Developed by Thomas C. Schelling (The Strategy of Conflict, 1960).
Identifies the outcome people will converge on without talking, because it stands out by precedent, prominence, or shared expectation, to predict and shape coordination.
Two colleagues lose each other at a trade show with the phone network down
At each of your turns, pick where and when to go. Your colleague is choosing at the same moment, and the reply shows how many of a hundred colleagues in her place would choose the same spot. Round two adds one thing you both heard. Illustrative.
You
Your colleague
You
Your colleague
Times you picked the focal point: 0 of 2Times you picked the focal point: 1 of 2Times you picked the focal point: 2 of 2
- Round one (You). The mobile network is down across the convention center, and you have lost the colleague you are presenting with this afternoon. Neither of you can call. She is asking herself the same question you are.
- Our booth, on the hour Your booth is where you work, but there are 400 booths and she may think you left it. Of 100 colleagues in her place, 19 go here. A private choice: only someone thinking exactly like you finds it.
- The main entrance, at noon The one entrance everyone came through, at the one time of day that stands out. Of 100 colleagues in her place, 47 go here. The focal point: the spot each of you expects the other to expect.
- The registration desk, right away A sensible place, but right away means a different minute to each of you, and the desk fills a whole hall. Of 100 colleagues, 22 go here. A prominent place with no prominent time.
- Her reasoning (Your colleague). She does not ask where she would like to meet. She asks where you would expect her to expect you, and that pushes both of you toward whatever stands out to everyone: the one big entrance, the round hour of noon.
- Round two (You). The network fails again on the third morning. This time you both heard the events lead say at the morning briefing: if the network goes down, meet at the coffee bar beside our booth.
- The main entrance, at noon The first day's answer for strangers. Now that you share a rule, 24 of 100 colleagues in her place go here. The focal point has moved, and this one is stale.
- The booth coffee bar, on the hour Where the briefing said, at the next round hour. Of 100 colleagues in her place, 58 go here. A rule you both heard beats a landmark you can both see.
- The hotel lobby, at 5 pm Where the dinner bus leaves, but that is hours away and she may not wait. Of 100 colleagues, 18 go here. Plausible, and nobody's first expectation.
- Why it moved (Your colleague). A precedent both sides know wins because each knows the other knows it. To steer coordination, make the outcome you want the most obvious one before it is needed: agree on the fallback spot in advance, and it becomes the focal point.
An example
A medical device company sent forty staff to a three-day trade show in a convention center the size of six football fields. On the first morning the mobile network failed for four hours. The team scattered: some waited at the booth, some at registration, a few went back to the hotel, and two client meetings were missed because the presenters could not find each other.
That evening the events lead asked everyone where they had tried to go. Most of the pairs who did find each other had gone to the main entrance at noon without agreeing it: the place that stood out to everyone, at the time that stood out in the day. She used that at the next morning's briefing and gave the team a fallback that would stand out more: if the network fails, meet at the coffee bar beside the booth, at the top of the next hour. When the network failed again on the third day, all but two of the forty were at the coffee bar within the hour.
Why it works
When several outcomes would all work, the hard part is choosing the same one. Without a way to talk, each party tries to predict the other, who is trying to predict them, and the reasoning would go in circles if nothing stood out. Something almost always does: a precedent, a round number, the biggest landmark, the obvious deadline. Each side expects the other to see it, so both choose it.
Knowing this makes coordination predictable. Before a negotiation, a launch, or any moment of lost contact, list what stands out to everyone and expect the parties to land there. It also makes coordination steerable: whoever makes an outcome the most prominent, by naming it first, setting the precedent, or agreeing on a fallback in advance, decides where everyone converges.
The thinking behind it
Thomas C. Schelling Thomas C. Schelling, an American economist who shared the 2005 Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences for work on conflict and cooperation, introduced focal points in The Strategy of Conflict (Harvard University Press, 1960). When people must coordinate without talking, they converge on the option that stands out by precedent, prominence, or shared expectation, each predicting what the others will predict. He also introduced credible commitment, and his segregation models, in Dynamic Models of Segregation (1971) and Micromotives and Macrobehavior (Norton, 1978), showed how mild individual preferences can tip into stark collective patterns.
How to run it
- Confirm it is a coordination problem. Several outcomes would work, and the parties gain most by matching.
- List the candidates that stand out. Precedent, round numbers, the most visible place or date, the default in the contract.
- Ask what each side expects the other to expect. Rank the candidates by how obvious they are to everyone, setting aside what anyone prefers.
- Predict the convergence. Expect the parties at the top candidate unless something new changes what stands out.
- To steer, make the outcome prominent. Name it first, set it as the default, or create the precedent.
- Agree on fallbacks before contact is lost. A rule stated in advance becomes the focal point when it is needed.
- Watch for a moved focal point. A new shared memory or announcement can replace the old landmark overnight.
Where it goes wrong
The first failure is treating a conflict as coordination. Focal points settle problems where any match beats a mismatch; where the parties want different outcomes, the obvious point favors one side, and the other may refuse it. Spot it when one side's gain is the other's loss, and switch to bargaining tools.
The second is assuming that what stands out to one side stands out to everyone. A spot obvious to head office may be invisible to a new team or another culture, so test the candidate with people from the other side. The third is relying on a stale focal point. Once a precedent changes, yesterday's obvious answer strands everyone who still uses it.
When to use something else
- BATNA and ZOPA. When the parties want different outcomes and the question is the range a deal can land in.
- Game Theory. When the situation needs its players, moves, and payoffs laid out before choosing a reasoning tool.
- Nash Equilibrium. When several stable outcomes exist and the task is to find them all before asking which one people will pick.
Where it sits in SOLVE eX
Go to the source
- The Strategy of Conflict, 1960