Originated by Robert Torrens (An Essay on the External Corn Trade, 1815) and David Ricardo (On the Principles of Political Economy and Taxation, 1817).
Assigns each task to whoever gives up the least to do it, which lets both parties gain even when one is better at everything.
The senior is faster at both tasks, and the team still does more when the junior takes the slides
Two consultants, forty hours a week each, owe the client ten slide decks a week and as many analyses as they can manage. Set the hours each needs per task: the outputs give what one analysis costs each of them in decks given up, and the point shows who gives up less. Give the analysis to that person and the decks to the other, and the team beats splitting the decks evenly, even when one is faster at everything. Illustrative.
Who takes the analysisThe junior gives up less for each analysis: the junior takes the analysis, the senior takes the decks.The senior gives up less for each analysis: the senior takes the analysis, the junior takes the decks.
An example
A two-person team at a small strategy firm owed a client ten slide decks a week on a pricing project, plus as many market analyses as they could turn out. The senior consultant was faster at everything: an analysis took her four hours and a deck two, while the junior needed twelve and three. They had been splitting the decks evenly, five each, and spending the rest of their time on analysis.
The engagement manager worked out what each task cost each person in the other task. For the senior, one analysis meant two decks not made; for the junior, it meant four. The senior was the cheaper analyst, and so the junior was the cheaper deck maker, even though he was slower at both. The junior took all ten decks, which filled thirty of his hours, and the senior moved to analysis full time. The team went from about nine and a half analyses a week to nearly eleven, with the same people and the same hours.
Why it works
The intuitive rule is to give each task to whoever is best at it. When one person is best at everything, that rule gives them everything, and the rest of the team waits. Comparative advantage replaces the question "who is faster?" with "who gives up less?" Every hour the senior spends on decks is an hour taken from analysis, where her lead is largest. Every hour the junior spends on decks costs little, because his analysis is slow.
The arithmetic always finds a division that helps, unless the two have exactly the same ratio of costs. Each party ends up doing the task where their disadvantage is smallest or their advantage largest, and the combined output rises. The same logic sets how work divides between teams, between a company and its suppliers, and between partners in an alliance.
The thinking behind it
David Ricardo David Ricardo, a classical economist, set out comparative advantage in his Principles of Political Economy (1817). He argued that two countries both gain from trade when each specializes in what it produces at the lower opportunity cost, even if one of them is better at producing everything. The principle carried from nations to firms and teams because it rests on nothing but the costs each party gives up.
Robert Torrens Robert Torrens, an Irish-born economist and Royal Marines officer, gave an early statement of the same idea in An Essay on the External Corn Trade (1815), two years before Ricardo's Principles; an anonymous pamphlet of 1814 is earlier still. His version: a country gains by importing goods it could make itself, when it can obtain them more cheaply by exporting what it makes with greater relative efficiency.
How to run it
- List the tasks and the people. Keep to the tasks that compete for the same hours; two or three is enough to see the pattern.
- Estimate each person's time per task. Use recent work, not titles; a rough figure in hours is enough.
- Compute what each task costs each person. Divide the hours for one task by the hours for the other, so the cost reads as units of the other task given up.
- Give each task to whoever gives up less. The person with the lowest cost in one task takes it, and the other person takes the remaining task.
- Check the totals against the old split. Count the team's combined output both ways, so the gain is shown in numbers.
- Check that each person is better off. Make sure nobody carries only the dull work for long; rotate or reward where needed.
- Revisit as skills change. Training the junior changes the ratios, and the division should change with them.
Where it goes wrong
The common failure is assigning work by absolute speed. The strongest performer keeps every task because they do each one best, becomes the bottleneck, and the team's output stalls. Work out what each task costs each person in the other before assigning.
A second failure is a division that locks people in. A junior who only ever makes decks never gets faster at analysis, so the gap that justified the split becomes permanent. Plan some rotation for learning, and accept a small loss of output for it. The third is ignoring switching costs: when tasks interleave tightly, the hand-offs can eat the gain. Count the hours lost to hand-offs before reorganizing.
When to use something else
- Opportunity Cost Reasoning. When the choice is one use of a resource against its best alternative, with no division of work involved.
- Theory of Constraints. When one person or step limits the whole team's output and the work is relieving that constraint.
- Linear Programming. When there are many tasks, people, and limits at once, and the best division needs solving.
Where it sits in SOLVE eX
Go to the source
- On the Principles of Political Economy and Taxation, 1817
- An Essay on the External Corn Trade, 1815