Thinking Tools6.1 Designing and Testing the SolutionAlso known as HAZOP
From hazard review at Imperial Chemical Industries from 1963, published by H. G. Lawley (Operability Studies and Hazard Analysis, 1974) and first printed as HAZOP by Trevor Kletz (Hazop and Hazan, 1983).
Walks a process design node by node, applying guide words such as no, more, less, and reverse to each parameter to find deviations, their causes, and their consequences.
One node of a milk pasteurizer, with each guide word applied to flow and temperature
The node is the holding tube, where milk must stay at 72 degrees for at least 15 seconds. Each tag is something that could happen there. Place it in the cell for the deviation it causes, guide word across and parameter up; the panel gives the cause, the consequence, and the safeguard. One cell, reverse temperature, is not a meaningful pair. The first is placed as an example. Illustrative.
Items (select one, then a box)
Not placedPlacedNo flowMore flowLess flowBackflowNo heatToo hotToo coolSkip
Not placedPlacedNo flowMore flowLess flowBackflowNo heatToo hotToo coolSkip
Not placedPlacedNo flowMore flowLess flowBackflowNo heatToo hotToo coolSkip
Not placedPlacedNo flowMore flowLess flowBackflowNo heatToo hotToo coolSkip
Not placedPlacedNo flowMore flowLess flowBackflowNo heatToo hotToo coolSkip
Not placedPlacedNo flowMore flowLess flowBackflowNo heatToo hotToo coolSkip
Not placedPlacedNo flowMore flowLess flowBackflowNo heatToo hotToo coolSkip
Parameter
FlowTemperature
No flow
More flow
Less flow
Backflow
No heat
Too hot
Too cool
Skip
NoMoreLessReverse
Guide word
Pump trips. The feed pump stops on an electrical fault.Not placed yet.Pump trips. The feed pump stops on an electrical fault.No flow: Milk stops in the tube. It overheats and scorches, and the line stops.Cause: pump trip. Consequence: scorched milk, line stop. Safeguard: low-flow alarm and an automatic flush.Pump trips. The feed pump stops on an electrical fault.More flow: Milk passes through faster than the 15 seconds the tube was sized for: under-pasteurized product. The critical deviation at this node.Pump trips. The feed pump stops on an electrical fault.Less flow: Milk stays longer than designed. Safe, but flavor suffers and output drops.Pump trips. The feed pump stops on an electrical fault.Backflow: Raw milk moves toward the pasteurized side, usually through a leak where the two pass each other. A contamination hazard.Pump trips. The feed pump stops on an electrical fault.No heat: Milk reaches the tube cold. Nothing is pasteurized.Pump trips. The feed pump stops on an electrical fault.Too hot: Milk runs hotter than set. A quality problem, with fouling that later cuts heat transfer.Pump trips. The feed pump stops on an electrical fault.Too cool: Milk runs a few degrees under 72. Under-pasteurized if not caught.Pump trips. The feed pump stops on an electrical fault.Skip: Reverse temperature has no physical meaning here. Record that the pair was considered, and move on.Pump runs fast. A replacement pump motor turns faster than the original.Not placed yet.Pump runs fast. A replacement pump motor turns faster than the original.No flow: Milk stops in the tube. It overheats and scorches, and the line stops.Pump runs fast. A replacement pump motor turns faster than the original.More flow: Milk passes through faster than the 15 seconds the tube was sized for: under-pasteurized product. The critical deviation at this node.Cause: wrong motor after maintenance. Consequence: hold time under 15 seconds. Safeguard: a fixed-speed timing pump and a flow meter that diverts the milk. Action: check speed after any repair.Pump runs fast. A replacement pump motor turns faster than the original.Less flow: Milk stays longer than designed. Safe, but flavor suffers and output drops.Pump runs fast. A replacement pump motor turns faster than the original.Backflow: Raw milk moves toward the pasteurized side, usually through a leak where the two pass each other. A contamination hazard.Pump runs fast. A replacement pump motor turns faster than the original.No heat: Milk reaches the tube cold. Nothing is pasteurized.Pump runs fast. A replacement pump motor turns faster than the original.Too hot: Milk runs hotter than set. A quality problem, with fouling that later cuts heat transfer.Pump runs fast. A replacement pump motor turns faster than the original.Too cool: Milk runs a few degrees under 72. Under-pasteurized if not caught.Pump runs fast. A replacement pump motor turns faster than the original.Skip: Reverse temperature has no physical meaning here. Record that the pair was considered, and move on.Clogged filter. The inlet strainer partly blocks with milk solids.Not placed yet.Clogged filter. The inlet strainer partly blocks with milk solids.No flow: Milk stops in the tube. It overheats and scorches, and the line stops.Clogged filter. The inlet strainer partly blocks with milk solids.More flow: Milk passes through faster than the 15 seconds the tube was sized for: under-pasteurized product. The critical deviation at this node.Clogged filter. The inlet strainer partly blocks with milk solids.Less flow: Milk stays longer than designed. Safe, but flavor suffers and output drops.Cause: a missed cleaning. Consequence: lower output, cooked taste. Safeguard: pressure gauge across the strainer.Clogged filter. The inlet strainer partly blocks with milk solids.Backflow: Raw milk moves toward the pasteurized side, usually through a leak where the two pass each other. A contamination hazard.Clogged filter. The inlet strainer partly blocks with milk solids.No heat: Milk reaches the tube cold. Nothing is pasteurized.Clogged filter. The inlet strainer partly blocks with milk solids.Too hot: Milk runs hotter than set. A quality problem, with fouling that later cuts heat transfer.Clogged filter. The inlet strainer partly blocks with milk solids.Too cool: Milk runs a few degrees under 72. Under-pasteurized if not caught.Clogged filter. The inlet strainer partly blocks with milk solids.Skip: Reverse temperature has no physical meaning here. Record that the pair was considered, and move on.Pressure drop. Pressure on the pasteurized side falls below the raw side in the heat exchanger.Not placed yet.Pressure drop. Pressure on the pasteurized side falls below the raw side in the heat exchanger.No flow: Milk stops in the tube. It overheats and scorches, and the line stops.Pressure drop. Pressure on the pasteurized side falls below the raw side in the heat exchanger.More flow: Milk passes through faster than the 15 seconds the tube was sized for: under-pasteurized product. The critical deviation at this node.Pressure drop. Pressure on the pasteurized side falls below the raw side in the heat exchanger.Less flow: Milk stays longer than designed. Safe, but flavor suffers and output drops.Pressure drop. Pressure on the pasteurized side falls below the raw side in the heat exchanger.Backflow: Raw milk moves toward the pasteurized side, usually through a leak where the two pass each other. A contamination hazard.Cause: a downstream valve opens. Consequence: raw milk leaks into finished milk through any pinhole. Safeguard: keep the pasteurized side at higher pressure, with a controller that diverts flow.Pressure drop. Pressure on the pasteurized side falls below the raw side in the heat exchanger.No heat: Milk reaches the tube cold. Nothing is pasteurized.Pressure drop. Pressure on the pasteurized side falls below the raw side in the heat exchanger.Too hot: Milk runs hotter than set. A quality problem, with fouling that later cuts heat transfer.Pressure drop. Pressure on the pasteurized side falls below the raw side in the heat exchanger.Too cool: Milk runs a few degrees under 72. Under-pasteurized if not caught.Pressure drop. Pressure on the pasteurized side falls below the raw side in the heat exchanger.Skip: Reverse temperature has no physical meaning here. Record that the pair was considered, and move on.Steam fails. The boiler trips and the heating section goes cold.Not placed yet.Steam fails. The boiler trips and the heating section goes cold.No flow: Milk stops in the tube. It overheats and scorches, and the line stops.Steam fails. The boiler trips and the heating section goes cold.More flow: Milk passes through faster than the 15 seconds the tube was sized for: under-pasteurized product. The critical deviation at this node.Steam fails. The boiler trips and the heating section goes cold.Less flow: Milk stays longer than designed. Safe, but flavor suffers and output drops.Steam fails. The boiler trips and the heating section goes cold.Backflow: Raw milk moves toward the pasteurized side, usually through a leak where the two pass each other. A contamination hazard.Steam fails. The boiler trips and the heating section goes cold.No heat: Milk reaches the tube cold. Nothing is pasteurized.Cause: boiler fault. Consequence: unheated milk. Safeguard: a temperature probe that sends milk back to the raw tank.Steam fails. The boiler trips and the heating section goes cold.Too hot: Milk runs hotter than set. A quality problem, with fouling that later cuts heat transfer.Steam fails. The boiler trips and the heating section goes cold.Too cool: Milk runs a few degrees under 72. Under-pasteurized if not caught.Steam fails. The boiler trips and the heating section goes cold.Skip: Reverse temperature has no physical meaning here. Record that the pair was considered, and move on.Steam stuck on. The steam valve sticks fully open.Not placed yet.Steam stuck on. The steam valve sticks fully open.No flow: Milk stops in the tube. It overheats and scorches, and the line stops.Steam stuck on. The steam valve sticks fully open.More flow: Milk passes through faster than the 15 seconds the tube was sized for: under-pasteurized product. The critical deviation at this node.Steam stuck on. The steam valve sticks fully open.Less flow: Milk stays longer than designed. Safe, but flavor suffers and output drops.Steam stuck on. The steam valve sticks fully open.Backflow: Raw milk moves toward the pasteurized side, usually through a leak where the two pass each other. A contamination hazard.Steam stuck on. The steam valve sticks fully open.No heat: Milk reaches the tube cold. Nothing is pasteurized.Steam stuck on. The steam valve sticks fully open.Too hot: Milk runs hotter than set. A quality problem, with fouling that later cuts heat transfer.Cause: valve failure. Consequence: cooked flavor and fouling. Safeguard: high-temperature alarm; action: add the valve to the weekly check.Steam stuck on. The steam valve sticks fully open.Too cool: Milk runs a few degrees under 72. Under-pasteurized if not caught.Steam stuck on. The steam valve sticks fully open.Skip: Reverse temperature has no physical meaning here. Record that the pair was considered, and move on.Heater fouled. Deposits build up in the heating plates over a long run.Not placed yet.Heater fouled. Deposits build up in the heating plates over a long run.No flow: Milk stops in the tube. It overheats and scorches, and the line stops.Heater fouled. Deposits build up in the heating plates over a long run.More flow: Milk passes through faster than the 15 seconds the tube was sized for: under-pasteurized product. The critical deviation at this node.Heater fouled. Deposits build up in the heating plates over a long run.Less flow: Milk stays longer than designed. Safe, but flavor suffers and output drops.Heater fouled. Deposits build up in the heating plates over a long run.Backflow: Raw milk moves toward the pasteurized side, usually through a leak where the two pass each other. A contamination hazard.Heater fouled. Deposits build up in the heating plates over a long run.No heat: Milk reaches the tube cold. Nothing is pasteurized.Heater fouled. Deposits build up in the heating plates over a long run.Too hot: Milk runs hotter than set. A quality problem, with fouling that later cuts heat transfer.Heater fouled. Deposits build up in the heating plates over a long run.Too cool: Milk runs a few degrees under 72. Under-pasteurized if not caught.Cause: run too long between cleanings. Consequence: milk at 70 degrees. Safeguard: the same diversion valve, set to trip below 72.Heater fouled. Deposits build up in the heating plates over a long run.Skip: Reverse temperature has no physical meaning here. Record that the pair was considered, and move on.
Your sort matched 0 of 7.Your sort matched 1 of 7.Your sort matched 2 of 7.Your sort matched 3 of 7.Your sort matched 4 of 7.Your sort matched 5 of 7.Your sort matched 6 of 7.Your sort matched 7 of 7.
No flow
Milk stops in the tube. It overheats and scorches, and the line stops.
More flow
Milk passes through faster than the 15 seconds the tube was sized for: under-pasteurized product. The critical deviation at this node.
Less flow
Milk stays longer than designed. Safe, but flavor suffers and output drops.
Backflow
Raw milk moves toward the pasteurized side, usually through a leak where the two pass each other. A contamination hazard.
No heat
Milk reaches the tube cold. Nothing is pasteurized.
Too hot
Milk runs hotter than set. A quality problem, with fouling that later cuts heat transfer.
Too cool
Milk runs a few degrees under 72. Under-pasteurized if not caught.
Skip
Reverse temperature has no physical meaning here. Record that the pair was considered, and move on.
The sort
Pump trips: No flow. Cause: pump trip. Consequence: scorched milk, line stop. Safeguard: low-flow alarm and an automatic flush.
Pump runs fast: More flow. Cause: wrong motor after maintenance. Consequence: hold time under 15 seconds. Safeguard: a fixed-speed timing pump and a flow meter that diverts the milk. Action: check speed after any repair.
Clogged filter: Less flow. Cause: a missed cleaning. Consequence: lower output, cooked taste. Safeguard: pressure gauge across the strainer.
Pressure drop: Backflow. Cause: a downstream valve opens. Consequence: raw milk leaks into finished milk through any pinhole. Safeguard: keep the pasteurized side at higher pressure, with a controller that diverts flow.
Steam fails: No heat. Cause: boiler fault. Consequence: unheated milk. Safeguard: a temperature probe that sends milk back to the raw tank.
Steam stuck on: Too hot. Cause: valve failure. Consequence: cooked flavor and fouling. Safeguard: high-temperature alarm; action: add the valve to the weekly check.
Heater fouled: Too cool. Cause: run too long between cleanings. Consequence: milk at 70 degrees. Safeguard: the same diversion valve, set to trip below 72.
An example
A dairy was replacing its pasteurizing line, and before the design was frozen the plant manager booked four mornings for a hazard and operability study. Around the table sat the design engineer, the shift supervisor, a maintenance fitter, the quality manager, and an experienced facilitator.
They split the line into six nodes and started with the holding tube, where milk must stay at 72 degrees for at least fifteen seconds. For each parameter the facilitator read out the guide words in turn: no flow, more flow, less flow, reverse flow, then the same for temperature. Most rows had safeguards already. Two did not. More flow turned up a gap: a pump motor replaced after a breakdown could run faster than the original and cut the hold time, and nothing checked its speed. Reverse flow turned up a second: if pressure on the finished side dropped below the raw side, raw milk could leak through a pinhole in the heat exchanger. The design gained a fixed-speed timing pump and a pressure controller before a single pipe was ordered.
Why it works
Asked what could go wrong, a team lists the failures it has seen. The guide words replace that open question with a fixed set of small ones, applied to every parameter at every node: what if there is no flow here, more flow, less, reverse? The fixed set reaches combinations nobody would think to raise, and the node-by-node walk keeps the team from skipping the dull parts of the plant where accidents often start.
The team matters as much as the words. A designer knows what the line is meant to do, an operator knows what it actually does at three in the morning, and a fitter knows what gets replaced with what. Each guide word puts all three views on the same deviation at once, and the worksheet records the cause, the consequence, and the safeguard, so every gap becomes an action with an owner.
The thinking behind it
H. G. Lawley H. G. Lawley wrote the first open-literature account of the method, Operability Studies and Hazard Analysis (1974, Chemical Engineering Progress). The guide-word study had grown up inside Imperial Chemical Industries from 1963 as a way of finding hazards in process plant designs before they were built. His paper set out the guide-word procedure for engineers outside the company where it began, and it is the usual starting point for the method's published history.
Trevor Kletz Trevor Kletz, ICI's first technical safety adviser from 1968 to 1982 and a leading writer on process safety, described the study in Hazop and Hazan: Notes on the Identification and Assessment of Hazards (1983), the book that first printed the name HAZOP. His paper What You Don't Have, Can't Leak began the idea of inherently safer design: the best answer to a deviation the study finds is often to design the hazard out.
How to run it
Assemble the team. Bring design, operations, maintenance, and safety, with a facilitator who keeps the pace and a scribe who keeps the worksheet.
Divide the design into nodes. Mark sections of the process drawing where conditions are roughly the same, such as one vessel or one length of pipe.
Set each node's design intent. Write what each parameter should be there, such as 72 degrees for at least fifteen seconds.
Apply every guide word to every parameter. Read out no, more, less, reverse, and the rest, and ask what would cause each deviation.
Record consequences and safeguards. For each credible cause, write what would happen and what already prevents or detects it.
Turn gaps into actions. Where a safeguard is missing or weak, name the change, the owner, and the date.
Close the actions before startup. Review each action at a follow-up meeting and rerun the study on any node the changes alter.
Where it goes wrong
The study becomes a checklist marathon. After the third morning, the team says no new hazards to every row to finish. Keep sessions short, rotate facilitators on long studies, and stop when attention drops.
The wrong people are in the room. Without an operator or a fitter, the study tests the design as drawn, not as run and repaired. If nobody present has worked a night shift on such a line, find someone who has.
The actions are never closed. A worksheet full of recommendations goes into a file, and the plant starts up with the gaps. Track every action to closure, and treat an open one as a reason to delay startup.
When to use something else
Failure Mode and Effects Analysis. When the system is a product or a machine whose components fail, more than a process whose conditions drift.
Premortem. When the thing to examine is a plan or a project, and the team needs to imagine how it failed.
Poka-Yoke. When a hazard comes from a human step, and the fix is a design that makes the error impossible.