Developed by William R. Miller (Motivational Interviewing with Problem Drinkers, 1983) and, with Stephen Rollnick, set out in Motivational Interviewing: Helping People Change (third edition, 2013).
A conversation method that draws out a person's own reasons to change through open questions, affirmations, reflections, and summaries, then builds on them until a plan emerges.
A talk about missed targets, run on open questions, affirmations, reflections, and a summary
At each of the manager's turns, pick a line: one of the four moves, or the urge to fix it for him (argue, advise, assign). The rep's answer shows, and the bar tracks how far he has made his own case for changing. Illustrative.
Manager
Sales rep
Manager
Sales rep
His own case for change0of 5
- The opening (Manager). The rep is at 60 percent of target for the second quarter running. Pick the manager's opening.
- You know you're at 60 percent of target again, right? Yes. I know. Closed: a fact he already knows, and a one-word answer.
- Let's talk about what you need to do differently. Okay. What do you want me to do? The fix-it reflex: the plan is now the manager's, not his.
- How has this quarter felt from where you sit? Rough. The territory got bigger and the leads got worse. Open question: he tells his side, and the talk is about his view.
- His side (Sales rep). He starts with the reasons it was not his fault. That is normal; arguing with them now would make him defend them.
- A reflection (Manager). Pick the manager's reply.
- Everyone got new territory, and most of them are at target. Sure. I guess I'm just worse at it, then. An argument: he digs in, and now he is defending himself.
- You've been covering more ground with less to work with. Yeah. And honestly, I've been chasing the big accounts because they're more fun. A reflection: he feels heard, and he offers his own part in it.
- His own part (Sales rep). Without being asked, he has named something he does that he could change.
- An affirmation (Manager). Pick the manager's reply.
- Right, so start calling the mid-size accounts tomorrow. Fine. I'll try. Advice too soon: a weak promise to end the conversation.
- That's an honest read of your own pipeline. If I'd worked the mid-size list, I'd probably be at 80 percent. And I'd sleep better. An affirmation: it rewards the candor, and he gives two reasons to change.
- His reasons (Sales rep). Two reasons for changing, both his. The manager has not argued for anything.
- A summary (Manager). Pick how the manager pulls it together.
- So the big deals stalled, and you think mid-size accounts would close the gap. Fair? Yes. I could block Tuesday and Thursday mornings for them. A summary of his own words: he hears his case whole and moves to act.
- Great, so we agree you'll make forty calls a week. Forty? Okay, if that's the number. An assignment: the number is the manager's, and so is the plan.
- Readiness (Sales rep). He has moved from reasons to a step. Now, and not before, it is time to plan.
- Planning (Manager). Pick the manager's next line.
- I'll put it in your goals and check it every week. Sure. Taken over: his plan becomes a target set for him.
- What would make those two mornings stick? Blocking them on my calendar, and you not booking me into meetings then. An open question: he builds the plan and names what he needs.
- His plan (Sales rep). Two mornings a week on mid-size accounts, kept clear of meetings. He made the case and the plan himself.
An example
A regional sales manager at an equipment distributor had a rep at 60 percent of target for the second quarter running. The previous review had been a list of fixes, forty calls a week and a pipeline report every Friday, and nothing had moved.
This time she asked how the quarter had felt from his side. He blamed the bigger territory and weaker leads. She reflected that he had been covering more ground with less, and he volunteered that he had been chasing the large accounts because they were more interesting. She credited the honesty, and he added that working the mid-size list would probably have put him near 80 percent, and that he would sleep better. She summarized his case back to him, and he proposed blocking two mornings a week for mid-size calls. Her only planning question was what would make those mornings stick.
He asked her to stop booking him into meetings on those mornings. The next quarter he finished at 84 percent.
Why it works
A person who is unsure about changing carries arguments on both sides. When a manager argues for the change, the person instinctively answers with the other side, and each round of advice strengthens the case for staying put. Motivational interviewing turns that around: it asks open questions, reflects and affirms what the person says, and listens for their own reasons, so the case for changing is made in their words.
People tend to believe what they hear themselves argue. A plan they proposed is one they will defend; a plan handed to them is one they will comply with until the pressure eases. The method's discipline is restraint: holding back the urge to fix the problem for the person until readiness shows in what the person says.
The thinking behind it
William R. Miller William R. Miller, a clinical psychologist at the University of New Mexico, first described motivational interviewing in Motivational Interviewing with Problem Drinkers (1983), a paper in Behavioural Psychotherapy. The approach he and Stephen Rollnick went on to found draws out a person's own reasons for change instead of confronting the person with the case against their behavior, so the argument for changing comes from the one who has to change.
Stephen Rollnick Stephen Rollnick, a clinical psychologist at Cardiff University, developed the method with Miller in Motivational Interviewing (1991) and later editions. Their third edition, Motivational Interviewing: Helping People Change (2013), frames it as help for resolving ambivalence, and describes change talk, the person's own statements of desire, ability, reasons, and need for change, which the counselor listens for and then strengthens in the conversation.
How to run it
- Ask open questions. Start with questions that need a story, such as how the quarter felt, not whether they know the number.
- Reflect what you hear. Say back the meaning of what they said, which shows you listened and invites them to go further.
- Affirm what is real. Credit honesty, effort, or a strength they showed, specifically and without flattery.
- Agree on the focus. Settle together which change the conversation is about, so it does not drift.
- Listen for their reasons. When they say why changing would help, reflect it and ask for more.
- Summarize their case. Gather the reasons they gave and say them back as one statement.
- Plan only when they are ready. When they start talking about doing, ask what they will do and what would help it stick.
Where it goes wrong
The manager slips back into advice. The urge to fix is strongest in people who are paid to fix things, and a single "so just do X" hands the plan back to the manager. When you feel the urge, ask a question instead.
The method is used as a disguise. A manager who has already decided the outcome and uses reflections to steer toward it is running a persuasion script, and people detect it. Use it when you genuinely want their view of the change.
It is used where the issue is not ambivalence. A rep who lacks the skill or the tools needs training or resources, not conversation about motivation. Check first that the person could change if they wanted to.
When to use something else
- Change Talk. When the conversation is already open and the job is to hear and strengthen each kind of change talk.
- Crucial Conversations. When the person does not yet accept that there is a problem, and the facts must be put on the table.
- Miracle Question. When the person is stuck on what is wrong and needs a picture of what better looks like.
Where it sits in SOLVE eX
Go to the source
- Motivational Interviewing with Problem Drinkers, 1983
- Motivational Interviewing: Helping People Change, Guilford Press, third edition; first edition 1991, 2013