Designed by Peter Hayward and Stuart Candy (The Polak Game, 2017) from Fred Polak's work on images of the future (The Image of the Future, 1955).
Has a group stand on two axes in a room (is the future getting better or worse, and can we shape it) to show which disagreements come from different outlooks.
Eight executives place themselves on two questions about the future
Select an executive to read what they said, then the quadrant it puts them in: the quadrant lights and says what that outlook argues for in the plan. Show the sort to see where each stood. Illustrative.
Items (select one, then a box)
Not placedPlacedBuild itRide itFight for itBrace for it
Not placedPlacedBuild itRide itFight for itBrace for it
Not placedPlacedBuild itRide itFight for itBrace for it
Not placedPlacedBuild itRide itFight for itBrace for it
Not placedPlacedBuild itRide itFight for itBrace for it
Not placedPlacedBuild itRide itFight for itBrace for it
Not placedPlacedBuild itRide itFight for itBrace for it
Not placedPlacedBuild itRide itFight for itBrace for it
The future
BetterWorse
Ride it
Build it
Brace for it
Fight for it
Out of our handsIn our hands
How much can we shape it?
Head of strategy. "Remote care will open markets we could never reach, if we move first."Not placed yet.Head of strategy. "Remote care will open markets we could never reach, if we move first."Build it: Better, and ours to shape: argues for bold investment and the ambitious version of the plan.Wants the full expansion, starting this year.Head of strategy. "Remote care will open markets we could never reach, if we move first."Ride it: Better on its own: argues for staying flexible and catching the wave, and distrusts big bets.Head of strategy. "Remote care will open markets we could never reach, if we move first."Fight for it: Harder, and effort still counts: argues for defending the core and spending where the group has control.Head of strategy. "Remote care will open markets we could never reach, if we move first."Brace for it: Harder and out of our hands: argues for cash, cuts, and keeping options open.Clinic network lead. "Our towns are growing and aging. Demand is coming, and how well we meet it is up to us."Not placed yet.Clinic network lead. "Our towns are growing and aging. Demand is coming, and how well we meet it is up to us."Build it: Better, and ours to shape: argues for bold investment and the ambitious version of the plan.Wants two new clinics and the staff to run them.Clinic network lead. "Our towns are growing and aging. Demand is coming, and how well we meet it is up to us."Ride it: Better on its own: argues for staying flexible and catching the wave, and distrusts big bets.Clinic network lead. "Our towns are growing and aging. Demand is coming, and how well we meet it is up to us."Fight for it: Harder, and effort still counts: argues for defending the core and spending where the group has control.Clinic network lead. "Our towns are growing and aging. Demand is coming, and how well we meet it is up to us."Brace for it: Harder and out of our hands: argues for cash, cuts, and keeping options open.IT director. "The tools get better every year whether we push or not. Buy them when they are ready."Not placed yet.IT director. "The tools get better every year whether we push or not. Buy them when they are ready."Build it: Better, and ours to shape: argues for bold investment and the ambitious version of the plan.IT director. "The tools get better every year whether we push or not. Buy them when they are ready."Ride it: Better on its own: argues for staying flexible and catching the wave, and distrusts big bets.Wants to wait and buy, never build.IT director. "The tools get better every year whether we push or not. Buy them when they are ready."Fight for it: Harder, and effort still counts: argues for defending the core and spending where the group has control.IT director. "The tools get better every year whether we push or not. Buy them when they are ready."Brace for it: Harder and out of our hands: argues for cash, cuts, and keeping options open.Board member. "Policy is moving our way, but it is decided far from here."Not placed yet.Board member. "Policy is moving our way, but it is decided far from here."Build it: Better, and ours to shape: argues for bold investment and the ambitious version of the plan.Board member. "Policy is moving our way, but it is decided far from here."Ride it: Better on its own: argues for staying flexible and catching the wave, and distrusts big bets.Wants a plan that can stretch when the rules change.Board member. "Policy is moving our way, but it is decided far from here."Fight for it: Harder, and effort still counts: argues for defending the core and spending where the group has control.Board member. "Policy is moving our way, but it is decided far from here."Brace for it: Harder and out of our hands: argues for cash, cuts, and keeping options open.Chief nursing officer. "Staffing gets worse every year, and we can still be the place nurses choose."Not placed yet.Chief nursing officer. "Staffing gets worse every year, and we can still be the place nurses choose."Build it: Better, and ours to shape: argues for bold investment and the ambitious version of the plan.Chief nursing officer. "Staffing gets worse every year, and we can still be the place nurses choose."Ride it: Better on its own: argues for staying flexible and catching the wave, and distrusts big bets.Chief nursing officer. "Staffing gets worse every year, and we can still be the place nurses choose."Fight for it: Harder, and effort still counts: argues for defending the core and spending where the group has control.Wants retention money before any expansion.Chief nursing officer. "Staffing gets worse every year, and we can still be the place nurses choose."Brace for it: Harder and out of our hands: argues for cash, cuts, and keeping options open.HR director. "The labor market will tighten. Pay alone will not fix it; culture can."Not placed yet.HR director. "The labor market will tighten. Pay alone will not fix it; culture can."Build it: Better, and ours to shape: argues for bold investment and the ambitious version of the plan.HR director. "The labor market will tighten. Pay alone will not fix it; culture can."Ride it: Better on its own: argues for staying flexible and catching the wave, and distrusts big bets.HR director. "The labor market will tighten. Pay alone will not fix it; culture can."Fight for it: Harder, and effort still counts: argues for defending the core and spending where the group has control.Wants a training academy and a manager program.HR director. "The labor market will tighten. Pay alone will not fix it; culture can."Brace for it: Harder and out of our hands: argues for cash, cuts, and keeping options open.Finance director. "Payment rates will keep falling, and nothing we do changes that."Not placed yet.Finance director. "Payment rates will keep falling, and nothing we do changes that."Build it: Better, and ours to shape: argues for bold investment and the ambitious version of the plan.Finance director. "Payment rates will keep falling, and nothing we do changes that."Ride it: Better on its own: argues for staying flexible and catching the wave, and distrusts big bets.Finance director. "Payment rates will keep falling, and nothing we do changes that."Fight for it: Harder, and effort still counts: argues for defending the core and spending where the group has control.Finance director. "Payment rates will keep falling, and nothing we do changes that."Brace for it: Harder and out of our hands: argues for cash, cuts, and keeping options open.Wants reserves built and the new wing delayed.Medical director. "Costs rise, payers squeeze, and a downturn is coming. Protect what we have."Not placed yet.Medical director. "Costs rise, payers squeeze, and a downturn is coming. Protect what we have."Build it: Better, and ours to shape: argues for bold investment and the ambitious version of the plan.Medical director. "Costs rise, payers squeeze, and a downturn is coming. Protect what we have."Ride it: Better on its own: argues for staying flexible and catching the wave, and distrusts big bets.Medical director. "Costs rise, payers squeeze, and a downturn is coming. Protect what we have."Fight for it: Harder, and effort still counts: argues for defending the core and spending where the group has control.Medical director. "Costs rise, payers squeeze, and a downturn is coming. Protect what we have."Brace for it: Harder and out of our hands: argues for cash, cuts, and keeping options open.Wants the existing services funded first.
Your sort matched 0 of 8.Your sort matched 1 of 8.Your sort matched 2 of 8.Your sort matched 3 of 8.Your sort matched 4 of 8.Your sort matched 5 of 8.Your sort matched 6 of 8.Your sort matched 7 of 8.Your sort matched 8 of 8.
Build it
Better, and ours to shape: argues for bold investment and the ambitious version of the plan.
Ride it
Better on its own: argues for staying flexible and catching the wave, and distrusts big bets.
Fight for it
Harder, and effort still counts: argues for defending the core and spending where the group has control.
Brace for it
Harder and out of our hands: argues for cash, cuts, and keeping options open.
The sort
Head of strategy: Build it. Wants the full expansion, starting this year.
Clinic network lead: Build it. Wants two new clinics and the staff to run them.
IT director: Ride it. Wants to wait and buy, never build.
Board member: Ride it. Wants a plan that can stretch when the rules change.
Chief nursing officer: Fight for it. Wants retention money before any expansion.
HR director: Fight for it. Wants a training academy and a manager program.
Finance director: Brace for it. Wants reserves built and the new wing delayed.
Medical director: Brace for it. Wants the existing services funded first.
An example
The leadership team of a regional hospital group had argued through three meetings about its five-year plan. The head of strategy wanted the full expansion, the finance director wanted reserves and a delay on the new wing, and the chief nursing officer wanted the money spent on keeping nurses. Each thought the others had misread the numbers.
The facilitator taped two crossing lines on the floor and asked two questions in turn: is the future of our hospitals getting better or worse, and how much of it can we shape? The eight executives ended up two to a quadrant. Nobody had misread the numbers. The pair at better and in our hands wanted expansion, the pair at worse and out of our hands wanted reserves, and the pair at worse but in our hands wanted to spend on staff. Each quadrant explained itself while the others listened, and the plan that followed carried a version for each outlook, with the signs that would say which future was arriving.
Why it works
Planning disagreements often look like disputes about evidence when they are disputes about outlook. Two people can read the same forecast and argue for opposite plans, because one expects things to improve and the other does not, or one believes effort changes outcomes and the other does not. Those beliefs rarely get said aloud, so the argument loops over the numbers.
Standing on a floor grid makes the outlook visible, and nobody has to defend it in words first. The group sees at a glance that the room is split, and how. Once the split is named, each side's plan reads as a reasonable answer to a different future, and the work moves to which future the evidence supports.
The thinking behind it
Peter Hayward Peter Hayward, who taught in Swinburne University's strategic foresight program, devised the Polak Game, also called Where Do You Stand?, as a classroom and workshop exercise in which people take a physical position that shows their image of the future. He built it on Fred Polak's The Image of the Future, and with Stuart Candy he described the game in a 2017 article in the Journal of Futures Studies, The Polak Game, Or: Where Do You Stand?
Stuart Candy Stuart Candy, a futurist known for experiential futures, which stage possible futures as objects and scenes people can encounter, wrote up the game with Hayward in 2017. In their account, players place themselves on a grid of optimism and pessimism drawn from Polak's work. The game fits his wider aim of making ideas about the future something people meet with their bodies and senses, beyond a slide or a report.
Fred Polak Fred Polak, a Dutch futurologist and one of the founders of futures studies, published The Image of the Future in Dutch in 1955, with an English translation by Elise Boulding in 1961. The book argues that the alternative futures a culture imagines play a central part in shaping it. The game's two questions, whether things are getting better and whether people can influence them, come from his account of those images.
How to run it
Mark two crossing lines on the floor. Better to worse along one line, in our hands to out of our hands along the other.
Ask the first question alone. Is the future of this business getting better or worse? Everyone stands on the first line, without discussion.
Ask the second question. How much of that future can we shape? Everyone moves along the second line from where they stand.
Let each quadrant talk among itself. Ten minutes on what standing there means for the plan each person favors.
Have each quadrant report while the others listen. No rebuttals in this round; questions only to understand.
Write the split onto the plan. Record who stood where and what plan each outlook implies, so the disagreement stays visible.
Name what would move people. Ask each quadrant what evidence would make them step into another one.
Where it goes wrong
People stand where the boss stands. If the most senior person moves first, others cluster nearby. Have everyone write a position on a card before anyone moves, or ask the senior people to move last.
The game becomes the whole session. It is an opening move that names the split; without a next step, such as scenarios or a plan with versions, the group leaves knowing only that it disagrees.
Positions are read as personality. Labeling colleagues as optimists or pessimists hardens the split. Treat each position as a forecast that evidence can test, and ask what would change it.
When to use something else
Scenario Planning. When the next step is building several futures in detail and testing the plan against each.
Futures Triangle. When the group needs to weigh the pull of images of the future against the push of the present and the weight of the past.
Six Thinking Hats. When the dispute is over how to think through one proposal, and the group should take each mode in turn.