Thinking Tools5.3 Validating Impact and ExecutionAlso known as Duty-Based Ethics, Categorical Imperative Test
From Immanuel Kant (Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals, 1785) and W. D. Ross (The Right and the Good, 1930).
Judges an action by the duties and rules it keeps or breaks, testing whether its principle could apply to everyone and whether it uses anyone merely as a means.
Six ways to handle a faulty batch, sorted by the two duty tests
Each plan for 4,000 space heaters with a wiring fault is run through two tests: could every company act on its rule, and does it treat everyone as more than a means to the company's ends. The first plan, selling the stock through before a recall, is placed as an example. Select each other plan and pick its box; only the top-right box is permissible. Illustrative.
Items (select one, then a box)
Not placedPlacedPermissibleFails the universal testFails the respect testFails both tests
Not placedPlacedPermissibleFails the universal testFails the respect testFails both tests
Not placedPlacedPermissibleFails the universal testFails the respect testFails both tests
Not placedPlacedPermissibleFails the universal testFails the respect testFails both tests
Not placedPlacedPermissibleFails the universal testFails the respect testFails both tests
Not placedPlacedPermissibleFails the universal testFails the respect testFails both tests
Treats everyone as more than a means?
YesNo
Fails the universal test
Permissible
Fails both tests
Fails the respect test
NoYes
Could every company act on this rule?
Sell, then recall. Let distributors sell the 2,600 units they hold through the holidays, then announce the recall in January.Not placed yet.Sell, then recall. Let distributors sell the 2,600 units they hold through the holidays, then announce the recall in January.Permissible: Passes both tests. The plan may still cost money; the duty is met.Sell, then recall. Let distributors sell the 2,600 units they hold through the holidays, then announce the recall in January.Fails the universal test: If every company acted on this rule, the rule would undo itself; this test shows the fault most plainly. Impermissible.Sell, then recall. Let distributors sell the 2,600 units they hold through the holidays, then announce the recall in January.Fails the respect test: The rule could hold for every company, but it uses someone as a tool for the company's ends without their agreement; this test shows the fault most plainly. Impermissible.Sell, then recall. Let distributors sell the 2,600 units they hold through the holidays, then announce the recall in January.Fails both tests: Usually a deception: it only works because others assume the honest rule. Impermissible.If every maker hid known hazards until stock cleared, no distributor would trust a maker's silence, and the plan would stop working. Buyers carry the risk so the company can book the sales.Tell and credit. Tell distributors about the fault this week, pull the 2,600 units, and credit them in full.Not placed yet.Tell and credit. Tell distributors about the fault this week, pull the 2,600 units, and credit them in full.Permissible: Passes both tests. The plan may still cost money; the duty is met.Any company could follow this rule, and everyone involved knows what is happening and why.Tell and credit. Tell distributors about the fault this week, pull the 2,600 units, and credit them in full.Fails the universal test: If every company acted on this rule, the rule would undo itself; this test shows the fault most plainly. Impermissible.Tell and credit. Tell distributors about the fault this week, pull the 2,600 units, and credit them in full.Fails the respect test: The rule could hold for every company, but it uses someone as a tool for the company's ends without their agreement; this test shows the fault most plainly. Impermissible.Tell and credit. Tell distributors about the fault this week, pull the 2,600 units, and credit them in full.Fails both tests: Usually a deception: it only works because others assume the honest rule. Impermissible.Warn buyers by mail. Write to the 1,400 buyers already registered and offer a free repair at home.Not placed yet.Warn buyers by mail. Write to the 1,400 buyers already registered and offer a free repair at home.Permissible: Passes both tests. The plan may still cost money; the duty is met.A rule every maker can follow, and the buyers decide for themselves with the facts in hand.Warn buyers by mail. Write to the 1,400 buyers already registered and offer a free repair at home.Fails the universal test: If every company acted on this rule, the rule would undo itself; this test shows the fault most plainly. Impermissible.Warn buyers by mail. Write to the 1,400 buyers already registered and offer a free repair at home.Fails the respect test: The rule could hold for every company, but it uses someone as a tool for the company's ends without their agreement; this test shows the fault most plainly. Impermissible.Warn buyers by mail. Write to the 1,400 buyers already registered and offer a free repair at home.Fails both tests: Usually a deception: it only works because others assume the honest rule. Impermissible.Registry, no dues. Post the fault to the industry's shared recall registry, which the makers fund together, but stop paying this year's dues, since the others will keep it running.Not placed yet.Registry, no dues. Post the fault to the industry's shared recall registry, which the makers fund together, but stop paying this year's dues, since the others will keep it running.Permissible: Passes both tests. The plan may still cost money; the duty is met.Registry, no dues. Post the fault to the industry's shared recall registry, which the makers fund together, but stop paying this year's dues, since the others will keep it running.Fails the universal test: If every company acted on this rule, the rule would undo itself; this test shows the fault most plainly. Impermissible.Free riding fails the first test most plainly: if every maker skipped the dues, there would be no registry to post to. The buyers still hear of the fault and the other makers can see who pays, so no one is misled about what is happening.Registry, no dues. Post the fault to the industry's shared recall registry, which the makers fund together, but stop paying this year's dues, since the others will keep it running.Fails the respect test: The rule could hold for every company, but it uses someone as a tool for the company's ends without their agreement; this test shows the fault most plainly. Impermissible.Registry, no dues. Post the fault to the industry's shared recall registry, which the makers fund together, but stop paying this year's dues, since the others will keep it running.Fails both tests: Usually a deception: it only works because others assume the honest rule. Impermissible.Unpaid Saturdays. Require the assemblers to work two unpaid Saturdays to rework the returned units.Not placed yet.Unpaid Saturdays. Require the assemblers to work two unpaid Saturdays to rework the returned units.Permissible: Passes both tests. The plan may still cost money; the duty is met.Unpaid Saturdays. Require the assemblers to work two unpaid Saturdays to rework the returned units.Fails the universal test: If every company acted on this rule, the rule would undo itself; this test shows the fault most plainly. Impermissible.Unpaid Saturdays. Require the assemblers to work two unpaid Saturdays to rework the returned units.Fails the respect test: The rule could hold for every company, but it uses someone as a tool for the company's ends without their agreement; this test shows the fault most plainly. Impermissible.Every company could require it without the rule undoing itself, so the first test alone would let it through. The second does not: it takes the assemblers' time for the company's purpose without their agreement.Unpaid Saturdays. Require the assemblers to work two unpaid Saturdays to rework the returned units.Fails both tests: Usually a deception: it only works because others assume the honest rule. Impermissible.False fix date. Tell distributors a fix ships Friday, knowing the parts will not arrive for a month, to keep them from returning stock.Not placed yet.False fix date. Tell distributors a fix ships Friday, knowing the parts will not arrive for a month, to keep them from returning stock.Permissible: Passes both tests. The plan may still cost money; the duty is met.False fix date. Tell distributors a fix ships Friday, knowing the parts will not arrive for a month, to keep them from returning stock.Fails the universal test: If every company acted on this rule, the rule would undo itself; this test shows the fault most plainly. Impermissible.False fix date. Tell distributors a fix ships Friday, knowing the parts will not arrive for a month, to keep them from returning stock.Fails the respect test: The rule could hold for every company, but it uses someone as a tool for the company's ends without their agreement; this test shows the fault most plainly. Impermissible.False fix date. Tell distributors a fix ships Friday, knowing the parts will not arrive for a month, to keep them from returning stock.Fails both tests: Usually a deception: it only works because others assume the honest rule. Impermissible.A promise made to be broken works only because promises are usually kept, and it uses the distributors to protect the quarter.
Your sort matched 0 of 6.Your sort matched 1 of 6.Your sort matched 2 of 6.Your sort matched 3 of 6.Your sort matched 4 of 6.Your sort matched 5 of 6.Your sort matched 6 of 6.
Permissible
Passes both tests. The plan may still cost money; the duty is met.
Fails the universal test
If every company acted on this rule, the rule would undo itself; this test shows the fault most plainly. Impermissible.
Fails the respect test
The rule could hold for every company, but it uses someone as a tool for the company's ends without their agreement; this test shows the fault most plainly. Impermissible.
Fails both tests
Usually a deception: it only works because others assume the honest rule. Impermissible.
The sort
Sell, then recall: Fails both tests. If every maker hid known hazards until stock cleared, no distributor would trust a maker's silence, and the plan would stop working. Buyers carry the risk so the company can book the sales.
Tell and credit: Permissible. Any company could follow this rule, and everyone involved knows what is happening and why.
Warn buyers by mail: Permissible. A rule every maker can follow, and the buyers decide for themselves with the facts in hand.
Registry, no dues: Fails the universal test. Free riding fails the first test most plainly: if every maker skipped the dues, there would be no registry to post to. The buyers still hear of the fault and the other makers can see who pays, so no one is misled about what is happening.
Unpaid Saturdays: Fails the respect test. Every company could require it without the rule undoing itself, so the first test alone would let it through. The second does not: it takes the assemblers' time for the company's purpose without their agreement.
False fix date: Fails both tests. A promise made to be broken works only because promises are usually kept, and it uses the distributors to protect the quarter.
An example
A maker of space heaters found a wiring fault in one batch of 4,000 units. Distributors still held 2,600 of them, and the holiday season was three weeks away. The sales vice president proposed letting the stock sell through and announcing the recall in January, when it would cost less. The general counsel asked for a day and ran the proposal through two questions.
First, the rule behind the plan: a maker may hide a known hazard until its stock clears. If every maker acted on that, no distributor would trust a maker's silence, so the plan only worked because other companies did not do it. Second, the plan used buyers as a means of booking holiday sales while they carried the risk. It failed both. The company told distributors that week, credited the 2,600 units in full, wrote to the 1,400 registered buyers offering a home repair, and posted the fault to the industry registry. The recall cost $1.1 million.
Why it works
Most business arguments weigh outcomes, and outcomes are easy to forecast in one's own favor. Duty tests ask about the plan itself, before anyone estimates the payoff. The first turns the plan into its general rule and asks whether that rule could hold if everyone followed it. A deception fails, because it works only while others act on the honest rule. The second asks whether the plan treats anyone merely as a tool, using them for the company's purpose in a way they have not agreed to and would not.
The tests are hard to bend. A forecast can always be made to favor a plan; the question of whether the plan relies on people not knowing what it does has a plain answer. That plainness is what makes a duty test useful in a room under pressure.
The thinking behind it
Immanuel Kant Immanuel Kant, the German Enlightenment philosopher, stated the categorical imperative in the Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals (1785), a founding text of duty-based ethics. Its best-known form is the test of acting only on a maxim, the rule behind an act, that one could will to become a universal law. The Groundwork also gives the formula this page uses as the second test: treat humanity, in oneself and in others, never merely as a means but always also as an end.
W. D. Ross W. D. Ross, a Scottish philosopher of ethics, argued in The Right and the Good (1930) that we carry several prima facie duties at once: fidelity, reparation, gratitude, justice, beneficence, non-maleficence, and self-improvement. He offered the list without claiming it was complete. When duties conflict, as fidelity to shareholders and the duty not to harm buyers can, no formula settles it; judgment in the particular case decides which duty takes precedence.
How to run it
State the plan as a rule. Write the general policy the plan acts on, such as "a maker may hide a known hazard until stock clears."
Universalize the rule. Imagine every company in the same position following it, and ask whether the plan would still work.
Look for a dependence on others' honesty. A plan that succeeds only because others keep the opposite rule fails the first test.
List everyone the plan touches. Include the people who would not be asked, such as buyers, assemblers, and distributors.
Ask whether each could agree. If the plan works only because someone does not know what it does, it uses them as a means.
Name the duties in conflict. Where two duties pull opposite ways, write both down and decide which carries more weight in this case.
Revise until both tests pass. Change what the plan does, leave the rule's wording alone, and run the tests again.
Where it goes wrong
The most common failure is stating the rule so narrowly that it passes: "a heater maker in its third year may delay a recall in December." Any plan can survive a rule written around it. Check the rule against how a stranger would describe what the company is doing.
The second is treating the tests as a cost-free verdict. Passing them can be expensive, as the recall was, and a team that has not faced the price will look for a loophole. Put the cost on the table with the verdict.
The third is using the tests to end a discussion that needs judgment. When duties really do conflict, the tests narrow the options without choosing among the ones that pass.
When to use something else
Consequentialism. When every option keeps faith with the people involved and the choice turns on which does the most good.
Contractualism. When the question is whether a rule can be justified to each person it binds, objection by objection.
Casuistry. When the case is messy and the best guide is how similar cases were judged before.