Thinking Tools2.1 Finding the Reasons to ResolveAlso known as DARN-CAT, Eliciting Change Talk
From the motivational interviewing of William R. Miller and Stephen Rollnick (Motivational Interviewing, third edition, 2013), with the commitment-language research of Paul C. Amrhein (2003).
Listens for a person's own statements of desire, ability, reasons, need, commitment, activation, and steps taken toward change, and draws each one out further.
Eight things a manager said about delegating, sorted by the kind of change talk
A coach listens for the manager's own words for change. The bottom row is talk that builds the case for changing; the top row is talk that moves toward doing it; one box holds the case against. One statement is placed as an example. Select each other statement, then its box: each one shows the reflection that draws it out further. Illustrative.
Items (select one, then a box)
Not placedPlacedDesireAbilityReasonsNeedCommitActivationStepsSustain talk
Not placedPlacedDesireAbilityReasonsNeedCommitActivationStepsSustain talk
Not placedPlacedDesireAbilityReasonsNeedCommitActivationStepsSustain talk
Not placedPlacedDesireAbilityReasonsNeedCommitActivationStepsSustain talk
Not placedPlacedDesireAbilityReasonsNeedCommitActivationStepsSustain talk
Not placedPlacedDesireAbilityReasonsNeedCommitActivationStepsSustain talk
Not placedPlacedDesireAbilityReasonsNeedCommitActivationStepsSustain talk
Not placedPlacedDesireAbilityReasonsNeedCommitActivationStepsSustain talk
Stage
Moving to actPreparing
Commit
Activation
Steps
Sustain talk
Desire
Ability
Reasons
Need
D and CA and AR and TN, or sustain
The letters of DARN CAT, bottom row then top
Not the bottleneck. "I'd like to stop being the bottleneck on every decision."Not placed yet.Not the bottleneck. "I'd like to stop being the bottleneck on every decision."Desire: Wanting the change: I want, I'd like, I wish. Reflect the want back so the manager hears it in his own words.A want, in his words. The coach reflects: "You'd like decisions to move without waiting on you."Not the bottleneck. "I'd like to stop being the bottleneck on every decision."Ability: Seeing it as possible: I could, I might be able to. Ask how, which makes the possibility concrete.Not the bottleneck. "I'd like to stop being the bottleneck on every decision."Reasons: A specific benefit of changing: if I did, then. Ask for more reasons; each one adds weight.Not the bottleneck. "I'd like to stop being the bottleneck on every decision."Need: A sense that it has to happen: I have to, I need to. Reflect the urgency without adding to it.Not the bottleneck. "I'd like to stop being the bottleneck on every decision."Commit: A statement of intent: I will, I'm going to. Pin down what and when.Not the bottleneck. "I'd like to stop being the bottleneck on every decision."Activation: Readiness short of a promise: I'm ready, I'm willing. Ask what the first step would be.Not the bottleneck. "I'd like to stop being the bottleneck on every decision."Steps: Something already done toward the change. Affirm it: it is evidence he can do this.Not the bottleneck. "I'd like to stop being the bottleneck on every decision."Sustain talk: The case for staying as he is. Not change talk: reflect it without arguing, then ask about the other side.Dana could do the report. "Dana could probably handle the weekly client report."Not placed yet.Dana could do the report. "Dana could probably handle the weekly client report."Desire: Wanting the change: I want, I'd like, I wish. Reflect the want back so the manager hears it in his own words.Dana could do the report. "Dana could probably handle the weekly client report."Ability: Seeing it as possible: I could, I might be able to. Ask how, which makes the possibility concrete.He sees it as possible. The coach asks: "How would you set her up to do it?"Dana could do the report. "Dana could probably handle the weekly client report."Reasons: A specific benefit of changing: if I did, then. Ask for more reasons; each one adds weight.Dana could do the report. "Dana could probably handle the weekly client report."Need: A sense that it has to happen: I have to, I need to. Reflect the urgency without adding to it.Dana could do the report. "Dana could probably handle the weekly client report."Commit: A statement of intent: I will, I'm going to. Pin down what and when.Dana could do the report. "Dana could probably handle the weekly client report."Activation: Readiness short of a promise: I'm ready, I'm willing. Ask what the first step would be.Dana could do the report. "Dana could probably handle the weekly client report."Steps: Something already done toward the change. Affirm it: it is evidence he can do this.Dana could do the report. "Dana could probably handle the weekly client report."Sustain talk: The case for staying as he is. Not change talk: reflect it without arguing, then ask about the other side.Time for the hiring plan. "If I handed things off, I'd finally have time for the hiring plan."Not placed yet.Time for the hiring plan. "If I handed things off, I'd finally have time for the hiring plan."Desire: Wanting the change: I want, I'd like, I wish. Reflect the want back so the manager hears it in his own words.Time for the hiring plan. "If I handed things off, I'd finally have time for the hiring plan."Ability: Seeing it as possible: I could, I might be able to. Ask how, which makes the possibility concrete.Time for the hiring plan. "If I handed things off, I'd finally have time for the hiring plan."Reasons: A specific benefit of changing: if I did, then. Ask for more reasons; each one adds weight.A concrete benefit. The coach asks: "What else would you do with that time?"Time for the hiring plan. "If I handed things off, I'd finally have time for the hiring plan."Need: A sense that it has to happen: I have to, I need to. Reflect the urgency without adding to it.Time for the hiring plan. "If I handed things off, I'd finally have time for the hiring plan."Commit: A statement of intent: I will, I'm going to. Pin down what and when.Time for the hiring plan. "If I handed things off, I'd finally have time for the hiring plan."Activation: Readiness short of a promise: I'm ready, I'm willing. Ask what the first step would be.Time for the hiring plan. "If I handed things off, I'd finally have time for the hiring plan."Steps: Something already done toward the change. Affirm it: it is evidence he can do this.Time for the hiring plan. "If I handed things off, I'd finally have time for the hiring plan."Sustain talk: The case for staying as he is. Not change talk: reflect it without arguing, then ask about the other side.Out of the weeds by fall. "I have to get out of the weeds before the reorg in the fall."Not placed yet.Out of the weeds by fall. "I have to get out of the weeds before the reorg in the fall."Desire: Wanting the change: I want, I'd like, I wish. Reflect the want back so the manager hears it in his own words.Out of the weeds by fall. "I have to get out of the weeds before the reorg in the fall."Ability: Seeing it as possible: I could, I might be able to. Ask how, which makes the possibility concrete.Out of the weeds by fall. "I have to get out of the weeds before the reorg in the fall."Reasons: A specific benefit of changing: if I did, then. Ask for more reasons; each one adds weight.Out of the weeds by fall. "I have to get out of the weeds before the reorg in the fall."Need: A sense that it has to happen: I have to, I need to. Reflect the urgency without adding to it.Urgency he feels himself. The coach reflects it, "The reorg makes this pressing", and adds no pressure of her own.Out of the weeds by fall. "I have to get out of the weeds before the reorg in the fall."Commit: A statement of intent: I will, I'm going to. Pin down what and when.Out of the weeds by fall. "I have to get out of the weeds before the reorg in the fall."Activation: Readiness short of a promise: I'm ready, I'm willing. Ask what the first step would be.Out of the weeds by fall. "I have to get out of the weeds before the reorg in the fall."Steps: Something already done toward the change. Affirm it: it is evidence he can do this.Out of the weeds by fall. "I have to get out of the weeds before the reorg in the fall."Sustain talk: The case for staying as he is. Not change talk: reflect it without arguing, then ask about the other side.Nobody knows the client. "Nobody else knows this client the way I do."Not placed yet.Nobody knows the client. "Nobody else knows this client the way I do."Desire: Wanting the change: I want, I'd like, I wish. Reflect the want back so the manager hears it in his own words.Nobody knows the client. "Nobody else knows this client the way I do."Ability: Seeing it as possible: I could, I might be able to. Ask how, which makes the possibility concrete.Nobody knows the client. "Nobody else knows this client the way I do."Reasons: A specific benefit of changing: if I did, then. Ask for more reasons; each one adds weight.Nobody knows the client. "Nobody else knows this client the way I do."Need: A sense that it has to happen: I have to, I need to. Reflect the urgency without adding to it.Nobody knows the client. "Nobody else knows this client the way I do."Commit: A statement of intent: I will, I'm going to. Pin down what and when.Nobody knows the client. "Nobody else knows this client the way I do."Activation: Readiness short of a promise: I'm ready, I'm willing. Ask what the first step would be.Nobody knows the client. "Nobody else knows this client the way I do."Steps: Something already done toward the change. Affirm it: it is evidence he can do this.Nobody knows the client. "Nobody else knows this client the way I do."Sustain talk: The case for staying as he is. Not change talk: reflect it without arguing, then ask about the other side.The case for staying put. Arguing would make him defend it; the coach reflects it and asks what Dana does know.Ready to try one task. "I'm willing to try it with one task and see."Not placed yet.Ready to try one task. "I'm willing to try it with one task and see."Desire: Wanting the change: I want, I'd like, I wish. Reflect the want back so the manager hears it in his own words.Ready to try one task. "I'm willing to try it with one task and see."Ability: Seeing it as possible: I could, I might be able to. Ask how, which makes the possibility concrete.Ready to try one task. "I'm willing to try it with one task and see."Reasons: A specific benefit of changing: if I did, then. Ask for more reasons; each one adds weight.Ready to try one task. "I'm willing to try it with one task and see."Need: A sense that it has to happen: I have to, I need to. Reflect the urgency without adding to it.Ready to try one task. "I'm willing to try it with one task and see."Commit: A statement of intent: I will, I'm going to. Pin down what and when.Ready to try one task. "I'm willing to try it with one task and see."Activation: Readiness short of a promise: I'm ready, I'm willing. Ask what the first step would be.Ready, not yet promised. The coach asks: "Which task would you start with?"Ready to try one task. "I'm willing to try it with one task and see."Steps: Something already done toward the change. Affirm it: it is evidence he can do this.Ready to try one task. "I'm willing to try it with one task and see."Sustain talk: The case for staying as he is. Not change talk: reflect it without arguing, then ask about the other side.Showed Dana the data. "I already showed Dana where the report data lives."Not placed yet.Showed Dana the data. "I already showed Dana where the report data lives."Desire: Wanting the change: I want, I'd like, I wish. Reflect the want back so the manager hears it in his own words.Showed Dana the data. "I already showed Dana where the report data lives."Ability: Seeing it as possible: I could, I might be able to. Ask how, which makes the possibility concrete.Showed Dana the data. "I already showed Dana where the report data lives."Reasons: A specific benefit of changing: if I did, then. Ask for more reasons; each one adds weight.Showed Dana the data. "I already showed Dana where the report data lives."Need: A sense that it has to happen: I have to, I need to. Reflect the urgency without adding to it.Showed Dana the data. "I already showed Dana where the report data lives."Commit: A statement of intent: I will, I'm going to. Pin down what and when.Showed Dana the data. "I already showed Dana where the report data lives."Activation: Readiness short of a promise: I'm ready, I'm willing. Ask what the first step would be.Showed Dana the data. "I already showed Dana where the report data lives."Steps: Something already done toward the change. Affirm it: it is evidence he can do this.A step already taken. The coach affirms it: he has started.Showed Dana the data. "I already showed Dana where the report data lives."Sustain talk: The case for staying as he is. Not change talk: reflect it without arguing, then ask about the other side.Giving her the report. "I'm going to give Dana the report starting this month."Not placed yet.Giving her the report. "I'm going to give Dana the report starting this month."Desire: Wanting the change: I want, I'd like, I wish. Reflect the want back so the manager hears it in his own words.Giving her the report. "I'm going to give Dana the report starting this month."Ability: Seeing it as possible: I could, I might be able to. Ask how, which makes the possibility concrete.Giving her the report. "I'm going to give Dana the report starting this month."Reasons: A specific benefit of changing: if I did, then. Ask for more reasons; each one adds weight.Giving her the report. "I'm going to give Dana the report starting this month."Need: A sense that it has to happen: I have to, I need to. Reflect the urgency without adding to it.Giving her the report. "I'm going to give Dana the report starting this month."Commit: A statement of intent: I will, I'm going to. Pin down what and when.A commitment. The coach pins it down: "Which week, and how will you check in?"Giving her the report. "I'm going to give Dana the report starting this month."Activation: Readiness short of a promise: I'm ready, I'm willing. Ask what the first step would be.Giving her the report. "I'm going to give Dana the report starting this month."Steps: Something already done toward the change. Affirm it: it is evidence he can do this.Giving her the report. "I'm going to give Dana the report starting this month."Sustain talk: The case for staying as he is. Not change talk: reflect it without arguing, then ask about the other side.
Your sort matched 0 of 8.Your sort matched 1 of 8.Your sort matched 2 of 8.Your sort matched 3 of 8.Your sort matched 4 of 8.Your sort matched 5 of 8.Your sort matched 6 of 8.Your sort matched 7 of 8.Your sort matched 8 of 8.
Desire
Wanting the change: I want, I'd like, I wish. Reflect the want back so the manager hears it in his own words.
Ability
Seeing it as possible: I could, I might be able to. Ask how, which makes the possibility concrete.
Reasons
A specific benefit of changing: if I did, then. Ask for more reasons; each one adds weight.
Need
A sense that it has to happen: I have to, I need to. Reflect the urgency without adding to it.
Commit
A statement of intent: I will, I'm going to. Pin down what and when.
Activation
Readiness short of a promise: I'm ready, I'm willing. Ask what the first step would be.
Steps
Something already done toward the change. Affirm it: it is evidence he can do this.
Sustain talk
The case for staying as he is. Not change talk: reflect it without arguing, then ask about the other side.
The sort
Not the bottleneck: Desire. A want, in his words. The coach reflects: "You'd like decisions to move without waiting on you."
Dana could do the report: Ability. He sees it as possible. The coach asks: "How would you set her up to do it?"
Time for the hiring plan: Reasons. A concrete benefit. The coach asks: "What else would you do with that time?"
Out of the weeds by fall: Need. Urgency he feels himself. The coach reflects it, "The reorg makes this pressing", and adds no pressure of her own.
Nobody knows the client: Sustain talk. The case for staying put. Arguing would make him defend it; the coach reflects it and asks what Dana does know.
Ready to try one task: Activation. Ready, not yet promised. The coach asks: "Which task would you start with?"
Showed Dana the data: Steps. A step already taken. The coach affirms it: he has started.
Giving her the report: Commit. A commitment. The coach pins it down: "Which week, and how will you check in?"
An example
A sales director had told one of his regional managers twice that he needed to delegate more, and both times the manager agreed and changed nothing. The company's internal coach took a different approach in their next session: she stopped making the case and started listening for his.
Within twenty minutes he had said he would like to stop being the bottleneck, that one of his leads, Dana, could probably handle the weekly client report, and that he had to get out of the weeds before the fall reorganization. He also said nobody else knew the biggest client the way he did. The coach reflected each pro-change statement back in his words and asked for more, and reflected the objection without arguing with it. By the end he mentioned that he had already shown Dana where the report data lived.
He left having said, in his own words, that he would hand over the report that month and check in with her after the first two.
Why it works
People who are ambivalent about a change hold both arguments at once. When someone else argues for the change, the ambivalent person supplies the other side, and every round of persuasion strengthens the case against. Change talk works in the opposite direction: the listener waits for the person's own statements in favor of changing and makes them bigger by reflecting them and asking for more.
What people hear themselves say shapes what they come to believe, so a case built from their own words carries a weight that a manager's argument never will. Sorting the statements by kind tells the listener where the person is. Desire, ability, reasons, and need build the case; commitment, readiness, and steps taken signal movement toward acting. A listener who hears only the first kind knows it is too early to ask for a plan.
The thinking behind it
William R. Miller William R. Miller, a psychologist at the University of New Mexico, founded motivational interviewing with Stephen Rollnick: a counseling style that draws out a person's own reasons for changing instead of confronting them. The third edition of their Motivational Interviewing (2013) describes change talk, the client's own statements of desire, ability, reasons, and need for change, as the thing the counselor listens for and strengthens.
Paul C. Amrhein Paul C. Amrhein, a psychologist at Montclair State University, coded what 84 drug users said during motivational interviews in a study with Miller and colleagues, published in 2003. The strength of commitment language as clients reviewed a change plan predicted later abstinence, and statements of desire, ability, need, and reasons predicted that commitment. A later study of marijuana treatment found that commitment language did not predict outcomes, though desire and reasons statements did.
How to run it
Listen for the kinds. Hear each statement as desire, ability, reasons, need, commitment, readiness, steps taken, or the case against.
Reflect it in their words. Say back what they said, a little more firmly, using their phrase, not yours.
Ask for more. Follow a reason with "what else?" and an ability with "how would you do it?"
Leave the case against alone. Reflect an objection without arguing, which keeps it from hardening, then ask about the other side.
Affirm steps already taken. Name what they have done, since it is evidence they can do more.
Summarize the case so far. Gather their reasons in one statement and let them hear it whole.
Ask about commitment last. Wait until the talk shifts toward acting before asking what they will do and when.
Where it goes wrong
The listener argues anyway. The urge to correct the case against ("but Dana knows the client fine") is strong in a manager, and it turns the conversation back into persuasion. If you notice yourself building an argument, reflect what they just said.
Reflections become parroting. Repeating every phrase word for word sounds mechanical, and the person stops elaborating. Reflect the meaning, and choose the change talk to reflect, not everything.
The listener asks for commitment too early. A person still voicing reasons and needs who is pressed for a plan will make a soft promise to end the pressure, and soft promises rarely hold. Wait for the language to move toward I will and I'm ready.
When to use something else
Motivational Interviewing. When the whole conversation needs structure, from building rapport and agreeing the topic to planning, with change talk as one part of it.
Miracle Question. When the person is stuck describing the problem and cannot yet say what they want instead.
Crucial Conversations. When the issue is a performance problem the person does not yet acknowledge.