Behavior Change Wheel

Thinking Tools6.1 Designing and Testing the SolutionAlso known as COM-B

Developed by Susan Michie, Maartje M. van Stralen, and Robert West (The Behaviour Change Wheel, 2011), and set out as a guide with Lou Atkins (2014).

Diagnoses a behavior problem as a gap in capability, opportunity, or motivation, then links that gap to the intervention types and policy levers able to close it.

Why ward nurses skip hand hygiene, sorted by what is missing

Six findings from a week of watching one ward. The first is placed as an example; select each other one, then the gap it shows: capability, opportunity, or motivation, and which part of it. Each box says what kind of fix that gap calls for, so the diagnosis chooses the fix. Illustrative.

Items (select one, then a box)
  • Not placedPlacedPhysical capabilityPsychological capabilityPhysical opportunitySocial opportunityAutomatic motivationReflective motivation
  • Not placedPlacedPhysical capabilityPsychological capabilityPhysical opportunitySocial opportunityAutomatic motivationReflective motivation
  • Not placedPlacedPhysical capabilityPsychological capabilityPhysical opportunitySocial opportunityAutomatic motivationReflective motivation
  • Not placedPlacedPhysical capabilityPsychological capabilityPhysical opportunitySocial opportunityAutomatic motivationReflective motivation
  • Not placedPlacedPhysical capabilityPsychological capabilityPhysical opportunitySocial opportunityAutomatic motivationReflective motivation
  • Not placedPlacedPhysical capabilityPsychological capabilityPhysical opportunitySocial opportunityAutomatic motivationReflective motivation

Which part of it

Part twoPart one
Psychological capability
Social opportunity
Reflective motivation
Physical capability
Physical opportunity
Automatic motivation
CapabilityOpportunityMotivation

What is missing

Gel at far end of bay.Not placed yet.Gel at far end of bay.Physical capability: A skill or a physical ability is missing. Training fits: practice until the technique is right.Gel at far end of bay.Psychological capability: Knowledge or understanding is missing. Teaching it fits: training, or a briefing at the point of need.Gel at far end of bay.Physical opportunity: The place, the time, or the materials get in the way. Restructure the environment so the behavior is easy where it is needed.The nurses know when to clean their hands and want to; the dispenser is twelve steps away. Put gel at every bed and on lanyards, and more training would add nothing.Gel at far end of bay.Social opportunity: The people around them make it harder. Change the setting they work in, starting with what the senior people visibly do.Gel at far end of bay.Automatic motivation: Habit or impulse wins in the moment. Work on the moment itself: a cue where the habit fires.Gel at far end of bay.Reflective motivation: They doubt it matters, or do not plan to do it. Work on the belief, with evidence they will accept.Agency staff unsure when.Not placed yet.Agency staff unsure when.Physical capability: A skill or a physical ability is missing. Training fits: practice until the technique is right.Agency staff unsure when.Psychological capability: Knowledge or understanding is missing. Teaching it fits: training, or a briefing at the point of need.Temporary nurses have not been taught the ward's moments for hand hygiene. A two-minute briefing at the start of each shift closes the gap.Agency staff unsure when.Physical opportunity: The place, the time, or the materials get in the way. Restructure the environment so the behavior is easy where it is needed.Agency staff unsure when.Social opportunity: The people around them make it harder. Change the setting they work in, starting with what the senior people visibly do.Agency staff unsure when.Automatic motivation: Habit or impulse wins in the moment. Work on the moment itself: a cue where the habit fires.Agency staff unsure when.Reflective motivation: They doubt it matters, or do not plan to do it. Work on the belief, with evidence they will accept.Senior doctors skip it.Not placed yet.Senior doctors skip it.Physical capability: A skill or a physical ability is missing. Training fits: practice until the technique is right.Senior doctors skip it.Psychological capability: Knowledge or understanding is missing. Teaching it fits: training, or a briefing at the point of need.Senior doctors skip it.Physical opportunity: The place, the time, or the materials get in the way. Restructure the environment so the behavior is easy where it is needed.Senior doctors skip it.Social opportunity: The people around them make it harder. Change the setting they work in, starting with what the senior people visibly do.Junior staff copy what they see on rounds. Ask the consultants to clean their hands visibly at each bed.Senior doctors skip it.Automatic motivation: Habit or impulse wins in the moment. Work on the moment itself: a cue where the habit fires.Senior doctors skip it.Reflective motivation: They doubt it matters, or do not plan to do it. Work on the belief, with evidence they will accept.Gloves feel like enough.Not placed yet.Gloves feel like enough.Physical capability: A skill or a physical ability is missing. Training fits: practice until the technique is right.Gloves feel like enough.Psychological capability: Knowledge or understanding is missing. Teaching it fits: training, or a briefing at the point of need.Gloves feel like enough.Physical opportunity: The place, the time, or the materials get in the way. Restructure the environment so the behavior is easy where it is needed.Gloves feel like enough.Social opportunity: The people around them make it harder. Change the setting they work in, starting with what the senior people visibly do.Gloves feel like enough.Automatic motivation: Habit or impulse wins in the moment. Work on the moment itself: a cue where the habit fires.Gloves feel like enough.Reflective motivation: They doubt it matters, or do not plan to do it. Work on the belief, with evidence they will accept.A belief: gloves seem to make hand cleaning pointless. Show the ward's own swab results from gloved hands.Hands go to chart first.Not placed yet.Hands go to chart first.Physical capability: A skill or a physical ability is missing. Training fits: practice until the technique is right.Hands go to chart first.Psychological capability: Knowledge or understanding is missing. Teaching it fits: training, or a briefing at the point of need.Hands go to chart first.Physical opportunity: The place, the time, or the materials get in the way. Restructure the environment so the behavior is easy where it is needed.Hands go to chart first.Social opportunity: The people around them make it harder. Change the setting they work in, starting with what the senior people visibly do.Hands go to chart first.Automatic motivation: Habit or impulse wins in the moment. Work on the moment itself: a cue where the habit fires.Habit: on entering a bay, hands reach for the chart first. A prompt on the chart holder catches the habit as it fires.Hands go to chart first.Reflective motivation: They doubt it matters, or do not plan to do it. Work on the belief, with evidence they will accept.Rubs too briefly to work.Not placed yet.Rubs too briefly to work.Physical capability: A skill or a physical ability is missing. Training fits: practice until the technique is right.The technique is wrong: a quick rub misses most of the hand. Practice with a light box that shows the missed areas.Rubs too briefly to work.Psychological capability: Knowledge or understanding is missing. Teaching it fits: training, or a briefing at the point of need.Rubs too briefly to work.Physical opportunity: The place, the time, or the materials get in the way. Restructure the environment so the behavior is easy where it is needed.Rubs too briefly to work.Social opportunity: The people around them make it harder. Change the setting they work in, starting with what the senior people visibly do.Rubs too briefly to work.Automatic motivation: Habit or impulse wins in the moment. Work on the moment itself: a cue where the habit fires.Rubs too briefly to work.Reflective motivation: They doubt it matters, or do not plan to do it. Work on the belief, with evidence they will accept.

Your sort matched 0 of 6.Your sort matched 1 of 6.Your sort matched 2 of 6.Your sort matched 3 of 6.Your sort matched 4 of 6.Your sort matched 5 of 6.Your sort matched 6 of 6.

Physical capability
A skill or a physical ability is missing. Training fits: practice until the technique is right.
Psychological capability
Knowledge or understanding is missing. Teaching it fits: training, or a briefing at the point of need.
Physical opportunity
The place, the time, or the materials get in the way. Restructure the environment so the behavior is easy where it is needed.
Social opportunity
The people around them make it harder. Change the setting they work in, starting with what the senior people visibly do.
Automatic motivation
Habit or impulse wins in the moment. Work on the moment itself: a cue where the habit fires.
Reflective motivation
They doubt it matters, or do not plan to do it. Work on the belief, with evidence they will accept.

The sort

  • Gel at far end of bay: Physical opportunity. The nurses know when to clean their hands and want to; the dispenser is twelve steps away. Put gel at every bed and on lanyards, and more training would add nothing.
  • Agency staff unsure when: Psychological capability. Temporary nurses have not been taught the ward's moments for hand hygiene. A two-minute briefing at the start of each shift closes the gap.
  • Senior doctors skip it: Social opportunity. Junior staff copy what they see on rounds. Ask the consultants to clean their hands visibly at each bed.
  • Gloves feel like enough: Reflective motivation. A belief: gloves seem to make hand cleaning pointless. Show the ward's own swab results from gloved hands.
  • Hands go to chart first: Automatic motivation. Habit: on entering a bay, hands reach for the chart first. A prompt on the chart holder catches the habit as it fires.
  • Rubs too briefly to work: Physical capability. The technique is wrong: a quick rub misses most of the hand. Practice with a light box that shows the missed areas.

An example

A hospital's infection control lead was asked to raise hand hygiene on a surgical ward, where audits put it at just over half of the moments it was required. The plan on her desk was a refresher training module, the third in two years.

She first wrote down the behavior exactly: cleaning hands with gel before touching a patient. Then she spent a week watching the ward and sorted what she saw by what was missing. Most of it had nothing to do with knowledge. The dispensers were at the far end of each bay, junior staff copied senior doctors who skipped it on rounds, and on entering a bay hands went straight to the chart. Only the agency nurses lacked the knowledge. The intervention matched the gaps: gel at every bed and on lanyards, consultants asked to clean their hands visibly at each bed, a prompt on the chart holders, and a short briefing for agency staff. Compliance reached four in five within a quarter, with no new training module.

Why it works

Behavior programs tend to jump to a favorite fix, usually training or incentives, before anyone has asked what is actually in the way. The wheel makes the diagnosis come first. Behavior needs capability (the knowledge and skill to do it), opportunity (a setting and people that allow it), and motivation (the beliefs and habits that drive it), and each has two parts. Find which part is missing, and the kinds of intervention that can help follow from it.

The link from gap to intervention is the point. Training cannot move a dispenser, and a poster cannot teach technique. Matching the fix to the gap stops a program from spending its budget on the one thing that was never missing, and the same structure tells an evaluation what to measure afterward.

The thinking behind it

Susan Michie Susan Michie, a health psychologist who directs University College London's center for the study of behavior change, built the wheel with Maartje M. van Stralen and Robert West and published it as The behaviour change wheel (Implementation Science, 2011), a method for characterizing and designing interventions. At its hub is the COM-B model: behavior arises from capability, opportunity, and motivation, and an intervention should target whichever is lacking. Around the hub sit nine intervention functions, and around those seven policy categories for delivering them.

Lou Atkins Lou Atkins, a behavior change researcher, wrote the practical guide to the wheel with Susan Michie and Robert West (Silverback Publishing, 2014). The guide turns the 2011 framework into a design process that a program team can follow, from defining the target behavior and diagnosing it with the COM-B model to choosing intervention functions and the policy categories able to deliver them.

How to run it

  1. Define the behavior precisely. Name who must do what, when, and where, in terms an observer could count.
  2. Watch it happen. Observe the setting and ask the people involved what makes the behavior easy or hard.
  3. Diagnose the gap. Sort each finding into capability, opportunity, or motivation, and which of the two parts of each.
  4. Match the gaps to kinds of intervention. Pick the intervention types that fit each gap, such as restructuring the setting for an opportunity gap.
  5. Choose how to deliver them. Decide, from the wheel's outer ring of policy categories, which route can put each intervention in place and who owns it.
  6. Design the specific changes. Write down exactly what changes, for whom, and from what date.
  7. Measure the behavior itself. Count the target behavior before and after, and diagnose again if it has not moved.

Where it goes wrong

The behavior is vague. "Improve hygiene" cannot be diagnosed, because nobody can say which act is missing. Rewrite it until an observer could tick a box each time it happens.

The diagnosis is done from a desk. Teams assume the gap is knowledge because training is what they know how to buy. Watch the behavior in its setting before sorting anything.

Every gap gets every fix. A long list of interventions dilutes effort and makes it impossible to tell what worked. Fix the largest gap first and measure before adding the next.

When to use something else

  • COM-B Model. When the job is only the diagnosis, and choosing the interventions can wait.
  • Fogg Behavior Model. When one person's single small habit is the target, and the question is the prompt and how easy the action is.
  • Implementation Intentions. When people already mean to act and need an if-then plan to follow through.

Where it sits in SOLVE eX

Go to the source

Back to the catalog