Developed by Steve de Shazer and Insoo Kim Berg in solution-focused brief therapy (de Shazer, Clues, 1988).
Asks someone to imagine the problem solved overnight without their knowing, then to describe what they would notice first, turning a stuck complaint into a concrete picture of the goal.
From a complaint about handoffs to one step for this week
At each of the coach's turns, pick a line: the next question of the miracle sequence, or a question that sends the talk back to the problem. The shift lead's answer shows, and the bar tracks how concrete the picture of the goal has become. Illustrative.
Coach
Shift lead
Coach
Shift lead
How concrete the goal is0of 4
- The complaint (Shift lead). A warehouse day-shift lead: "Handoffs with the night shift are broken. They drop half of what we pass them, every night."
- The question (Coach). Pick the coach's first question.
- Why do you think the night shift drops things? Because they don't care, and their lead never checks anything. Problem talk: more detail about what is wrong, and more blame.
- Suppose overnight the handoffs got fixed and nobody told you. What would you notice first? I'd walk in and there wouldn't be three angry messages waiting. The miracle question: for the first time, he describes the goal.
- A first picture (Shift lead). An absence is a start. The next question turns it into something present.
- Others' eyes (Coach). Pick the question.
- How many messages do you get on an average morning now? Three or four. Sometimes six. Back to the problem: a number for what is wrong.
- What would the night lead notice was different? That we gave her one list at six, in one place, not a pile of chat threads. Another's view: the goal turns into a behavior someone could see.
- A behavior (Shift lead). The picture now holds something the day shift would do, not only what the night shift would stop doing.
- Exceptions (Coach). Pick the question.
- Good, so let's write a handoff policy for both shifts. Another policy. We have three already. A jump to a solution: his picture becomes the coach's project.
- Has there been a night lately when some of that already happened? Last Thursday, actually. Marco did a whiteboard list and nothing got dropped. An exception: part of the goal already exists, and it worked.
- An exception (Shift lead). A night with the problem absent. What made it work is something they can repeat.
- One small step (Coach). Pick the last question.
- What's one small piece of Thursday you could repeat this week? I'll do the whiteboard list myself at six on Monday and Wednesday. A small step, chosen by him, toward a goal he described.
- Great. I'll ask Marco to train everyone on the whiteboard. Sure, if he has time. Taken over: a plan for him, owned by nobody.
- This week (Shift lead). Two nights of one-list handoffs, run by the lead himself. The complaint has become a goal and a first step.
An example
The day-shift lead at a distribution warehouse came to a coaching session with one subject: the night shift. Handoffs were broken, the night crew dropped half of what was passed to them, and their lead never checked anything. Twenty minutes of the session went to examples.
The coach warned him the next question would sound strange, then asked it. Suppose the handoffs got fixed overnight while he slept, and nobody told him. What would he notice first? He said there would be no angry messages waiting. What would the night lead notice? One list at six o'clock, in one place, instead of chat threads. Had any night lately looked like that? He thought, and remembered last Thursday, when a picker named Marco had written the open orders on a whiteboard and nothing was dropped.
Asked for one small piece of Thursday he could repeat, he said he would write the whiteboard list himself on Monday and Wednesday. By the end of the month the night shift had adopted the board.
Why it works
A person stuck in a problem can describe it in great detail and still have no picture of what they want instead. Analyzing the problem adds detail to it, and often more blame. The miracle question skips past the cause. By asking the person to imagine the problem gone and describe what they would notice, it forces them to build the goal in concrete, visible terms, which the problem talk never produced.
The follow-ups do the rest. Asking what others would notice turns a feeling into behavior. Asking whether any part already happens turns up exceptions, times the problem was absent, which show what works and prove that change is possible. And because the picture and the first step both come from the person, the step is one they believe in and will try.
The thinking behind it
Steve de Shazer Steve de Shazer, a psychotherapist, developed solution-focused brief therapy with Insoo Kim Berg and their team at the Brief Family Therapy Center in Milwaukee. The approach builds on what the client wants and on exceptions to the problem, and uses tools such as the miracle question and scaling questions. Clues: Investigating Solutions in Brief Therapy (1988) is his account of it.
Insoo Kim Berg Insoo Kim Berg, a family therapist, co-founded the Brief Family Therapy Center in Milwaukee with Steve de Shazer in 1978 and developed solution-focused brief therapy there with him in the 1980s. The approach asks clients to describe a preferred future, including through the miracle question. Interviewing for Solutions (1998), written with Peter De Jong, is her textbook account of the method.
How to run it
- Warn them first. Say that the next question will sound odd, which gives them permission to play along.
- Ask the miracle question. The problem is solved overnight and no one tells them: what is the first thing they notice?
- Wait out the silence. The question takes time to answer, and filling the pause lets them off the hook.
- Turn absences into presences. When they say what would stop, ask what would be happening instead.
- Ask what others would notice. A colleague's or customer's view turns a feeling into behavior someone could see.
- Look for exceptions. Ask when any part of the picture already happened, and what was different then.
- Ask for one small step. Ask what small piece they could do this week, chosen by them, and stop there.
Where it goes wrong
The coach drifts back to the problem. A question about how often it happens, or why, pulls the person straight back into the complaint. After the miracle question, every question should be about the picture or the exceptions.
The answer stays vague. "Things would just work" is not a goal. Keep asking what they would see, hear, or do differently until the answer is something a camera could record.
The step is too big. A person who leaves committed to fixing handoffs for good will likely fail by Friday. A step small enough to do on Monday, and borrowed from an exception that already worked, is the one that holds.
When to use something else
- Five Whys. When the cause matters and the fix depends on finding it, as with a defect or a process failure.
- Motivational Interviewing. When the person knows what they want but is unsure whether to change.
- After-Action Review. When a team needs to learn from one event, comparing what was meant to happen with what did.
Where it sits in SOLVE eX
Go to the source
- Clues: Investigating Solutions in Brief Therapy, 1988
- Solution-Focused Brief Therapy, Brief Family Therapy Center, Milwaukee, 1980s