Futures Wheel

Thinking Tools4.3 Crafting Solutions for the Future StateAlso known as Implication Wheel

Originated by Jerome C. Glenn (Futurizing Teaching vs Futures Course, 1972), documented with Theodore J. Gordon (Futures Research Methodology, 2009).

Places a trend or decision at the center of a page and rings it with first-order consequences, then their consequences, working outward to expose ripple effects.

One change at the center, and its ripples out to the third ring

A child-care chain asks what a four-day school week in its county would mean. The change sits at the root; each ring out is what the ring before it causes, tagged welcome, unwelcome, or surprise. Select a box to read the reasoning, and mark the three outer effects you would plan for first. Illustrative.

0 of 3 marked1 of 3 marked2 of 3 marked3 of 3 marked

Select a box to read why it follows, then mark the three outer effects to plan for.A four-day school week. The change at the center: from next fall, public schools in the county close on Fridays and lengthen the other four days.6,000 children home on Fridays. The direct effect everyone sees first.Parents need Friday care. Working parents need somewhere for school-age children one day a week.A Friday program could fill. A school-age Friday program at every center, priced by the day.Friday staffing doubles. Friday rooms need about twice the usual staff, in a market already short of aides.Some parents cut to four days. Parents who can will work four longer days and keep children home on Friday.Fewer five-day enrollments. Toddler siblings move to four-day plans, which earn less per child.Longer school days. The four remaining days run about an hour longer.After-school care shrinks. Pickup moves from 3:00 to 4:00, so after-school sessions lose an hour of billable time.After-care revenue falls a fifth. Shorter sessions at today's prices, unless pricing changes.Teaching jobs gain a day off. A four-day week makes school jobs more attractive to anyone qualified to hold one.Credentialed staff leave for schools. The chain's lead teachers with state certification are exactly who the district now recruits.Wage pressure on lead teachers. Keeping them means closing part of the gap with district pay.District saves on running costs. Fewer days of buses, heating, and cafeterias.Savings could fund free pre-K. The board has already floated spending the savings on pre-K for four-year-olds.Four-year-old rooms empty out. The chain's best-margin rooms face a free competitor within two years.High schoolers free on Fridays. Teenagers have a weekday free for the first time.Teen aides for Friday rooms. Sixteen- and seventeen-year-olds can staff Friday rooms as aides, which eases the staffing problem from the first branch.

An example

A regional child-care chain heard that its county's school board would vote on a four-day school week. The first reaction in the leadership meeting was simple: children home on Fridays, so more demand.

The chief operating officer put the change in the middle of a whiteboard and asked for its direct consequences, then for what each of those would cause. Five first-ring effects came out: children home on Fridays, longer school days, teaching jobs with a day off, savings for the district, and high schoolers free on Fridays. The second and third rings told a different story. Longer days would cut an hour from every after-school session, the district would start recruiting the chain's certified lead teachers, and the board had already floated spending the savings on free pre-K, which would empty the chain's best-margin rooms. The plan that came out covered three things: a priced Friday program staffed partly by teen aides, a retention offer for lead teachers, and a pre-K partnership proposal to the district.

Why it works

First-order effects are the ones everyone names, and decisions get made on them. Most of the risk and the opportunity sits further out, where one consequence meets another and where nobody has looked. The wheel makes the search systematic: every direct effect is asked in turn what it causes, and then the question is asked again one ring further out.

Working in rings keeps the chain of reasoning visible, so each distant effect can be traced back to the change and argued with. Tagging each effect as welcome, unwelcome, or surprising sorts the map into what to exploit, what to guard against, and where the group's assumptions were wrong. A surprise in the third ring is usually the most valuable thing the session produces.

The thinking behind it

Jerome C. Glenn Jerome C. Glenn, a futurist and cofounder and longtime head of the Millennium Project, devised the futures wheel as a graduate student at Antioch in the early 1970s and described it in a 1972 article on futurizing teaching in the journal Social Science Record. The method is to put a change at the center and ring it with its direct consequences, then with the consequences of those, so the knock-on effects appear on the page.

Theodore J. Gordon Theodore J. Gordon, a futurist who worked with Olaf Helmer at RAND on early Delphi forecasting and developed cross-impact analysis with him, was among the founders of the Institute for the Future. With Jerome C. Glenn he edited the Millennium Project's Futures Research Methodology (version 3.0, 2009), the reference work that documents the futures wheel, with Delphi and cross-impact analysis, among the working methods of the field.

How to run it

  1. Write the change in the center. State one trend, decision, or event plainly, with a date if it has one.
  2. Draw the first ring. List five to ten direct consequences, each on its own line from the center.
  3. Ask what each one causes. Draw a second ring of consequences for every first-ring effect, without judging yet.
  4. Push one more ring out where it matters. Extend the branches that touch your business, budget, or people to a third ring.
  5. Tag every effect. Mark each one welcome, unwelcome, or surprising, from your organization's point of view.
  6. Look for crossings. Note where effects from different branches meet or cancel, such as a staffing gap one branch opens and another fills.
  7. Pick the effects to act on. Choose two or three outer effects and give each an owner and a first step.

Where it goes wrong

The rings stop at the obvious. Groups list the first ring and a few second-ring effects and call it done. Require a third ring on every branch that touches money or people.

Every effect is treated as certain. A wheel shows what could follow, and some of its chains are long shots. Mark the links people doubt, and check the ones a plan will rest on.

Only the welcome effects get followed. Teams that hope for the change explore its upside; teams that fear it explore its downside. Assign someone to push the branches the room would rather not.

When to use something else

  • Second-Order Thinking. When one decision needs a quick check of its consequences' consequences, without a full map.
  • Scenario Planning. When several uncertain forces could combine into quite different futures and the plan must hold in each.
  • Cross-Impact Analysis. When the question is how several expected events change one another's likelihood.

Where it sits in SOLVE eX

Go to the source

  • Futurizing Teaching vs Futures Course, Social Science Record, 1972
  • Futures Research Methodology, version 3.0, The Millennium Project, 2009

Back to the catalog