Originated by Geert Hofstede (Culture's Consequences, 1980), with the long-term orientation dimension from Michael Harris Bond (1987) and the sixth from Michael Minkov (Cultures and Organizations, third edition, with Geert Hofstede and Gert Jan Hofstede, 2010).
Compares national cultures on six dimensions, including power distance, individualism, and uncertainty avoidance, to anticipate where working norms will clash.
Two countries' scores on Hofstede's six dimensions, for a joint project team
The black line is the head-office country; the bars are the partner country, which the sliders set. Where a bar stands far from the line, the two halves of the team bring different defaults to meetings and decisions: who may contradict the boss, how much must be planned before starting, whether credit goes to people or to the group. The outputs count the gaps of 30 points or more, the ones to plan around. The scores are invented. Illustrative.
Partner countryHead-office country
An example
A medical-device company set up a joint project team with a contract manufacturer abroad to bring a new infusion pump into production. By month three the head-office engineers complained that the partner's staff never pushed back in meetings and then did something else, and the partner's managers complained that head office changed plans every week and expected juniors to argue with directors.
The project director pulled the two countries' published scores on Hofstede's six dimensions. Four gaps stood out at 30 points or more: power distance, individualism, uncertainty avoidance, and long-term orientation. Each matched a complaint. Junior engineers at the partner would not contradict a director in a meeting, so objections went unsaid. A high-uncertainty-avoidance team read weekly plan changes as a sign the project was out of control.
The team agreed three protocols. Design objections were collected in writing before meetings, without names. Changes to the plan were batched into a release every two weeks, each with a reason attached. And each technical decision named a single accountable owner on each side. The first lot shipped a week early.
Why it works
National cultures differ in a handful of deep defaults: how much inequality of power people accept, whether the individual or the group comes first, how uncomfortable ambiguity feels, and how far ahead people plan. These defaults shape ordinary working behavior, such as who speaks in meetings, how plans are made, and how decisions are owned, so people from different cultures clash over things each side considers simply normal.
Published scores turn that into something checkable before the friction starts. Comparing two cultures dimension by dimension shows where the defaults are close and where they are far apart, and each large gap predicts a recognizable kind of friction. The tool is a forecast for groups, so its value is in setting up protocols that bridge the gaps; it is weakest as a description of any single person.
The thinking behind it
Geert Hofstede Geert Hofstede, a Dutch social psychologist, drew on surveys of IBM employees in many countries to describe national cultures along dimensions such as power distance, individualism, and uncertainty avoidance, published in Culture's Consequences (1980). Critics argue the dimensions are national averages that explain little of individual behavior, should not be applied to individuals, and rest on a narrow original sample. Used as averages for planning how two groups will work together, they still give a team a shared vocabulary for its differences.
Michael Harris Bond Michael Harris Bond led the researchers who published as the Chinese Culture Connection, in Chinese Values and the Search for Culture-Free Dimensions of Culture (1987). Their survey, built from Chinese values instead of Western ones, found a dimension Hofstede had missed, which he added to his model as long-term orientation, first called Confucian dynamism. It was an early sign that the model depended on the values its questions were built from.
Michael Minkov Michael Minkov, a cross-cultural researcher, joined Geert Hofstede and Gert Jan Hofstede on the third edition of Cultures and Organizations: Software of the Mind (2010). That edition added a sixth dimension, indulgence versus restraint, drawn from his research: how freely a society allows people to enjoy life and act on their impulses. With it the model reached the six dimensions practitioners compare today.
How to run it
- Identify the cultures involved. List each national culture with a real say in how the work gets done, including the head office.
- Look up their published scores. Use the six dimensions, and note the source and date of the scores.
- Find the largest gaps. Mark the dimensions where the cultures sit far apart; a gap of 30 points or more usually shows up in daily work.
- Predict the friction each gap causes. Write how each gap will appear in meetings, planning, feedback, and decisions, from both sides.
- Agree protocols that bridge the gaps. Set working rules both sides can live with, such as written input before meetings or batched plan changes.
- Check against the real people. Ask the team whether the predictions fit them, and adjust for individuals who differ from their national average.
Where it goes wrong
The common failure is applying a national score to a person. A manager treats a colleague as a walking average and gets both the prediction and the relationship wrong. It shows up as people feeling stereotyped. The scores describe groups; use them to set team protocols, and learn individuals one by one.
A second failure is treating old scores as fixed. Cultures shift, and a team drawn from one industry or generation may sit far from its country's average. Treat the scores as a hypothesis to check in the first weeks. A third is stopping at insight: knowing that power distance differs changes nothing until a process changes how disagreement reaches the people who decide.
When to use something else
- Culture Map. When the question is day-to-day business behavior, such as giving feedback, persuading, and scheduling, on scales built for managers.
- Proxemics. When the friction is physical: how close people stand, how rooms are laid out, who sits where.
- Difficult Conversations. When the gaps have already produced a conflict between specific people and the work is talking it through.
Where it sits in SOLVE eX
Go to the source
- Culture's Consequences, 1980
- Chinese Culture Connection survey, 1987
- Cultures and Organizations: Software of the Mind, third edition, 2010