. Without signs to watch and a date to review them, the futures become a workshop memory. Name the indicators, give someone the job of watching them, and revisit the plan when one moves.

When to use something else

  • Wind Tunneling. When the scenarios exist and the job is putting several strategic options through each one.
  • Cross-Impact Analysis. When the forces interact, and the question is how one event changes the odds of the others.
  • Three Horizons. When the question is how today's business gives way to an emerging one over time.

Where it sits in SOLVE eX

Go to the source

  • The Year 2000: A Framework for Speculation, 1967
  • Scenarios: Uncharted Waters Ahead, Harvard Business Review, 1985
  • The Art of the Long View, 1991

Back to the catalog