Gamification

Thinking Tools6.1 Designing and Testing the SolutionAlso known as Octalysis, Gamification frameworks

Octalysis developed by Yu-kai Chou (Actionable Gamification, 2015), in the field set out by Jane McGonigal (2011) and Kevin Werbach and Dan Hunter (2012), with the crowding-out caution of Edward L. Deci and Richard M. Ryan (1985).

Applies game mechanics such as progress, status, scarcity, surprise, and meaning to ordinary work or customer activity, matching each mechanic to the motive behind the behavior.

Nine game mechanics for getting job reports filed, placed on the eight motives

Field technicians file only 55 percent of job reports the same day. The eight motives sit as they do on the octagon, positive at the top, pressure at the bottom. The certification bar is placed as an example. Select each other mechanic and pick the motive it works on; the center holds the mechanic with no motive behind it. Illustrative.

Items (select one, then a box)
  • Not placedPlacedAccomplishmentMeaningCreativityOwnershipNo motiveSocial influenceScarcityAvoiding lossUnpredictability
  • Not placedPlacedAccomplishmentMeaningCreativityOwnershipNo motiveSocial influenceScarcityAvoiding lossUnpredictability
  • Not placedPlacedAccomplishmentMeaningCreativityOwnershipNo motiveSocial influenceScarcityAvoiding lossUnpredictability
  • Not placedPlacedAccomplishmentMeaningCreativityOwnershipNo motiveSocial influenceScarcityAvoiding lossUnpredictability
  • Not placedPlacedAccomplishmentMeaningCreativityOwnershipNo motiveSocial influenceScarcityAvoiding lossUnpredictability
  • Not placedPlacedAccomplishmentMeaningCreativityOwnershipNo motiveSocial influenceScarcityAvoiding lossUnpredictability
  • Not placedPlacedAccomplishmentMeaningCreativityOwnershipNo motiveSocial influenceScarcityAvoiding lossUnpredictability
  • Not placedPlacedAccomplishmentMeaningCreativityOwnershipNo motiveSocial influenceScarcityAvoiding lossUnpredictability
  • Not placedPlacedAccomplishmentMeaningCreativityOwnershipNo motiveSocial influenceScarcityAvoiding lossUnpredictability

How it feels

PositiveMixedPressure
Accomplishment
Meaning
Creativity
Ownership
No motive
Social influence
Scarcity
Avoiding loss
Unpredictability
Outside rewardsEitherThe work itself

Where the pull comes from

Certification bar. Each complete report moves a technician toward the next certification level, shown as a bar in the app.Not placed yet.Certification bar. Each complete report moves a technician toward the next certification level, shown as a bar in the app.Accomplishment: Progress toward something hard. Make the progress real: a level that is earned, not handed out.Accomplishment, tied to a level techs already respect. Side effect: thin reports filed to move the bar, so count only complete ones.Certification bar. Each complete report moves a technician toward the next certification level, shown as a bar in the app.Meaning: Being part of something bigger than the task. Show whom the behavior helped.Certification bar. Each complete report moves a technician toward the next certification level, shown as a bar in the app.Creativity: Choosing how to do it and seeing the result. Give room to contribute, with quick feedback.Certification bar. Each complete report moves a technician toward the next certification level, shown as a bar in the app.Ownership: Building up something of one's own. Let the behavior add to a collection people keep.Certification bar. Each complete report moves a technician toward the next certification level, shown as a bar in the app.No motive: A mechanic that connects to no drive. Usually points or badges that buy nothing and show to no one: the weakest fit.Certification bar. Each complete report moves a technician toward the next certification level, shown as a bar in the app.Social influence: Peers, comparison, and belonging. Strong, and it can shame the people at the bottom.Certification bar. Each complete report moves a technician toward the next certification level, shown as a bar in the app.Scarcity: Wanting what is limited or time-bound. Drives fast action, and can feel like a trick.Certification bar. Each complete report moves a technician toward the next certification level, shown as a bar in the app.Avoiding loss: Fear of losing what one already has. Effective in the short run, and people resent it.Certification bar. Each complete report moves a technician toward the next certification level, shown as a bar in the app.Unpredictability: Curiosity about what happens next. Fun in small doses, and it wears off.Points per report. Ten points for every report filed, shown on a profile page that nobody visits.Not placed yet.Points per report. Ten points for every report filed, shown on a profile page that nobody visits.Accomplishment: Progress toward something hard. Make the progress real: a level that is earned, not handed out.Points per report. Ten points for every report filed, shown on a profile page that nobody visits.Meaning: Being part of something bigger than the task. Show whom the behavior helped.Points per report. Ten points for every report filed, shown on a profile page that nobody visits.Creativity: Choosing how to do it and seeing the result. Give room to contribute, with quick feedback.Points per report. Ten points for every report filed, shown on a profile page that nobody visits.Ownership: Building up something of one's own. Let the behavior add to a collection people keep.Points per report. Ten points for every report filed, shown on a profile page that nobody visits.No motive: A mechanic that connects to no drive. Usually points or badges that buy nothing and show to no one: the weakest fit.No motive behind it. Points that buy nothing and that no one sees lifted filing for three weeks, then faded.Points per report. Ten points for every report filed, shown on a profile page that nobody visits.Social influence: Peers, comparison, and belonging. Strong, and it can shame the people at the bottom.Points per report. Ten points for every report filed, shown on a profile page that nobody visits.Scarcity: Wanting what is limited or time-bound. Drives fast action, and can feel like a trick.Points per report. Ten points for every report filed, shown on a profile page that nobody visits.Avoiding loss: Fear of losing what one already has. Effective in the short run, and people resent it.Points per report. Ten points for every report filed, shown on a profile page that nobody visits.Unpredictability: Curiosity about what happens next. Fun in small doses, and it wears off.Report saved a trip. When a later crew uses a report's notes at the same site, the author gets a message: your report saved a second visit.Not placed yet.Report saved a trip. When a later crew uses a report's notes at the same site, the author gets a message: your report saved a second visit.Accomplishment: Progress toward something hard. Make the progress real: a level that is earned, not handed out.Report saved a trip. When a later crew uses a report's notes at the same site, the author gets a message: your report saved a second visit.Meaning: Being part of something bigger than the task. Show whom the behavior helped.Meaning: the report helps a colleague and a customer. Side effect: none to speak of, but it needs real cases behind it.Report saved a trip. When a later crew uses a report's notes at the same site, the author gets a message: your report saved a second visit.Creativity: Choosing how to do it and seeing the result. Give room to contribute, with quick feedback.Report saved a trip. When a later crew uses a report's notes at the same site, the author gets a message: your report saved a second visit.Ownership: Building up something of one's own. Let the behavior add to a collection people keep.Report saved a trip. When a later crew uses a report's notes at the same site, the author gets a message: your report saved a second visit.No motive: A mechanic that connects to no drive. Usually points or badges that buy nothing and show to no one: the weakest fit.Report saved a trip. When a later crew uses a report's notes at the same site, the author gets a message: your report saved a second visit.Social influence: Peers, comparison, and belonging. Strong, and it can shame the people at the bottom.Report saved a trip. When a later crew uses a report's notes at the same site, the author gets a message: your report saved a second visit.Scarcity: Wanting what is limited or time-bound. Drives fast action, and can feel like a trick.Report saved a trip. When a later crew uses a report's notes at the same site, the author gets a message: your report saved a second visit.Avoiding loss: Fear of losing what one already has. Effective in the short run, and people resent it.Report saved a trip. When a later crew uses a report's notes at the same site, the author gets a message: your report saved a second visit.Unpredictability: Curiosity about what happens next. Fun in small doses, and it wears off.Add your own tips. Technicians can attach their own fix tips to a report, and other techs rate them.Not placed yet.Add your own tips. Technicians can attach their own fix tips to a report, and other techs rate them.Accomplishment: Progress toward something hard. Make the progress real: a level that is earned, not handed out.Add your own tips. Technicians can attach their own fix tips to a report, and other techs rate them.Meaning: Being part of something bigger than the task. Show whom the behavior helped.Add your own tips. Technicians can attach their own fix tips to a report, and other techs rate them.Creativity: Choosing how to do it and seeing the result. Give room to contribute, with quick feedback.Creativity and feedback: the report becomes a place to show craft. Side effect: tips need light moderation.Add your own tips. Technicians can attach their own fix tips to a report, and other techs rate them.Ownership: Building up something of one's own. Let the behavior add to a collection people keep.Add your own tips. Technicians can attach their own fix tips to a report, and other techs rate them.No motive: A mechanic that connects to no drive. Usually points or badges that buy nothing and show to no one: the weakest fit.Add your own tips. Technicians can attach their own fix tips to a report, and other techs rate them.Social influence: Peers, comparison, and belonging. Strong, and it can shame the people at the bottom.Add your own tips. Technicians can attach their own fix tips to a report, and other techs rate them.Scarcity: Wanting what is limited or time-bound. Drives fast action, and can feel like a trick.Add your own tips. Technicians can attach their own fix tips to a report, and other techs rate them.Avoiding loss: Fear of losing what one already has. Effective in the short run, and people resent it.Add your own tips. Technicians can attach their own fix tips to a report, and other techs rate them.Unpredictability: Curiosity about what happens next. Fun in small doses, and it wears off.Your site library. Every report adds to a technician's personal library of sites serviced, with photos, kept when they change crews.Not placed yet.Your site library. Every report adds to a technician's personal library of sites serviced, with photos, kept when they change crews.Accomplishment: Progress toward something hard. Make the progress real: a level that is earned, not handed out.Your site library. Every report adds to a technician's personal library of sites serviced, with photos, kept when they change crews.Meaning: Being part of something bigger than the task. Show whom the behavior helped.Your site library. Every report adds to a technician's personal library of sites serviced, with photos, kept when they change crews.Creativity: Choosing how to do it and seeing the result. Give room to contribute, with quick feedback.Your site library. Every report adds to a technician's personal library of sites serviced, with photos, kept when they change crews.Ownership: Building up something of one's own. Let the behavior add to a collection people keep.Ownership: the record is theirs. Side effect: techs may resist sharing notes they now think of as their own.Your site library. Every report adds to a technician's personal library of sites serviced, with photos, kept when they change crews.No motive: A mechanic that connects to no drive. Usually points or badges that buy nothing and show to no one: the weakest fit.Your site library. Every report adds to a technician's personal library of sites serviced, with photos, kept when they change crews.Social influence: Peers, comparison, and belonging. Strong, and it can shame the people at the bottom.Your site library. Every report adds to a technician's personal library of sites serviced, with photos, kept when they change crews.Scarcity: Wanting what is limited or time-bound. Drives fast action, and can feel like a trick.Your site library. Every report adds to a technician's personal library of sites serviced, with photos, kept when they change crews.Avoiding loss: Fear of losing what one already has. Effective in the short run, and people resent it.Your site library. Every report adds to a technician's personal library of sites serviced, with photos, kept when they change crews.Unpredictability: Curiosity about what happens next. Fun in small doses, and it wears off.Crew board. Each crew sees its same-day filing rate beside the other crews' on the depot screen.Not placed yet.Crew board. Each crew sees its same-day filing rate beside the other crews' on the depot screen.Accomplishment: Progress toward something hard. Make the progress real: a level that is earned, not handed out.Crew board. Each crew sees its same-day filing rate beside the other crews' on the depot screen.Meaning: Being part of something bigger than the task. Show whom the behavior helped.Crew board. Each crew sees its same-day filing rate beside the other crews' on the depot screen.Creativity: Choosing how to do it and seeing the result. Give room to contribute, with quick feedback.Crew board. Each crew sees its same-day filing rate beside the other crews' on the depot screen.Ownership: Building up something of one's own. Let the behavior add to a collection people keep.Crew board. Each crew sees its same-day filing rate beside the other crews' on the depot screen.No motive: A mechanic that connects to no drive. Usually points or badges that buy nothing and show to no one: the weakest fit.Crew board. Each crew sees its same-day filing rate beside the other crews' on the depot screen.Social influence: Peers, comparison, and belonging. Strong, and it can shame the people at the bottom.Social influence: no crew wants to be last. Side effect: the bottom crew stops looking at the board.Crew board. Each crew sees its same-day filing rate beside the other crews' on the depot screen.Scarcity: Wanting what is limited or time-bound. Drives fast action, and can feel like a trick.Crew board. Each crew sees its same-day filing rate beside the other crews' on the depot screen.Avoiding loss: Fear of losing what one already has. Effective in the short run, and people resent it.Crew board. Each crew sees its same-day filing rate beside the other crews' on the depot screen.Unpredictability: Curiosity about what happens next. Fun in small doses, and it wears off.Double if same day. Reports filed within four hours of the job count double toward the quarterly bonus.Not placed yet.Double if same day. Reports filed within four hours of the job count double toward the quarterly bonus.Accomplishment: Progress toward something hard. Make the progress real: a level that is earned, not handed out.Double if same day. Reports filed within four hours of the job count double toward the quarterly bonus.Meaning: Being part of something bigger than the task. Show whom the behavior helped.Double if same day. Reports filed within four hours of the job count double toward the quarterly bonus.Creativity: Choosing how to do it and seeing the result. Give room to contribute, with quick feedback.Double if same day. Reports filed within four hours of the job count double toward the quarterly bonus.Ownership: Building up something of one's own. Let the behavior add to a collection people keep.Double if same day. Reports filed within four hours of the job count double toward the quarterly bonus.No motive: A mechanic that connects to no drive. Usually points or badges that buy nothing and show to no one: the weakest fit.Double if same day. Reports filed within four hours of the job count double toward the quarterly bonus.Social influence: Peers, comparison, and belonging. Strong, and it can shame the people at the bottom.Double if same day. Reports filed within four hours of the job count double toward the quarterly bonus.Scarcity: Wanting what is limited or time-bound. Drives fast action, and can feel like a trick.Scarcity: a window that closes. Side effect: a rush of short reports at hour three.Double if same day. Reports filed within four hours of the job count double toward the quarterly bonus.Avoiding loss: Fear of losing what one already has. Effective in the short run, and people resent it.Double if same day. Reports filed within four hours of the job count double toward the quarterly bonus.Unpredictability: Curiosity about what happens next. Fun in small doses, and it wears off.Streak counter. A counter of consecutive days with every report filed, reset to zero by one miss.Not placed yet.Streak counter. A counter of consecutive days with every report filed, reset to zero by one miss.Accomplishment: Progress toward something hard. Make the progress real: a level that is earned, not handed out.Streak counter. A counter of consecutive days with every report filed, reset to zero by one miss.Meaning: Being part of something bigger than the task. Show whom the behavior helped.Streak counter. A counter of consecutive days with every report filed, reset to zero by one miss.Creativity: Choosing how to do it and seeing the result. Give room to contribute, with quick feedback.Streak counter. A counter of consecutive days with every report filed, reset to zero by one miss.Ownership: Building up something of one's own. Let the behavior add to a collection people keep.Streak counter. A counter of consecutive days with every report filed, reset to zero by one miss.No motive: A mechanic that connects to no drive. Usually points or badges that buy nothing and show to no one: the weakest fit.Streak counter. A counter of consecutive days with every report filed, reset to zero by one miss.Social influence: Peers, comparison, and belonging. Strong, and it can shame the people at the bottom.Streak counter. A counter of consecutive days with every report filed, reset to zero by one miss.Scarcity: Wanting what is limited or time-bound. Drives fast action, and can feel like a trick.Streak counter. A counter of consecutive days with every report filed, reset to zero by one miss.Avoiding loss: Fear of losing what one already has. Effective in the short run, and people resent it.Avoiding loss: nobody wants to break a streak. Side effect: anxiety, and a long streak lost makes people quit trying.Streak counter. A counter of consecutive days with every report filed, reset to zero by one miss.Unpredictability: Curiosity about what happens next. Fun in small doses, and it wears off.Weekly lucky draw. One report filed on time each week is drawn at random and wins lunch for its crew.Not placed yet.Weekly lucky draw. One report filed on time each week is drawn at random and wins lunch for its crew.Accomplishment: Progress toward something hard. Make the progress real: a level that is earned, not handed out.Weekly lucky draw. One report filed on time each week is drawn at random and wins lunch for its crew.Meaning: Being part of something bigger than the task. Show whom the behavior helped.Weekly lucky draw. One report filed on time each week is drawn at random and wins lunch for its crew.Creativity: Choosing how to do it and seeing the result. Give room to contribute, with quick feedback.Weekly lucky draw. One report filed on time each week is drawn at random and wins lunch for its crew.Ownership: Building up something of one's own. Let the behavior add to a collection people keep.Weekly lucky draw. One report filed on time each week is drawn at random and wins lunch for its crew.No motive: A mechanic that connects to no drive. Usually points or badges that buy nothing and show to no one: the weakest fit.Weekly lucky draw. One report filed on time each week is drawn at random and wins lunch for its crew.Social influence: Peers, comparison, and belonging. Strong, and it can shame the people at the bottom.Weekly lucky draw. One report filed on time each week is drawn at random and wins lunch for its crew.Scarcity: Wanting what is limited or time-bound. Drives fast action, and can feel like a trick.Weekly lucky draw. One report filed on time each week is drawn at random and wins lunch for its crew.Avoiding loss: Fear of losing what one already has. Effective in the short run, and people resent it.Weekly lucky draw. One report filed on time each week is drawn at random and wins lunch for its crew.Unpredictability: Curiosity about what happens next. Fun in small doses, and it wears off.Unpredictability: a small chance each time. Side effect: the novelty fades within a quarter.

Your sort matched 0 of 9.Your sort matched 1 of 9.Your sort matched 2 of 9.Your sort matched 3 of 9.Your sort matched 4 of 9.Your sort matched 5 of 9.Your sort matched 6 of 9.Your sort matched 7 of 9.Your sort matched 8 of 9.Your sort matched 9 of 9.

Accomplishment
Progress toward something hard. Make the progress real: a level that is earned, not handed out.
Meaning
Being part of something bigger than the task. Show whom the behavior helped.
Creativity
Choosing how to do it and seeing the result. Give room to contribute, with quick feedback.
Ownership
Building up something of one's own. Let the behavior add to a collection people keep.
No motive
A mechanic that connects to no drive. Usually points or badges that buy nothing and show to no one: the weakest fit.
Social influence
Peers, comparison, and belonging. Strong, and it can shame the people at the bottom.
Scarcity
Wanting what is limited or time-bound. Drives fast action, and can feel like a trick.
Avoiding loss
Fear of losing what one already has. Effective in the short run, and people resent it.
Unpredictability
Curiosity about what happens next. Fun in small doses, and it wears off.

The sort

  • Certification bar: Accomplishment. Accomplishment, tied to a level techs already respect. Side effect: thin reports filed to move the bar, so count only complete ones.
  • Points per report: No motive. No motive behind it. Points that buy nothing and that no one sees lifted filing for three weeks, then faded.
  • Report saved a trip: Meaning. Meaning: the report helps a colleague and a customer. Side effect: none to speak of, but it needs real cases behind it.
  • Add your own tips: Creativity. Creativity and feedback: the report becomes a place to show craft. Side effect: tips need light moderation.
  • Your site library: Ownership. Ownership: the record is theirs. Side effect: techs may resist sharing notes they now think of as their own.
  • Crew board: Social influence. Social influence: no crew wants to be last. Side effect: the bottom crew stops looking at the board.
  • Double if same day: Scarcity. Scarcity: a window that closes. Side effect: a rush of short reports at hour three.
  • Streak counter: Avoiding loss. Avoiding loss: nobody wants to break a streak. Side effect: anxiety, and a long streak lost makes people quit trying.
  • Weekly lucky draw: Unpredictability. Unpredictability: a small chance each time. Side effect: the novelty fades within a quarter.

An example

A field service company needed its technicians to file job reports the same day; only 55 percent did. The operations team added points for every report and badges at round numbers. Filing rose to 61 percent, and within eight weeks it was back where it started. The points bought nothing, and nobody looked at anyone's badges.

The second attempt started with the technicians. A dozen interviews showed what they cared about: being good at the work, and not letting their crew down. So the team matched mechanics to those motives. Each complete report moved a technician toward the next certification level. Reports could carry the author's own fix tips, rated by other techs. When a later crew used a report at the same site, its author heard about the visit it saved. A streak counter was tried and dropped after two weeks, when techs said it made them anxious. A quarter later, same-day filing stood at 84 percent, and the points were gone.

Why it works

People do things for reasons, and a game mechanic works only when it connects to one of them. Progress bars work on the wish to get better at something hard; team boards work on belonging and comparison; a closing window works on scarcity. Points and badges on their own connect to nothing, which is why they lift a number briefly and then fade.

Sorting mechanics by the motive they serve also shows their cost. The motives at the top, accomplishment, meaning, creativity, feel good and last. The ones at the bottom, scarcity, fear of loss, and curiosity about chance, drive fast action and leave people feeling pushed. A design that leans on the bottom gets results that stop when the pressure does, and rewards attached to work people already care about can crowd out the reason they cared.

The thinking behind it

Yu-kai Chou Yu-kai Chou, a gamification consultant, published the Octalysis framework on his blog in 2012 and set it out in Actionable Gamification (2015). Octalysis sorts the motives that games draw on into eight core drives, arranged on an octagon, and is used to analyze and design engagement in products. It is a practitioner's framework, built from design work, and makes no claim to be research.

Kevin Werbach Kevin Werbach, a Wharton School professor of legal studies and business ethics, taught an early course on gamification with Dan Hunter and wrote For the Win (2012) with him. The book is a six-step guide to designing game elements into business, with advice on avoiding the failures that follow from bad design. Jane McGonigal's Reality Is Broken (2011) had argued the case for applying game design to real problems a year earlier.

Edward L. Deci Edward L. Deci, a psychologist at the University of Rochester, founded self-determination theory with Richard M. Ryan; Intrinsic Motivation and Self-Determination in Human Behavior (1985) sets it out. The theory separates motivation a person endorses from motivation imposed by rewards or pressure, and ties the first to the needs for autonomy, competence, and relatedness. It is the source of the caution every gamified design needs: a reward can crowd out the reason people did the work.

How to run it

  1. Name the one behavior. Pick a single action with a number attached, such as reports filed the same day.
  2. Ask why people do or skip it. Talk to the people involved and write down their reasons in their words.
  3. Sort the reasons by motive. Place each reason on the eight drives, from accomplishment and meaning to scarcity and fear of loss.
  4. Pick mechanics for the strongest motives. Choose one or two mechanics that connect to the drives people already have.
  5. Name each mechanic's side effect. Write down what it will push people to do that you do not want, such as thin reports.
  6. Lean on the top of the octagon. Use pressure mechanics sparingly and for short periods, if at all.
  7. Measure the behavior, not the game. Track the original number for at least a quarter, after the novelty has worn off.

Where it goes wrong

The first failure is points and badges with no motive behind them. They lift the number for a few weeks and then fade, and the team concludes that gamification does not work. Connect each mechanic to a reason people already have.

The second is gaming the metric. A progress bar for reports filed produces reports with nothing in them. Count only the version of the behavior the team actually wants.

The third is leaning on pressure. Streaks, countdowns, and public rankings get fast results and leave people resentful, and the bottom of any leaderboard stops trying. If people describe the system as stressful, take the pressure mechanics out first.

When to use something else

Where it sits in SOLVE eX

Go to the source

  • Actionable Gamification: Beyond Points, Badges, and Leaderboards, 2015
  • For the Win: How Game Thinking Can Revolutionize Your Business, 2012
  • Reality Is Broken, 2011
  • Intrinsic Motivation and Self-Determination in Human Behavior, 1985

Back to the catalog