From accounting standard-setting, set out in the Financial Accounting Standards Board's Statement of Financial Accounting Concepts No. 1 (1978), with the gap read for warning signs by Howard M. Schilit (Financial Shenanigans, 1993).
Compares when cash actually moves with when revenue and costs are booked, and treats the gap between the two as the first place to look for trouble.
Profit is booked when the goods ship; the cash arrives three months later
A distributor of restaurant supplies growing 20 percent a quarter, earning 8 cents of profit on each dollar of sales. The black line is net income; the bars are the cash its operations actually brought in. Set how long customers take to pay and how fast sales grow: with quick payment the bars sit near the line, and as payment stretches the bars drop below zero while profit keeps rising, because each quarter's sales sit unpaid in receivables. Illustrative.
Cash from operations, $MNet income, $M
An example
A distributor of restaurant supplies won a run of new accounts and grew sales about 20 percent a quarter for a year and a half. Every quarter it reported a profit, eight cents on each dollar of sales, and the owners were pleased with the trend. Then the bank called about the credit line, which was nearly drawn.
The new controller set net income beside cash from operations, quarter by quarter. The two had parted company from the first quarter of the growth run. The new accounts were restaurant groups that paid in ninety days, so each quarter's sales sat in receivables while the distributor paid its own suppliers in thirty. Over six quarters the business booked about $8 million of profit and used about $9 million of cash. Nothing was wrong with the accounting; the profit was real and still uncollected. The fix was commercial: a two percent discount for payment in thirty days, deposits from new accounts, and a growth plan the credit line could carry.
Why it works
Accrual accounting books revenue when it is earned and costs when they are incurred, which makes profit a good measure of how the business performed over a period. Cash accounting records money only when it moves, which makes it a good measure of whether the business can pay its bills. Most of the time the two tell the same story a little apart in time. When they diverge, the gap is information.
Some gaps are healthy, such as receivables growing with sales in a business whose customers pay reliably. Some are warnings: receivables growing faster than sales, inventory piling up, or costs capitalized that used to be expensed. Reading the gap tells which. A growing business is especially exposed, because it books profit on this quarter's sales while it waits for last quarter's cash, so the faster it grows, the more cash it needs.
The thinking behind it
Howard M. Schilit Howard M. Schilit, an accounting analyst, wrote Financial Shenanigans: How to Detect Accounting Gimmicks and Fraud in Financial Reports (McGraw-Hill, 1993, later revised). It catalogs the accounting gimmicks companies use to distort reported earnings and the ways a reader of financial reports can detect them. A gap that opens between reported profit and the cash it should produce is among the first places such a reader looks, which is why the comparison on this page is a diligence habit as well as a management one. The cash and accrual bases themselves belong to the accounting profession and its standard setters, not to one author.
How to run it
- Decide the question. Profitability, survival, or long-run value each lean on a different statement, so say which one matters now.
- Set net income beside cash from operations. Line them up period by period for at least four quarters.
- Find where profit did not become cash. The cash flow statement shows the movement in receivables, inventory, payables, and deferred items.
- Trace each gap to its cause. Slow-paying customers, stock building ahead of sales, costs capitalized, or revenue booked before delivery.
- Compare the gap with the growth. Receivables growing in step with sales is normal; growing faster than sales is a question for the collections team.
- Track the gap over time. A gap that persists or widens for three quarters needs an explanation in writing.
- Act on the cause. Change terms, deposits, stock levels, or the pace of growth so the cash the business needs is planned.
Where it goes wrong
The common failure is reading profit alone because it is the number in the headline. A business can report a profit every quarter and still run out of cash; the bank notices before the owners do. Put the two lines on the same page every month.
A second failure is treating every gap as trouble. A fast-growing business with reliable customers will always show cash lagging profit; the question is whether the lag matches the payment terms. Compare receivables with sales and with the terms before raising the alarm. The third is reading one quarter. Timing effects, such as a large order shipped on the last day, swing a single period; the pattern across several quarters is what carries meaning.
When to use something else
- Balance Sheet Thinking. When the question is what a decision does to the stocks of assets and debt, beyond the timing of cash.
- Stock-and-Flow Models. When the build-up of receivables or inventory needs modeling as a stock that fills and drains over time.
- KPI Design. When the fix is choosing the measures that will show the gap early, such as days of sales outstanding.
Where it sits in SOLVE eX
Go to the source
- Statement of Financial Accounting Concepts No. 1: Objectives of Financial Reporting by Business Enterprises, Financial Accounting Standards Board, 1978
- Financial Shenanigans: How to Detect Accounting Gimmicks and Fraud in Financial Reports, 1993