Wind Tunneling

Thinking Tools5.3 Validating Impact and ExecutionAlso known as Scenario Stress-Testing

Developed by Kees van der Heijden (Scenarios: The Art of Strategic Conversation, 1996).

Runs an existing strategy through each of a set of scenarios to see where it holds, where it fails, and what change would make it hold across all of them.

A retailer's growth strategy run through four scenarios

Each row is one element of the strategy, set at load to the plan as written; the lines under it say where the plan fails or strains in the four scenarios (a downturn, a shift online, a labor squeeze, and a boom). Change one element at a time until no line is left. Illustrative.

New stores

Funding

Online

Staffing

  • No failure found in any of the four scenarios for this combination.Downturn: fails. Twelve new leases and the loan payments come due while sales fall by a fifth.Downturn: fails. A borrowed warehouse sits half empty when spending drops.Downturn: strained. The cash is in, but the rent on stores the company used to own is fixed.Shift online: fails. A third of sales move online, and the company has no way to serve them.Shift online: strained. Twelve new stores open just as foot traffic falls.Labor squeeze: fails. Part-time staff leave first when wages rise, and the stores cannot open full hours.Boom: strained. Too few people to cover the peak, and hiring takes months.Boom: strained. Demand outruns six stores, and rivals take the sites.Holds in all four. The options are taken up in a boom and lapse in a downturn, the stores double as online depots, and trained staff cover both jobs.
  • No failure found in any of the four scenarios for this combination.Downturn: fails. Twelve new leases and the loan payments come due while sales fall by a fifth.Downturn: fails. A borrowed warehouse sits half empty when spending drops.Downturn: strained. The cash is in, but the rent on stores the company used to own is fixed.Shift online: fails. A third of sales move online, and the company has no way to serve them.Shift online: strained. Twelve new stores open just as foot traffic falls.Labor squeeze: fails. Part-time staff leave first when wages rise, and the stores cannot open full hours.Boom: strained. Too few people to cover the peak, and hiring takes months.Boom: strained. Demand outruns six stores, and rivals take the sites.Holds in all four. The options are taken up in a boom and lapse in a downturn, the stores double as online depots, and trained staff cover both jobs.
  • No failure found in any of the four scenarios for this combination.Downturn: fails. Twelve new leases and the loan payments come due while sales fall by a fifth.Downturn: fails. A borrowed warehouse sits half empty when spending drops.Downturn: strained. The cash is in, but the rent on stores the company used to own is fixed.Shift online: fails. A third of sales move online, and the company has no way to serve them.Shift online: strained. Twelve new stores open just as foot traffic falls.Labor squeeze: fails. Part-time staff leave first when wages rise, and the stores cannot open full hours.Boom: strained. Too few people to cover the peak, and hiring takes months.Boom: strained. Demand outruns six stores, and rivals take the sites.Holds in all four. The options are taken up in a boom and lapse in a downturn, the stores double as online depots, and trained staff cover both jobs.
  • No failure found in any of the four scenarios for this combination.Downturn: fails. Twelve new leases and the loan payments come due while sales fall by a fifth.Downturn: fails. A borrowed warehouse sits half empty when spending drops.Downturn: strained. The cash is in, but the rent on stores the company used to own is fixed.Shift online: fails. A third of sales move online, and the company has no way to serve them.Shift online: strained. Twelve new stores open just as foot traffic falls.Labor squeeze: fails. Part-time staff leave first when wages rise, and the stores cannot open full hours.Boom: strained. Too few people to cover the peak, and hiring takes months.Boom: strained. Demand outruns six stores, and rivals take the sites.Holds in all four. The options are taken up in a boom and lapse in a downturn, the stores double as online depots, and trained staff cover both jobs.
  • Downturn: fails. Twelve new leases and the loan payments come due while sales fall by a fifth. (stores: Open 12 now, money: Borrow)
  • Downturn: fails. A borrowed warehouse sits half empty when spending drops. (online: Build a warehouse, money: Borrow)
  • Downturn: strained. The cash is in, but the rent on stores the company used to own is fixed. (money: Sell and lease back)
  • Shift online: fails. A third of sales move online, and the company has no way to serve them. (online: Keep it small)
  • Shift online: strained. Twelve new stores open just as foot traffic falls. (stores: Open 12 now)
  • Labor squeeze: fails. Part-time staff leave first when wages rise, and the stores cannot open full hours. (staff: Mostly part-time)
  • Boom: strained. Too few people to cover the peak, and hiring takes months. (staff: Lean full-time)
  • Boom: strained. Demand outruns six stores, and rivals take the sites. (stores: Open 6 now)
  • Holds in all four. The options are taken up in a boom and lapse in a downturn, the stores double as online depots, and trained staff cover both jobs. (stores: Open 6, option on 6, money: Cash from operations, online: Ship from stores, staff: Cross-trained full-time)

An example

A regional home-goods retailer's board had a growth plan in front of it: open twelve stores next year on borrowed money, keep online sales small, and staff the new stores mostly part-time. The planning team had already built four scenarios for the next five years: a downturn, a steep shift of spending online, a labor squeeze, and a boom.

The chief financial officer ran the plan through each scenario as written. It did well in the boom. In the downturn, twelve new leases and the loan payments arrived just as sales fell by a fifth. In the online shift, the company had nothing to serve a third of its customers with. In the labor squeeze, the part-time staff left first. The plan, read this way, was a bet on one future. The revised plan opened six stores with options on six more, paid for them from cash, shipped online orders from the stores, and hired cross-trained full-time staff. It earned less in the boom and survived the other three.

Why it works

A strategy is usually written for the future its authors expect, and the assumption is never stated, so nobody tests it. Running the strategy through several scenarios makes each hidden bet visible: wherever it fails, it was depending on that future not arriving.

The scenarios must be different enough to matter and plausible enough to take seriously, which is why they are built first and separately from the strategy. The test then works element by element. A strategy usually fails in a scenario because of one or two parts, and a change to those parts (a smaller commitment, an option instead of a purchase, a capability that serves two futures) often makes it hold in more of them at a modest cost in the best case. What still fails gets a contingency plan and a signal to watch for.

The thinking behind it

Kees van der Heijden Kees van der Heijden, a scenario planner from Royal Dutch Shell's planning group, set out the practice in Scenarios: The Art of Strategic Conversation (1996). The book treats scenario planning as a process by which an organization learns, carried on as a conversation among its managers about how the future might unfold, and describes testing strategies against several plausible futures to see which hold up. Wind tunneling is that test: a strategy placed in each future in turn, the way an aircraft design is tested in a wind tunnel before it flies.

How to run it

  1. Build the scenarios first. Three or four futures, each plausible and each different from the others in what drives it.
  2. Write the strategy as its elements. Four to eight concrete choices, such as how many stores, funded how, staffed how.
  3. Run each element through each scenario. Ask what happens to it in that future, and mark it holds, strained, or fails.
  4. Find the elements that fail most. Usually one or two parts carry most of the exposure.
  5. Revise those elements. Look for a smaller commitment, an option in place of a purchase, or a capability useful in more than one future.
  6. Price the revision in the best case. Say what the robust plan gives up if the favored future arrives, so the board chooses with that in view.
  7. Plan contingencies for what still fails. Name the early signal of that future and the move to make when it shows.

Where it goes wrong

The scenarios are variations on the expected future. A base case, a slightly better case, and a slightly worse case all pass the plan, and the test proves nothing. Check that each scenario would make at least one board member uncomfortable.

The strategy gets revised until it holds everywhere and does nothing. Every commitment is cut to an option, and the plan survives every future by never acting. Keep the elements that carry the upside, and hedge the rest.

The test is run by the plan's authors. They read each scenario in the kindest light for their plan. Have someone outside the plan run at least the scenario it fears most.

When to use something else

  • Scenario Planning. When the scenarios themselves have not been built yet; they come first.
  • Premortem. When there is no time for scenarios and the team needs to find the plan's weak points in one session.
  • Sensitivity Analysis. When the uncertainty is in a few numbers in a model, not in whole different futures.

Where it sits in SOLVE eX

Go to the source

  • Scenarios: The Art of Strategic Conversation, Wiley, 1996

Back to the catalog