Circle of Competence

Thinking Tools5.3 Validating Impact and Execution

From Warren E. Buffett (Berkshire Hathaway shareholder letter, 1996) and Charles T. Munger (A Lesson on Elementary, Worldly Wisdom, 1994).

Draws an honest line around what a person or firm understands well enough to judge, then keeps high-stakes decisions inside it or limits the exposure outside.

Eight lending ideas for a regional bank, placed by how well it understands them

Each note says what the bank knows about the business and the stake proposed. Place each idea by the team's real understanding and the size of the bet; inside the circle the bank decides with conviction, at the edge it bets small or shrinks the bet, and outside it declines. The first is placed as an example. Illustrative.

Items (select one, then a box)
  • Not placedPlacedDecide with convictionShrink the stakeBet small and learnDecline
  • Not placedPlacedDecide with convictionShrink the stakeBet small and learnDecline
  • Not placedPlacedDecide with convictionShrink the stakeBet small and learnDecline
  • Not placedPlacedDecide with convictionShrink the stakeBet small and learnDecline
  • Not placedPlacedDecide with convictionShrink the stakeBet small and learnDecline
  • Not placedPlacedDecide with convictionShrink the stakeBet small and learnDecline
  • Not placedPlacedDecide with convictionShrink the stakeBet small and learnDecline
  • Not placedPlacedDecide with convictionShrink the stakeBet small and learnDecline

Stake proposed

LargeSmall
Decline
Shrink the stake
Decide with conviction
Bet small and learn
Outside the circleAt the edgeInside the circle

How well the team understands it

Farm equipment loans. Forty years of lending on tractors and combines in its own counties; $60M proposed.Not placed yet.Farm equipment loans. Forty years of lending on tractors and combines in its own counties; $60M proposed.Decide with conviction: Inside the circle: the team can say what would make this go wrong and how likely it is. Decide on the merits, at whatever size the merits support.The bank knows the borrowers, the resale prices, and the bad years. Large and inside: decide on the numbers.Farm equipment loans. Forty years of lending on tractors and combines in its own counties; $60M proposed.Shrink the stake: At the edge, and large: some of the risk cannot be priced. Cut the bet to a size the bank could lose while it learns.Farm equipment loans. Forty years of lending on tractors and combines in its own counties; $60M proposed.Bet small and learn: At the edge, and small: a fair way to widen the circle. Name what the bank expects to learn, and by when.Farm equipment loans. Forty years of lending on tractors and combines in its own counties; $60M proposed.Decline: Outside the circle: the team cannot say what would make this fail. Decline, whatever the stake, or bring in someone who can.Grain elevator. A $4M loan to a cooperative it has banked for decades.Not placed yet.Grain elevator. A $4M loan to a cooperative it has banked for decades.Decide with conviction: Inside the circle: the team can say what would make this go wrong and how likely it is. Decide on the merits, at whatever size the merits support.Inside, and small: an easy yes or no on the merits.Grain elevator. A $4M loan to a cooperative it has banked for decades.Shrink the stake: At the edge, and large: some of the risk cannot be priced. Cut the bet to a size the bank could lose while it learns.Grain elevator. A $4M loan to a cooperative it has banked for decades.Bet small and learn: At the edge, and small: a fair way to widen the circle. Name what the bank expects to learn, and by when.Grain elevator. A $4M loan to a cooperative it has banked for decades.Decline: Outside the circle: the team cannot say what would make this fail. Decline, whatever the stake, or bring in someone who can.Main Street shops. Small loans to shops in the towns where it has branches.Not placed yet.Main Street shops. Small loans to shops in the towns where it has branches.Decide with conviction: Inside the circle: the team can say what would make this go wrong and how likely it is. Decide on the merits, at whatever size the merits support.Inside: the loan officers know the owners and the foot traffic.Main Street shops. Small loans to shops in the towns where it has branches.Shrink the stake: At the edge, and large: some of the risk cannot be priced. Cut the bet to a size the bank could lose while it learns.Main Street shops. Small loans to shops in the towns where it has branches.Bet small and learn: At the edge, and small: a fair way to widen the circle. Name what the bank expects to learn, and by when.Main Street shops. Small loans to shops in the towns where it has branches.Decline: Outside the circle: the team cannot say what would make this fail. Decline, whatever the stake, or bring in someone who can.Solar farm on farmland. $45M for solar arrays on farms it lends to; returns depend on power contracts and subsidy rules.Not placed yet.Solar farm on farmland. $45M for solar arrays on farms it lends to; returns depend on power contracts and subsidy rules.Decide with conviction: Inside the circle: the team can say what would make this go wrong and how likely it is. Decide on the merits, at whatever size the merits support.Solar farm on farmland. $45M for solar arrays on farms it lends to; returns depend on power contracts and subsidy rules.Shrink the stake: At the edge, and large: some of the risk cannot be priced. Cut the bet to a size the bank could lose while it learns.It knows the land, not power markets. Boundary sign: nobody can say what a subsidy change would do. Join a larger lender's deal for $8M instead.Solar farm on farmland. $45M for solar arrays on farms it lends to; returns depend on power contracts and subsidy rules.Bet small and learn: At the edge, and small: a fair way to widen the circle. Name what the bank expects to learn, and by when.Solar farm on farmland. $45M for solar arrays on farms it lends to; returns depend on power contracts and subsidy rules.Decline: Outside the circle: the team cannot say what would make this fail. Decline, whatever the stake, or bring in someone who can.Dental practices. $3M in practice loans in the next state, through a broker.Not placed yet.Dental practices. $3M in practice loans in the next state, through a broker.Decide with conviction: Inside the circle: the team can say what would make this go wrong and how likely it is. Decide on the merits, at whatever size the merits support.Dental practices. $3M in practice loans in the next state, through a broker.Shrink the stake: At the edge, and large: some of the risk cannot be priced. Cut the bet to a size the bank could lose while it learns.Dental practices. $3M in practice loans in the next state, through a broker.Bet small and learn: At the edge, and small: a fair way to widen the circle. Name what the bank expects to learn, and by when.Small, and close to what it knows: small-business lending, new borrowers. Track defaults for two years before growing it.Dental practices. $3M in practice loans in the next state, through a broker.Decline: Outside the circle: the team cannot say what would make this fail. Decline, whatever the stake, or bring in someone who can.Crypto custody. A pilot holding digital assets for customers, $2M to set up.Not placed yet.Crypto custody. A pilot holding digital assets for customers, $2M to set up.Decide with conviction: Inside the circle: the team can say what would make this go wrong and how likely it is. Decide on the merits, at whatever size the merits support.Crypto custody. A pilot holding digital assets for customers, $2M to set up.Shrink the stake: At the edge, and large: some of the risk cannot be priced. Cut the bet to a size the bank could lose while it learns.Crypto custody. A pilot holding digital assets for customers, $2M to set up.Bet small and learn: At the edge, and small: a fair way to widen the circle. Name what the bank expects to learn, and by when.Crypto custody. A pilot holding digital assets for customers, $2M to set up.Decline: Outside the circle: the team cannot say what would make this fail. Decline, whatever the stake, or bring in someone who can.Small, but outside: no one can name the ways it fails. Decline.Aircraft leases. $50M in a fund of leases on passenger jets.Not placed yet.Aircraft leases. $50M in a fund of leases on passenger jets.Decide with conviction: Inside the circle: the team can say what would make this go wrong and how likely it is. Decide on the merits, at whatever size the merits support.Aircraft leases. $50M in a fund of leases on passenger jets.Shrink the stake: At the edge, and large: some of the risk cannot be priced. Cut the bet to a size the bank could lose while it learns.Aircraft leases. $50M in a fund of leases on passenger jets.Bet small and learn: At the edge, and small: a fair way to widen the circle. Name what the bank expects to learn, and by when.Aircraft leases. $50M in a fund of leases on passenger jets.Decline: Outside the circle: the team cannot say what would make this fail. Decline, whatever the stake, or bring in someone who can.Large and outside: the yield is attractive, and the team cannot price a used jet. Decline.Biotech venture fund. $20M into a fund of early drug companies, pitched by a board member's friend.Not placed yet.Biotech venture fund. $20M into a fund of early drug companies, pitched by a board member's friend.Decide with conviction: Inside the circle: the team can say what would make this go wrong and how likely it is. Decide on the merits, at whatever size the merits support.Biotech venture fund. $20M into a fund of early drug companies, pitched by a board member's friend.Shrink the stake: At the edge, and large: some of the risk cannot be priced. Cut the bet to a size the bank could lose while it learns.Biotech venture fund. $20M into a fund of early drug companies, pitched by a board member's friend.Bet small and learn: At the edge, and small: a fair way to widen the circle. Name what the bank expects to learn, and by when.Biotech venture fund. $20M into a fund of early drug companies, pitched by a board member's friend.Decline: Outside the circle: the team cannot say what would make this fail. Decline, whatever the stake, or bring in someone who can.Outside: the analogies to farm lending break at once. Decline.

Your sort matched 0 of 8.Your sort matched 1 of 8.Your sort matched 2 of 8.Your sort matched 3 of 8.Your sort matched 4 of 8.Your sort matched 5 of 8.Your sort matched 6 of 8.Your sort matched 7 of 8.Your sort matched 8 of 8.

Decide with conviction
Inside the circle: the team can say what would make this go wrong and how likely it is. Decide on the merits, at whatever size the merits support.
Shrink the stake
At the edge, and large: some of the risk cannot be priced. Cut the bet to a size the bank could lose while it learns.
Bet small and learn
At the edge, and small: a fair way to widen the circle. Name what the bank expects to learn, and by when.
Decline
Outside the circle: the team cannot say what would make this fail. Decline, whatever the stake, or bring in someone who can.

The sort

  • Farm equipment loans: Decide with conviction. The bank knows the borrowers, the resale prices, and the bad years. Large and inside: decide on the numbers.
  • Grain elevator: Decide with conviction. Inside, and small: an easy yes or no on the merits.
  • Main Street shops: Decide with conviction. Inside: the loan officers know the owners and the foot traffic.
  • Solar farm on farmland: Shrink the stake. It knows the land, not power markets. Boundary sign: nobody can say what a subsidy change would do. Join a larger lender's deal for $8M instead.
  • Dental practices: Bet small and learn. Small, and close to what it knows: small-business lending, new borrowers. Track defaults for two years before growing it.
  • Crypto custody: Decline. Small, but outside: no one can name the ways it fails. Decline.
  • Aircraft leases: Decline. Large and outside: the yield is attractive, and the team cannot price a used jet. Decline.
  • Biotech venture fund: Decline. Outside: the analogies to farm lending break at once. Decline.

An example

A regional bank with forty years of farm lending had more deposits than good loans, and its credit committee had eight proposals on the table, from more equipment loans to a fund of aircraft leases with an attractive yield.

The chief credit officer asked one question of each: can someone here say what would make this go wrong, and how likely that is? For equipment loans, a grain elevator, and small loans to shops in its own towns, the answers were quick and specific. For a $45 million solar farm on land it already lent against, the team knew the farms but could not say what a change in power subsidies would do to the returns. For dental practices in the next state, the business was familiar but the borrowers were not. For crypto custody, aircraft leases, and a biotech fund, nobody could answer at all. The committee approved the first three on their numbers, joined a larger lender's solar deal for $8 million, made $3 million in dental loans to learn from, and declined the rest.

Why it works

The danger in an unfamiliar opportunity is that its risk cannot be judged, so a decision that feels like analysis is really a guess, and an attractive return hides how little is known. Drawing the line honestly separates the decisions a team can make on the merits from the ones it cannot.

Knowing where the edge runs is worth more than a wide circle. Inside it, a team can act with conviction and at scale. At the edge, it can still act, at a size it could afford to lose, while it learns. Outside it, the honest answer is no, or a partner who knows the field. The boundary signs are practical: questions nobody can answer, analogies from the home business that break, and enthusiasm that rests on the return alone.

The thinking behind it

Warren E. Buffett Warren E. Buffett, the longtime chairman and chief executive of Berkshire Hathaway, wrote in the 1996 Chairman's Letter to shareholders that an investor does not need to understand every company, only to be able to evaluate those within a circle of competence. That letter is the usual source given for the term. His annual letters to shareholders are read as a practitioner's classic on investing and on allocating capital.

Charles T. Munger Charles T. Munger, Berkshire's vice chairman, made knowing the edges of one's competence a recurring maxim in his talks, among them A Lesson on Elementary, Worldly Wisdom As It Relates to Investment Management and Business (1994, at the USC Business School). He paired it with building a latticework of models from many fields and with inverting problems. These are an investor's maxims from talks, not research.

How to run it

  1. Name the domain. Say what field the decision really sits in, which may differ from the one it was pitched in.
  2. List what grounds the team's confidence. Write the specific knowledge: years of results, people who have run such businesses, data on how they fail.
  3. Ask how it would go wrong. If no one can name the main ways it fails and roughly how likely each is, the decision is outside the circle.
  4. Look for boundary signs. Watch for unanswerable questions, analogies from the home business that break, and support that rests only on the return.
  5. Inside, decide with conviction. Judge it on the merits and size it accordingly, without extra discounts for unfamiliarity.
  6. At the edge, shrink the stake. Bet an amount the firm could lose, through a partner where possible, and name what it should learn.
  7. Outside, decline or borrow knowledge. Say no, or bring in someone whose circle it is, and let them carry the judgment.

Where it goes wrong

The circle is drawn by confidence instead of knowledge. Successful people feel competent in fields next to their own, and a good record in farm lending becomes a belief about energy markets. Test the circle by asking how the business fails, not by how the team feels.

The circle never grows. A firm that only acts inside it misses the small, deliberate bets at the edge that would widen it. Set aside a budget for learning stakes, with a stated question each one answers.

The line is drawn once. Markets change, and something once inside the circle drifts out as its economics shift. Redraw it when the business you know changes, not only when a new pitch arrives.

When to use something else

  • Barbell Strategy. When the aim is to pair very safe positions with a few small, open-ended bets, by design.
  • Real Options Analysis. When the bet at the edge can be staged, and the value of starting small needs counting.
  • Outside View. When the team needs base rates for how such ventures usually turn out before judging this one.

Where it sits in SOLVE eX

Go to the source

Back to the catalog