From the five-factor finding of Ernest C. Tupes and Raymond E. Christal (1961), named by Lewis R. Goldberg (1981), and turned into instruments by Oliver P. John, Eileen M. Donahue, and Robert L. Kentle (The Big Five Inventory, 1991), Paul T. Costa Jr. and Robert R. McCrae (1992), and Christopher J. Soto with John (2017).
Profiles a person on five continuous traits, openness, conscientiousness, extraversion, agreeableness, and neuroticism, giving a tested vocabulary for how people differ at work.
Set a new team lead's five trait levels and see which first assignment they favor
A newly promoted lead can take one of two first-quarter assignments: running the weekly client escalation calls, or leading the warehouse system rollout. Set each trait from her inventory as low (bottom third against the norm group), middle, or high. The lines under the rows say what each extreme level implies; the two verdicts weigh the traits each assignment leans on. These are tendencies: weigh them beside her skills and her own preference. Illustrative.
Open-mindedness
Conscientiousness
Extraversion
Agreeableness
Negative emotionality
- No trait at an extreme: decide on skills, interest, and what she wants to learn.Low extraversion: a day of calls drains her. If she takes the escalations, cap them at two blocks a week.High extraversion: the calls will energize her; make sure quieter colleagues still get airtime.High conscientiousness: she will hold a rollout plan to its dates; give her the cutover checklist.Low conscientiousness: pair her with a coordinator who owns the rollout's dates and loose ends.Low agreeableness: blunt with clients; useful in hard vendor talks, risky on escalation calls.High negative emotionality: angry clients every week will weigh on her; the rollout's steadier rhythm suits her better.High open-mindedness: she will question the rollout plan, which helps in design and wears on people at cutover.
- No trait at an extreme: decide on skills, interest, and what she wants to learn.Low extraversion: a day of calls drains her. If she takes the escalations, cap them at two blocks a week.High extraversion: the calls will energize her; make sure quieter colleagues still get airtime.High conscientiousness: she will hold a rollout plan to its dates; give her the cutover checklist.Low conscientiousness: pair her with a coordinator who owns the rollout's dates and loose ends.Low agreeableness: blunt with clients; useful in hard vendor talks, risky on escalation calls.High negative emotionality: angry clients every week will weigh on her; the rollout's steadier rhythm suits her better.High open-mindedness: she will question the rollout plan, which helps in design and wears on people at cutover.
- No trait at an extreme: decide on skills, interest, and what she wants to learn.Low extraversion: a day of calls drains her. If she takes the escalations, cap them at two blocks a week.High extraversion: the calls will energize her; make sure quieter colleagues still get airtime.High conscientiousness: she will hold a rollout plan to its dates; give her the cutover checklist.Low conscientiousness: pair her with a coordinator who owns the rollout's dates and loose ends.Low agreeableness: blunt with clients; useful in hard vendor talks, risky on escalation calls.High negative emotionality: angry clients every week will weigh on her; the rollout's steadier rhythm suits her better.High open-mindedness: she will question the rollout plan, which helps in design and wears on people at cutover.
- No trait at an extreme: decide on skills, interest, and what she wants to learn.Low extraversion: a day of calls drains her. If she takes the escalations, cap them at two blocks a week.High extraversion: the calls will energize her; make sure quieter colleagues still get airtime.High conscientiousness: she will hold a rollout plan to its dates; give her the cutover checklist.Low conscientiousness: pair her with a coordinator who owns the rollout's dates and loose ends.Low agreeableness: blunt with clients; useful in hard vendor talks, risky on escalation calls.High negative emotionality: angry clients every week will weigh on her; the rollout's steadier rhythm suits her better.High open-mindedness: she will question the rollout plan, which helps in design and wears on people at cutover.
- No trait at an extreme: decide on skills, interest, and what she wants to learn.Low extraversion: a day of calls drains her. If she takes the escalations, cap them at two blocks a week.High extraversion: the calls will energize her; make sure quieter colleagues still get airtime.High conscientiousness: she will hold a rollout plan to its dates; give her the cutover checklist.Low conscientiousness: pair her with a coordinator who owns the rollout's dates and loose ends.Low agreeableness: blunt with clients; useful in hard vendor talks, risky on escalation calls.High negative emotionality: angry clients every week will weigh on her; the rollout's steadier rhythm suits her better.High open-mindedness: she will question the rollout plan, which helps in design and wears on people at cutover.
- Low extraversion: a day of calls drains her. If she takes the escalations, cap them at two blocks a week. (e: Low)
- High extraversion: the calls will energize her; make sure quieter colleagues still get airtime. (e: High)
- High conscientiousness: she will hold a rollout plan to its dates; give her the cutover checklist. (c: High)
- Low conscientiousness: pair her with a coordinator who owns the rollout's dates and loose ends. (c: Low)
- Low agreeableness: blunt with clients; useful in hard vendor talks, risky on escalation calls. (a: Low)
- High negative emotionality: angry clients every week will weigh on her; the rollout's steadier rhythm suits her better. (n: High)
- High open-mindedness: she will question the rollout plan, which helps in design and wears on people at cutover. (o: High)
- Client escalation calls
- Pick every rowA stretch: plan supportPlays to her tendencies
- Warehouse system rollout
- Pick every rowA stretch: plan supportPlays to her tendencies
An example
A logistics company promoted a senior analyst to lead a team of nine, and her first-quarter assignment was open: run the weekly client escalation calls, or lead the warehouse system rollout. The department head leaned toward the calls, since the last two leads had been outgoing and had run them well. Before deciding, the head and the new lead read her five-trait inventory together with a coach.
Extraversion sat at the 30th percentile, and its facets split: sociability at the 15th, assertiveness at the 60th, so she found long days of calls draining and still spoke up when a decision mattered. Conscientiousness at the 88th and open-mindedness at the 72nd fit a rollout that needed a plan held to its dates and a design questioned early. Negative emotionality was low, so pressure from either job would not spill onto the team. She took the rollout, with two escalation calls a week to keep her close to clients, and a coach's warning that her questions about the plan would help in design and wear on people at cutover.
Why it works
People explain each other's behavior with labels, such as introvert or difficult, that are too blunt to act on and too fixed to change. The five traits replace the labels with a tested vocabulary: each is a continuous dimension, everyone sits somewhere on all five, and a score means something only against a norm group. A 30th percentile is a tendency, a little below the middle, and nothing like a type.
The facets add the detail that makes the profile useful. Two people with the same extraversion score can differ sharply in sociability and assertiveness, and those differences predict different behavior at work. Read as tendencies that situations shift, the scores point to adjustments in the role, such as meeting load or delegation habits, where a type would only point to a verdict on the person.
The thinking behind it
Ernest C. Tupes Ernest Tupes, a personnel psychologist with the United States Air Force at Lackland Air Force Base, found with Raymond Christal five recurring factors in peer ratings of officers: surgency, agreeableness, dependability, emotional stability, and culture. Their technical report, Recurrent Personality Factors Based on Trait Ratings (1961), was reprinted in the Journal of Personality in 1992 and is an early statement of what became the five-factor model.
Lewis R. Goldberg Lewis Goldberg, a personality psychologist at the University of Oregon and the Oregon Research Institute, is associated with the lexical hypothesis: the personality traits that matter most to people are encoded in everyday language. He coined the name Big Five in Language and Individual Differences (1981) and, in An Alternative Description of Personality (1990), showed the five factors recurring across large sets of trait words.
Christopher J. Soto Christopher Soto, a personality psychologist, developed with Oliver John the BFI-2 (2017), a 60-item revision of the Big Five Inventory that John and colleagues first published in 1991. The revision measures the five broad domains and fifteen facets beneath them, three per domain, which their paper argued would add both detail and predictive power. The facets are what let a reader separate, for instance, sociability from assertiveness within one extraversion score.
How to run it
- Use a validated instrument. Pick a published, tested inventory such as the BFI-2, and skip quizzes that sort people into types.
- Read each score as a percentile. Compare it with the norm group the instrument reports, and treat the middle third as ordinary.
- Look under the broad scores. Check the facets, which often explain behavior the domain score hides.
- Translate scores into tendencies. Write how each extreme score may show in this role, and how it may not.
- Ask the person. Read the results together and let the person say where the description fits and where it does not.
- Adjust the role around the tendencies. Change meeting load, delegation, or pairing to suit the tendencies, and review after a quarter.
- Keep it one input among several. Weigh traits beside skills, values, and track record in any decision about the person.
Where it goes wrong
The most common failure is turning scores into types. A 30th percentile on extraversion becomes she is an introvert, and the label hardens into a reason to keep her out of client meetings. Keep the number and its facets in the conversation, and the label out.
The second is using the profile to select or reject people. Trait scores predict only part of performance and are easy to misuse in hiring or promotion. Use it for development and team design, beside evidence of what the person has done.
The third is reading broad scores alone. Domain scores average facets that can point in opposite directions. When a score seems to contradict what colleagues see, look at the facets before doubting either.
When to use something else
- Culture Map. When the differences that cause friction come from national working cultures more than individual temperament.
- Johari Window. When the goal is narrowing the gap between how someone sees themselves and how colleagues see them.
- Hofstede's Cultural Dimensions. When the comparison is between groups or countries, and no single person is the subject.
Where it sits in SOLVE eX
Go to the source
- Recurrent Personality Factors Based on Trait Ratings, USAF ASD Technical Report 61-97, 1961
- An alternative description of personality: The Big-Five factor structure, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1990
- The Big Five Inventory: Versions 4a and 54, Institute of Personality and Social Research, University of California, Berkeley, 1991
- Revised NEO Personality Inventory (NEO PI-R) and NEO Five-Factor Inventory (NEO-FFI) Professional Manual, 1992
- The next Big Five Inventory (BFI-2): Developing and assessing a hierarchical model with 15 facets, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 2017
- Language and Individual Differences: The Search for Universals in Personality Lexicons, Review of Personality and Social Psychology, vol. 2, ed. L. Wheeler, 1981