Moral Imagination

Thinking Tools4.3 Crafting Solutions for the Future State

Rooted in Adam Smith (The Theory of Moral Sentiments, 1759) and Edmund Burke's phrase (Reflections on the Revolution in France, 1790), and developed by Mark Johnson (Moral Imagination, 1993) and, for managers, Patricia Werhane (Moral Imagination and Management Decision-Making, 1999).

Pictures the specific people a decision touches, other framings, and consequences nobody planned for, so ethical issues hidden by a numbers-only view come into sight.

Eight consequences of automating a night shift, placed with the people who carry them

A packaging plant plans to replace its forty-person night shift with an automated line. The business case holds the first consequence, placed as an example. Select each other consequence and place it with the person whose day it changes: each one, in its place, shows the option it brings to light. Illustrative.

Items (select one, then a box)
  • Not placedPlacedThe casePackerSupervisorDiner owner
  • Not placedPlacedThe casePackerSupervisorDiner owner
  • Not placedPlacedThe casePackerSupervisorDiner owner
  • Not placedPlacedThe casePackerSupervisorDiner owner
  • Not placedPlacedThe casePackerSupervisorDiner owner
  • Not placedPlacedThe casePackerSupervisorDiner owner
  • Not placedPlacedThe casePackerSupervisorDiner owner
  • Not placedPlacedThe casePackerSupervisorDiner owner

Consequences

The decision
The case
Packer
Supervisor
Diner owner
The business caseA night packerHer supervisorThe diner owner

Seen by

Saves $2.1M a year. Night wages and overtime, net of the line's lease, come to $2.1 million a year.Not placed yet.Saves $2.1M a year. Night wages and overtime, net of the line's lease, come to $2.1 million a year.The case: The cost frame: what the spreadsheet can see. Necessary, and it was the whole decision until now.True, and the only consequence in the business case as written.Saves $2.1M a year. Night wages and overtime, net of the line's lease, come to $2.1 million a year.Packer: A packer with eleven years on nights. Picture her day before and after the change.Saves $2.1M a year. Night wages and overtime, net of the line's lease, come to $2.1 million a year.Supervisor: The night supervisor, who will carry out the change among people she has worked beside for a decade.Saves $2.1M a year. Night wages and overtime, net of the line's lease, come to $2.1 million a year.Diner owner: The owner of the diner across the road, open at 5 a.m. for the shift change.Payback in 26 months. The automated line pays for itself in twenty-six months.Not placed yet.Payback in 26 months. The automated line pays for itself in twenty-six months.The case: The cost frame: what the spreadsheet can see. Necessary, and it was the whole decision until now.The second number in the case. It sets the pace of everything else.Payback in 26 months. The automated line pays for itself in twenty-six months.Packer: A packer with eleven years on nights. Picture her day before and after the change.Payback in 26 months. The automated line pays for itself in twenty-six months.Supervisor: The night supervisor, who will carry out the change among people she has worked beside for a decade.Payback in 26 months. The automated line pays for itself in twenty-six months.Diner owner: The owner of the diner across the road, open at 5 a.m. for the shift change.Night pay funds daycare. The night premium pays for her daughter's daycare; day shifts pay less, and the day slots are nearly full.Not placed yet.Night pay funds daycare. The night premium pays for her daughter's daycare; day shifts pay less, and the day slots are nearly full.The case: The cost frame: what the spreadsheet can see. Necessary, and it was the whole decision until now.Night pay funds daycare. The night premium pays for her daughter's daycare; day shifts pay less, and the day slots are nearly full.Packer: A packer with eleven years on nights. Picture her day before and after the change.Option it brings to light: keep the night premium for a year for anyone who moves to days.Night pay funds daycare. The night premium pays for her daughter's daycare; day shifts pay less, and the day slots are nearly full.Supervisor: The night supervisor, who will carry out the change among people she has worked beside for a decade.Night pay funds daycare. The night premium pays for her daughter's daycare; day shifts pay less, and the day slots are nearly full.Diner owner: The owner of the diner across the road, open at 5 a.m. for the shift change.No ticket for new jobs. The line creates six technician jobs, and they need a certificate no packer holds.Not placed yet.No ticket for new jobs. The line creates six technician jobs, and they need a certificate no packer holds.The case: The cost frame: what the spreadsheet can see. Necessary, and it was the whole decision until now.No ticket for new jobs. The line creates six technician jobs, and they need a certificate no packer holds.Packer: A packer with eleven years on nights. Picture her day before and after the change.Option: train six packers for the certificate before the line arrives.No ticket for new jobs. The line creates six technician jobs, and they need a certificate no packer holds.Supervisor: The night supervisor, who will carry out the change among people she has worked beside for a decade.No ticket for new jobs. The line creates six technician jobs, and they need a certificate no packer holds.Diner owner: The owner of the diner across the road, open at 5 a.m. for the shift change.She picks who stays. Eight of the forty can move to days, and she is told to choose them.Not placed yet.She picks who stays. Eight of the forty can move to days, and she is told to choose them.The case: The cost frame: what the spreadsheet can see. Necessary, and it was the whole decision until now.She picks who stays. Eight of the forty can move to days, and she is told to choose them.Packer: A packer with eleven years on nights. Picture her day before and after the change.She picks who stays. Eight of the forty can move to days, and she is told to choose them.Supervisor: The night supervisor, who will carry out the change among people she has worked beside for a decade.Option: publish a rule based on seniority and skills, so the choice is not hers alone.She picks who stays. Eight of the forty can move to days, and she is told to choose them.Diner owner: The owner of the diner across the road, open at 5 a.m. for the shift change.Best people leave first. She expects her most experienced packers to find other jobs as soon as the news is out.Not placed yet.Best people leave first. She expects her most experienced packers to find other jobs as soon as the news is out.The case: The cost frame: what the spreadsheet can see. Necessary, and it was the whole decision until now.Best people leave first. She expects her most experienced packers to find other jobs as soon as the news is out.Packer: A packer with eleven years on nights. Picture her day before and after the change.Best people leave first. She expects her most experienced packers to find other jobs as soon as the news is out.Supervisor: The night supervisor, who will carry out the change among people she has worked beside for a decade.Option: announce the training and the day-shift moves on the same day as the change.Best people leave first. She expects her most experienced packers to find other jobs as soon as the news is out.Diner owner: The owner of the diner across the road, open at 5 a.m. for the shift change.Night trade down a third. A third of the diner's takings come from the night crew coming off shift.Not placed yet.Night trade down a third. A third of the diner's takings come from the night crew coming off shift.The case: The cost frame: what the spreadsheet can see. Necessary, and it was the whole decision until now.Night trade down a third. A third of the diner's takings come from the night crew coming off shift.Packer: A packer with eleven years on nights. Picture her day before and after the change.Night trade down a third. A third of the diner's takings come from the night crew coming off shift.Supervisor: The night supervisor, who will carry out the change among people she has worked beside for a decade.Night trade down a third. A third of the diner's takings come from the night crew coming off shift.Diner owner: The owner of the diner across the road, open at 5 a.m. for the shift change.Option: give the diner the plant's breakfast contract for the day shift.Early cook let go. Without the night trade, the owner expects to drop her early cook and open at 7.Not placed yet.Early cook let go. Without the night trade, the owner expects to drop her early cook and open at 7.The case: The cost frame: what the spreadsheet can see. Necessary, and it was the whole decision until now.Early cook let go. Without the night trade, the owner expects to drop her early cook and open at 7.Packer: A packer with eleven years on nights. Picture her day before and after the change.Early cook let go. Without the night trade, the owner expects to drop her early cook and open at 7.Supervisor: The night supervisor, who will carry out the change among people she has worked beside for a decade.Early cook let go. Without the night trade, the owner expects to drop her early cook and open at 7.Diner owner: The owner of the diner across the road, open at 5 a.m. for the shift change.The same option keeps the early cook: the day-shift breakfast order fills the 5 a.m. slot.

Your sort matched 0 of 8.Your sort matched 1 of 8.Your sort matched 2 of 8.Your sort matched 3 of 8.Your sort matched 4 of 8.Your sort matched 5 of 8.Your sort matched 6 of 8.Your sort matched 7 of 8.Your sort matched 8 of 8.

The case
The cost frame: what the spreadsheet can see. Necessary, and it was the whole decision until now.
Packer
A packer with eleven years on nights. Picture her day before and after the change.
Supervisor
The night supervisor, who will carry out the change among people she has worked beside for a decade.
Diner owner
The owner of the diner across the road, open at 5 a.m. for the shift change.

The sort

  • Saves $2.1M a year: The case. True, and the only consequence in the business case as written.
  • Payback in 26 months: The case. The second number in the case. It sets the pace of everything else.
  • Night pay funds daycare: Packer. Option it brings to light: keep the night premium for a year for anyone who moves to days.
  • No ticket for new jobs: Packer. Option: train six packers for the certificate before the line arrives.
  • She picks who stays: Supervisor. Option: publish a rule based on seniority and skills, so the choice is not hers alone.
  • Best people leave first: Supervisor. Option: announce the training and the day-shift moves on the same day as the change.
  • Night trade down a third: Diner owner. Option: give the diner the plant's breakfast contract for the day shift.
  • Early cook let go: Diner owner. The same option keeps the early cook: the day-shift breakfast order fills the 5 a.m. slot.

An example

A packaging plant's business case for an automated line was two numbers: $2.1 million a year saved on the forty-person night shift, and payback in twenty-six months. Before planning the rollout, the operations director wrote one page each for three people the decision would touch: a packer with eleven years on nights, the night supervisor, and the owner of the diner across the road.

The pages turned up what the spreadsheet could not. The packer's night premium paid for her daughter's daycare, and day shifts paid less. The six new technician jobs needed a certificate no packer held. The supervisor would be told to choose which eight of the forty moved to days. A third of the diner's takings came from the crew coming off shift. The plan that went to the board kept the night premium for a year for anyone moving to days, trained six packers as technicians, published a selection rule, and moved the plant's day-shift breakfast order to the diner. Savings in the first year fell to $1.8 million.

Why it works

Most decisions are framed by the numbers that justify them, and the frame decides what counts as a consequence. A cost model sees wages, leases, and payback. It cannot see a daycare bill, a supervisor choosing among friends, or a diner's early cook. Nobody hides those consequences on purpose; the frame simply has no place to put them.

Moral imagination widens the frame by picturing specific people, one at a time, and their actual day before and after the decision. Specific people work where categories do not: "affected employees" has no daycare bill. Once the consequences are visible, so are the options, because each burden suggests a change in how the decision is carried out. The decision may stay the same. Its shape changes, and the people carrying the cost are no longer surprised by it.

The thinking behind it

Adam Smith Adam Smith, the Scottish philosopher best known for The Wealth of Nations, grounded morality in The Theory of Moral Sentiments (1759) in sympathy: our capacity to imagine ourselves in another person's situation. He added the judgment of an imagined impartial spectator, someone who sees our conduct as others would. Both are acts of imagination, and both are older forms of the move this tool makes.

Mark Johnson Mark Johnson, a University of Oregon philosopher of embodied mind, argued in Moral Imagination (1993) that moral reasoning works through metaphor, narrative, and imagined cases more than through fixed rules. On his account, being able to picture how a situation unfolds for the people in it is part of reasoning well about it. Earlier, with George Lakoff, he had argued that ordinary thought is structured by metaphor.

Patricia H. Werhane Patricia H. Werhane, a business ethicist, carried the idea into management in Moral Imagination and Management Decision-Making (1999). She argued that managers fail ethically less often from bad intent than from a narrow mental model of their situation. Moral imagination, in her account, is the ability to step back from the roles and frames one takes for granted, see the situation from the other parties' positions, and imagine alternatives that are both workable and morally justifiable. The phrase itself is usually traced to Edmund Burke's Reflections on the Revolution in France (1790).

How to run it

  1. Write the decision as framed. State the choice and the numbers that justify it, exactly as the business case puts them.
  2. List the people it touches. Name specific roles inside and outside the organization, including those with no voice in the decision.
  3. Pick three to picture. Choose people whose days change most, such as a line worker, the person carrying out the change, and a neighbor.
  4. Write each one's day. Describe a working day for each, before and after, in concrete terms: money, time, choices, relationships.
  5. List what the frame missed. Write down each consequence that appears in the pages but not in the business case.
  6. Turn each consequence into an option. For each burden, name a change in timing, terms, or support that would ease it.
  7. Decide with both pictures. Present the numbers and the people side by side, with the cost of each option priced.

Where it goes wrong

The first failure is imagining a category instead of a person. "Affected employees will be supported" pictures no one, so it surfaces nothing. Write about one packer, with a shift, a bill, and a family.

The second is imagining people and then changing nothing. A list of hardships attached to an unchanged plan reads as cover. If no option came out of the exercise, picture more carefully or name the hard choice openly.

The third is imagining only the sympathetic. The diner owner is easy to picture; the customer who pays more if savings are cut is not. Include at least one person whose interest runs against the people the team feels for.

When to use something else

  • Ethical Matrix. When every group and every value needs laying out side by side in one table.
  • Second-Order Thinking. When the question is what the decision's consequences will cause in turn, over months and years.
  • Veil of Ignorance. When the decision should be judged as if the decider did not know which of the affected people they would be.

Where it sits in SOLVE eX

Go to the source

  • The Theory of Moral Sentiments, 1759
  • Reflections on the Revolution in France, 1790
  • Moral Imagination: Implications of Cognitive Science for Ethics, University of Chicago Press, 1993
  • Moral Imagination and Management Decision-Making, Oxford University Press, 1999

Back to the catalog