Thinking Tools1.2 Writing the Problem StatementAlso known as Hohfeld's Jural Relations
Developed by Wesley Newcomb Hohfeld (Some Fundamental Legal Conceptions as Applied in Judicial Reasoning, 1913).
Splits the loose word right into four distinct relations (claim, privilege, power, and immunity), each matched by a position someone else holds, to show what is really at stake.
Eight ways to read an employee's right to work from home, each with the employer's matching position
Each tag is something said in one dispute about a right to work from home. Place it by what kind of right it describes: about conduct now or about changing the terms, and a hold on the employer or a freedom from its control. The box names the employer's matching position and what follows if it recalls her to the office. The first is placed as an example. Illustrative.
Items (select one, then a box)
Not placedPlacedClaim: employer has a dutyPrivilege: employer has no-rightPower: employer is liableImmunity: employer has a disability
Not placedPlacedClaim: employer has a dutyPrivilege: employer has no-rightPower: employer is liableImmunity: employer has a disability
Not placedPlacedClaim: employer has a dutyPrivilege: employer has no-rightPower: employer is liableImmunity: employer has a disability
Not placedPlacedClaim: employer has a dutyPrivilege: employer has no-rightPower: employer is liableImmunity: employer has a disability
Not placedPlacedClaim: employer has a dutyPrivilege: employer has no-rightPower: employer is liableImmunity: employer has a disability
Not placedPlacedClaim: employer has a dutyPrivilege: employer has no-rightPower: employer is liableImmunity: employer has a disability
Not placedPlacedClaim: employer has a dutyPrivilege: employer has no-rightPower: employer is liableImmunity: employer has a disability
Not placedPlacedClaim: employer has a dutyPrivilege: employer has no-rightPower: employer is liableImmunity: employer has a disability
What it gives her against the employer
A holdFreedom
Claim: employer has a duty
Power: employer is liable
Privilege: employer has no-right
Immunity: employer has a disability
What she may do nowWho can change the terms
What the right concerns
Contract: two home days. Her contract says she will work from home on Mondays and Fridays.Not placed yet.Contract: two home days. Her contract says she will work from home on Mondays and Fridays.Claim: employer has a duty: She has a claim, so the employer has a duty to let her work from home. A recall to the office breaches that duty.A claim. The employer has a duty to allow those two days; a recall on a Friday is a breach.Contract: two home days. Her contract says she will work from home on Mondays and Fridays.Privilege: employer has no-right: She is free to work from home, and the employer has no right to stop it while the privilege lasts. But it owes her nothing to make it possible, and can end it by changing the rules.Contract: two home days. Her contract says she will work from home on Mondays and Fridays.Power: employer is liable: She can change the arrangement by her own act, such as a request, and the employer is liable to have its position changed. A recall is valid only until she uses the power.Contract: two home days. Her contract says she will work from home on Mondays and Fridays.Immunity: employer has a disability: The employer cannot change her arrangement alone; it has a disability. A recall has no effect without her consent.A reply within 10 days. Policy says a manager must answer any schedule request within ten days, with reasons.Not placed yet.A reply within 10 days. Policy says a manager must answer any schedule request within ten days, with reasons.Claim: employer has a duty: She has a claim, so the employer has a duty to let her work from home. A recall to the office breaches that duty.A claim to a decision, not to the schedule itself. The duty is to answer.A reply within 10 days. Policy says a manager must answer any schedule request within ten days, with reasons.Privilege: employer has no-right: She is free to work from home, and the employer has no right to stop it while the privilege lasts. But it owes her nothing to make it possible, and can end it by changing the rules.A reply within 10 days. Policy says a manager must answer any schedule request within ten days, with reasons.Power: employer is liable: She can change the arrangement by her own act, such as a request, and the employer is liable to have its position changed. A recall is valid only until she uses the power.A reply within 10 days. Policy says a manager must answer any schedule request within ten days, with reasons.Immunity: employer has a disability: The employer cannot change her arrangement alone; it has a disability. A recall has no effect without her consent.Nothing bans a cafe. The handbook says nothing about where work is done on the other three days.Not placed yet.Nothing bans a cafe. The handbook says nothing about where work is done on the other three days.Claim: employer has a duty: She has a claim, so the employer has a duty to let her work from home. A recall to the office breaches that duty.Nothing bans a cafe. The handbook says nothing about where work is done on the other three days.Privilege: employer has no-right: She is free to work from home, and the employer has no right to stop it while the privilege lasts. But it owes her nothing to make it possible, and can end it by changing the rules.A privilege: she breaks no rule working elsewhere. The employer owes her no laptop and can write a rule tomorrow.Nothing bans a cafe. The handbook says nothing about where work is done on the other three days.Power: employer is liable: She can change the arrangement by her own act, such as a request, and the employer is liable to have its position changed. A recall is valid only until she uses the power.Nothing bans a cafe. The handbook says nothing about where work is done on the other three days.Immunity: employer has a disability: The employer cannot change her arrangement alone; it has a disability. A recall has no effect without her consent.Free on Wednesdays. Her manager said she could work anywhere on Wednesdays if her work is done.Not placed yet.Free on Wednesdays. Her manager said she could work anywhere on Wednesdays if her work is done.Claim: employer has a duty: She has a claim, so the employer has a duty to let her work from home. A recall to the office breaches that duty.Free on Wednesdays. Her manager said she could work anywhere on Wednesdays if her work is done.Privilege: employer has no-right: She is free to work from home, and the employer has no right to stop it while the privilege lasts. But it owes her nothing to make it possible, and can end it by changing the rules.A privilege, granted and revocable. A recall for Wednesdays is lawful.Free on Wednesdays. Her manager said she could work anywhere on Wednesdays if her work is done.Power: employer is liable: She can change the arrangement by her own act, such as a request, and the employer is liable to have its position changed. A recall is valid only until she uses the power.Free on Wednesdays. Her manager said she could work anywhere on Wednesdays if her work is done.Immunity: employer has a disability: The employer cannot change her arrangement alone; it has a disability. A recall has no effect without her consent.Request takes effect. Under the pilot policy, an eligible request becomes her schedule in 30 days unless refused for a listed reason.Not placed yet.Request takes effect. Under the pilot policy, an eligible request becomes her schedule in 30 days unless refused for a listed reason.Claim: employer has a duty: She has a claim, so the employer has a duty to let her work from home. A recall to the office breaches that duty.Request takes effect. Under the pilot policy, an eligible request becomes her schedule in 30 days unless refused for a listed reason.Privilege: employer has no-right: She is free to work from home, and the employer has no right to stop it while the privilege lasts. But it owes her nothing to make it possible, and can end it by changing the rules.Request takes effect. Under the pilot policy, an eligible request becomes her schedule in 30 days unless refused for a listed reason.Power: employer is liable: She can change the arrangement by her own act, such as a request, and the employer is liable to have its position changed. A recall is valid only until she uses the power.A power: her request changes the terms. The employer is liable to that change unless it refuses on a listed ground.Request takes effect. Under the pilot policy, an eligible request becomes her schedule in 30 days unless refused for a listed reason.Immunity: employer has a disability: The employer cannot change her arrangement alone; it has a disability. A recall has no effect without her consent.Can swap days by notice. She may move a home day to another weekday by giving a week's notice.Not placed yet.Can swap days by notice. She may move a home day to another weekday by giving a week's notice.Claim: employer has a duty: She has a claim, so the employer has a duty to let her work from home. A recall to the office breaches that duty.Can swap days by notice. She may move a home day to another weekday by giving a week's notice.Privilege: employer has no-right: She is free to work from home, and the employer has no right to stop it while the privilege lasts. But it owes her nothing to make it possible, and can end it by changing the rules.Can swap days by notice. She may move a home day to another weekday by giving a week's notice.Power: employer is liable: She can change the arrangement by her own act, such as a request, and the employer is liable to have its position changed. A recall is valid only until she uses the power.A power over the schedule, exercised by notice.Can swap days by notice. She may move a home day to another weekday by giving a week's notice.Immunity: employer has a disability: The employer cannot change her arrangement alone; it has a disability. A recall has no effect without her consent.Changes need consent. A contract clause says her schedule cannot be changed without her written agreement.Not placed yet.Changes need consent. A contract clause says her schedule cannot be changed without her written agreement.Claim: employer has a duty: She has a claim, so the employer has a duty to let her work from home. A recall to the office breaches that duty.Changes need consent. A contract clause says her schedule cannot be changed without her written agreement.Privilege: employer has no-right: She is free to work from home, and the employer has no right to stop it while the privilege lasts. But it owes her nothing to make it possible, and can end it by changing the rules.Changes need consent. A contract clause says her schedule cannot be changed without her written agreement.Power: employer is liable: She can change the arrangement by her own act, such as a request, and the employer is liable to have its position changed. A recall is valid only until she uses the power.Changes need consent. A contract clause says her schedule cannot be changed without her written agreement.Immunity: employer has a disability: The employer cannot change her arrangement alone; it has a disability. A recall has no effect without her consent.An immunity. The employer has a disability: a recall without her signature changes nothing.No recall during pilot. The pilot letter says no participant will be recalled before it ends in June.Not placed yet.No recall during pilot. The pilot letter says no participant will be recalled before it ends in June.Claim: employer has a duty: She has a claim, so the employer has a duty to let her work from home. A recall to the office breaches that duty.No recall during pilot. The pilot letter says no participant will be recalled before it ends in June.Privilege: employer has no-right: She is free to work from home, and the employer has no right to stop it while the privilege lasts. But it owes her nothing to make it possible, and can end it by changing the rules.No recall during pilot. The pilot letter says no participant will be recalled before it ends in June.Power: employer is liable: She can change the arrangement by her own act, such as a request, and the employer is liable to have its position changed. A recall is valid only until she uses the power.No recall during pilot. The pilot letter says no participant will be recalled before it ends in June.Immunity: employer has a disability: The employer cannot change her arrangement alone; it has a disability. A recall has no effect without her consent.An immunity until June. After that, the employer's power returns.
Your sort matched 0 of 8.Your sort matched 1 of 8.Your sort matched 2 of 8.Your sort matched 3 of 8.Your sort matched 4 of 8.Your sort matched 5 of 8.Your sort matched 6 of 8.Your sort matched 7 of 8.Your sort matched 8 of 8.
Claim: employer has a duty
She has a claim, so the employer has a duty to let her work from home. A recall to the office breaches that duty.
Privilege: employer has no-right
She is free to work from home, and the employer has no right to stop it while the privilege lasts. But it owes her nothing to make it possible, and can end it by changing the rules.
Power: employer is liable
She can change the arrangement by her own act, such as a request, and the employer is liable to have its position changed. A recall is valid only until she uses the power.
Immunity: employer has a disability
The employer cannot change her arrangement alone; it has a disability. A recall has no effect without her consent.
The sort
Contract: two home days: Claim: employer has a duty. A claim. The employer has a duty to allow those two days; a recall on a Friday is a breach.
A reply within 10 days: Claim: employer has a duty. A claim to a decision, not to the schedule itself. The duty is to answer.
Nothing bans a cafe: Privilege: employer has no-right. A privilege: she breaks no rule working elsewhere. The employer owes her no laptop and can write a rule tomorrow.
Free on Wednesdays: Privilege: employer has no-right. A privilege, granted and revocable. A recall for Wednesdays is lawful.
Request takes effect: Power: employer is liable. A power: her request changes the terms. The employer is liable to that change unless it refuses on a listed ground.
Can swap days by notice: Power: employer is liable. A power over the schedule, exercised by notice.
Changes need consent: Immunity: employer has a disability. An immunity. The employer has a disability: a recall without her signature changes nothing.
No recall during pilot: Immunity: employer has a disability. An immunity until June. After that, the employer's power returns.
An example
A logistics company told its analysts to return to the office four days a week. One analyst replied that she had a right to work from home and would not come in. Her manager replied that she had no such right. Both were partly correct, and the argument went nowhere for a month.
The company's employment counsel took the word right apart. Her contract named Mondays and Fridays as home days: that was a claim, and the company had a duty to honor it, so recalling her on those days was a breach. Her manager had told her she could work anywhere on Wednesdays: that was a privilege, freely revocable, so a Wednesday recall was lawful. Under the pilot policy she had filed a request that became her schedule after thirty days: a power, already used. And the pilot letter promised no recalls before June: an immunity, which disabled the company from changing her schedule until then. The memo that settled it allowed Mondays and Fridays, ended the Wednesday arrangement, and set the rest for June.
Why it works
The word right does four different jobs, and arguments about rights usually stall because each side means a different one. A claim means someone else owes you something. A privilege means you owe no one a duty not to act, which says nothing about whether anyone must help you. A power means you can change a relationship by your own act. An immunity means someone else cannot change it.
Each kind also fixes the other party's position: a claim matches a duty, a privilege a no-right, a power a liability, and an immunity a disability. Naming the kind settles what the other side must do and what it may not do. Swapping one kind for another and watching the conclusion change shows which reading the dispute really turns on.
The thinking behind it
Wesley Newcomb Hohfeld Wesley Newcomb Hohfeld, a legal scholar, showed in his 1913 Yale Law Journal article Some Fundamental Legal Conceptions that the word right covers four distinct legal relations: claim, privilege, power, and immunity. Each has its correlative on the other party (duty, no-right, liability, and disability) and its opposite. Laid out as a table, the eight terms make it possible to say exactly what a right entails for both sides. His scheme is still the standard tool for taking apart what a legal right actually means.
How to run it
State the claimed right in plain words. Write who holds it, against whom, and over what, such as the analyst against the company, over where she works.
Find the source. Locate the contract clause, policy, promise, or law it rests on, word for word.
Classify it. Decide whether it is a claim, a privilege, a power, or an immunity, by asking what it lets the holder demand, do, change, or resist.
Name the other side's position. Write the matching duty, no-right, liability, or disability, and who holds it.
Work out the conclusion. Say what follows for the act in dispute, such as whether a recall is a breach, lawful, or void.
Swap the classification. Try each other kind and see whether the conclusion changes; where it does, that is the real question.
Settle which kind is meant. Resolve the classification from the source text first, then the dispute usually settles itself.
Where it goes wrong
Privileges are read as claims. Being free to do something feels like being owed it, and people expect the other side to make it possible. Ask whether anyone has a duty to help, or only no right to stop.
One right is analyzed when several are in play. A single phrase in a dispute usually bundles a claim, a power, and an immunity from different sources. Split the bundle and classify each part on its own.
The analysis replaces negotiation. Knowing exactly what each side is owed can harden positions. Use the classification to see where agreement is easy, and negotiate the parts that turn on discretion.
When to use something else
Interest-Based Bargaining. When what each side is owed is clear and the work is finding an arrangement both can live with.
Burden of Proof Analysis. When the question is who must prove what, and to what standard, before a right is recognized.
Reasoning from Precedent. When the classification itself is disputed and earlier cases must decide it.