Originated by Abraham H. Maslow (A Theory of Human Motivation, 1943; Motivation and Personality, 1954); Todd Bridgman, Stephen Cummings, and John Ballard traced the familiar pyramid drawing to a 1960 article (Who Built Maslow's Pyramid?, 2019).
Ranks human needs from survival and safety up through belonging and esteem to self-actualization, and shows which unmet level is most likely driving behavior now.
A bonus that landed flat, checked against the levels of need from the bottom up
At each of the manager's turns, read what the team says and decide: is this level met, so look one higher, or is this the gap? The verdict follows each call. The point is to find the lowest unmet level and answer it before offering anything above it. Illustrative.
Site manager
Warehouse team
Site manager
Warehouse team
Right calls: 0 of 3Right calls: 1 of 3Right calls: 2 of 3Right calls: 3 of 3
- The puzzle (Warehouse team). The warehouse launched a monthly bonus and a leaderboard for error-free picking. In the first month, picks per hour fell 6 percent and the team asked for a meeting.
- Basic needs (Site manager). Wages match the market, shifts are set a month ahead, and breaks are kept. Nobody has raised pay or hours.
- Met: look one level higher The manager moves on to security: is the job itself safe? Right: nothing at the bottom is short.
- This is the gap: raise base pay Finance asks why, when pay is already at market. Not here: a raise answers a need the team does not have.
- What the team says (Warehouse team). A supervisor heard that the company is weighing a merger of two warehouses. Nobody has confirmed or denied it, and three people have started looking for other jobs.
- Safety (Site manager). The rumor is unconfirmed, but the team is acting on it.
- Met: look higher, at belonging and recognition The manager adds a shout-out board to the leaderboard. Missed: a team afraid for its jobs hears a leaderboard as a ranking for the next layoff.
- This is the gap: stop and answer it The manager takes the question to the regional director that afternoon. Right: the lowest unmet level is safety, and it drives the behavior.
- Why the bonus missed (Warehouse team). Asked directly, the team says the leaderboard looks like a list of who to keep. Careful pickers slowed down to avoid errors on the record.
- The response (Site manager). The director confirms the site stays open for at least two years.
- Double the bonus to show goodwill The team takes the money and keeps looking for other jobs. A higher level offered over an open lower one: it misses.
- Put the two-year commitment in writing and say what would change it The manager reads the letter at the shift meeting and answers questions for an hour. Right: aimed at the gap. Once it closes, the bonus can do its job.
- Six weeks later (Warehouse team). Two of the three job seekers stayed. Picks per hour rose 4 percent above the old level, and the accuracy bonus paid out to most of the team.
An example
A distribution company rolled out a monthly bonus and a leaderboard for error-free picking at one warehouse. In the first month, picks per hour fell 6 percent and the team asked for a meeting. The site manager's first instinct was to make the bonus bigger.
Her HR partner suggested checking the team's needs from the bottom up instead. Pay, hours, and breaks were fine: wages matched the market and shifts were set a month ahead. One level up, she found the problem. A rumor had gone round that the company might merge two warehouses and close this one, nobody had answered it, and three people were already job hunting. To a team afraid for its jobs, a leaderboard looked like a list of who to keep, so careful pickers slowed down.
She took it to the regional director that day. The site would stay open for at least two years, and she read the commitment aloud at the next shift meeting. Six weeks later picks were 4 percent above the old level, and the bonus was paying out.
Why it works
People respond to the most pressing need they have, and appeals aimed above it land flat. Recognition means little to someone worried about rent; a purpose statement means little to someone who thinks the job may disappear. The hierarchy gives a fast order in which to check, starting at the bottom, so the first real gap found is the one most likely to be driving behavior.
The check also explains a common failure. Managers reach for the levels they control most easily, such as praise, bonuses, and titles, and those sit high up. When the problem sits lower, the higher offer is read through the lower worry and can backfire. Answering the lowest gap first does not replace the higher appeals; it lets them work.
The thinking behind it
Abraham H. Maslow Abraham H. Maslow proposed the hierarchy in A Theory of Human Motivation (1943, in Psychological Review) and developed it in Motivation and Personality (1954): physiological needs, safety, love and belonging, esteem, and self-actualization, with lower needs generally taking priority until they are largely met. He described the shift between levels as gradual, not a strict sequence. Later reviews of the research found little support for a fixed ranking, so the order works best as a first read.
Todd Bridgman Todd Bridgman, Stephen Cummings, and John Ballard showed in Who Built Maslow's Pyramid? (2019, Academy of Management Learning and Education) that Maslow never drew his hierarchy as a pyramid. They traced the familiar drawing to management writers: Keith Davis's staircase of 1957 and Charles McDermid's 1960 article in Business Horizons. The pyramid's hard steps are the writers' addition; Maslow described the shift between levels as gradual, which is why the figure treats the levels as an order to check, not a fixed ladder.
How to run it
- Name the puzzling behavior. Write what the person or group is doing that the current incentives do not explain, with numbers if there are any.
- Start at the bottom. Check pay, hours, rest, and physical conditions, and ask the people involved before assuming they are fine.
- Check security next. Look for threats to the job, the income, or the role: rumors, reorganizations, unclear contracts.
- Then belonging and standing. Ask whether people feel part of the team and whether their contribution is seen, in their words.
- Stop at the lowest real gap. The first level with a clear, current shortfall is the one to answer, even if a higher one also looks weak.
- Answer that gap directly. Choose a response aimed at it, in terms the group will believe, such as a written commitment instead of reassurance.
- Then return to the higher appeal. Once the gap closes, reintroduce the bonus, the recognition, or the purpose, and watch whether behavior follows.
Where it goes wrong
The levels are treated as a strict ladder. Real people pursue several needs at once, and a team can care about recognition while worried about pay. Use the order to decide where to look first, not to rule out everything above.
The check is done from the manager's desk. Assumptions about what a team has, such as fair pay or job security, are often wrong in exactly the places that matter. Ask the people involved.
The gap is real but unanswerable. Sometimes the lowest unmet need, such as job security during a sale, cannot be met. Say so plainly, give what certainty exists, and expect higher appeals to land weakly until it clears.
When to use something else
- COM-B Model. When the behavior may come from missing skill or opportunity, not only from unmet motivation.
- Jobs to Be Done. When the question is what a customer is trying to get done, more than which human need is unmet.
- Empathy Map. When the team needs to see what the group says, thinks, feels, and does before guessing at a need.
Where it sits in SOLVE eX
Go to the source
- A Theory of Human Motivation, Psychological Review, 1943
- Motivation and Personality, Harper, 1954
- Who Built Maslow's Pyramid?, Academy of Management Learning and Education, 2019