Zettelkasten

Thinking ToolsAny stepAlso known as Slip Box

From the early modern slip box, made a numbered and linked system by Niklas Luhmann (Kommunikation mit Zettelkästen, 1981) and popularized by Sönke Ahrens (How to Take Smart Notes, 2017).

A note system of one idea per note, each with an ID and dense links to related notes, so a network of ideas grows over time and feeds writing.

A slip box on pricing: numbered notes that branch, with links across the branches

Each box is one idea in the owner's words, with an ID that says where it was filed: 1a continues 1, 1a1 continues 1a. Select a note to read it, then a link under the box to follow a thought across branches; a chain of links is the outline of an essay. Mark the notes the essay would use. Illustrative.

Links between branches:

0 of 4 marked1 of 4 marked2 of 4 marked3 of 4 marked4 of 4 marked

Select a note to read it, or a link to follow a thought across branches.Entry: pricing. An entry note that points into the box. It lists where each line of thought starts; it is not a table of contents, and the notes below it can link anywhere.1 Price signals quality. Buyers who cannot judge quality directly read it from the price. Written after a book on consumer psychology.1a Cheap reads as risky in B2B. In business buying, a low quote raises the buyer's fear of being blamed for a failure.1a1 Buyers ask for references. A buyer facing a low quote asks for references to cover themselves. From a call with a procurement head.1b A premium needs proof. A high price holds only when the buyer can point to evidence for it.2 Buyers anchor on the first number. The first figure named in a negotiation pulls every later figure toward it.2a Lead with the full package. Quote the complete offer first, so the anchor is the high number.2b Discounts reset the anchor. Once a discount is given, the discounted price becomes the next year's starting point.3 Value pricing needs a metric. Pricing on value works only when buyer and seller can count the value the same way.3a Price per seat hides value. Charging per user ties price to headcount, which has little to do with what the software saves.3b Price on hours saved. A metric both sides can count: hours of work the product removes each month.A discount also reads as risk. Linked when 2b was written: a deep discount anchors low and, by note 1a, makes the buyer wonder what is wrong.Hours saved is the proof. Note 3b answers note 1b: a counted saving is the evidence a premium needs.Lead with the value. Leading with the full package works better when the package is priced on value: the first number the buyer hears is the saving, and the per-user fee never sets the anchor.

Five new notes from this month's reading: file each one beside the note it continues

A new note goes behind the note it continues and takes the next ID there, with a link back; a thought that continues nothing starts a new number. Select a note, then the place it belongs; the panel gives its ID and its links. One is filed as an example. Show the filing to compare yours. Illustrative.

Items (select one, then a box)
  • Not placedPlacedBehind note 1Behind note 2Behind note 3New number 4
  • Not placedPlacedBehind note 1Behind note 2Behind note 3New number 4
  • Not placedPlacedBehind note 1Behind note 2Behind note 3New number 4
  • Not placedPlacedBehind note 1Behind note 2Behind note 3New number 4
  • Not placedPlacedBehind note 1Behind note 2Behind note 3New number 4

Where it is filed

The box
Behind note 1
Behind note 2
Behind note 3
New number 4
1 Quality signal2 Anchoring3 Value metricNothing yet

Continues the thought of

Free trials lower risk. From a case on software sales: a trial lets a cautious buyer try before committing.Not placed yet.Free trials lower risk. From a case on software sales: a trial lets a cautious buyer try before committing.Behind note 1: It continues the idea that price signals quality. It takes the next free ID in that branch and a link back to the note it answers.It answers 1a: a trial lowers the buyer's risk without lowering the price. Filed as 1a2, with a link to 1a.Free trials lower risk. From a case on software sales: a trial lets a cautious buyer try before committing.Behind note 2: It continues the idea that buyers anchor on the first number. It takes the next free ID in that branch.Free trials lower risk. From a case on software sales: a trial lets a cautious buyer try before committing.Behind note 3: It continues the idea that value pricing needs a metric. It takes the next free ID in that branch.Free trials lower risk. From a case on software sales: a trial lets a cautious buyer try before committing.New number 4: No existing note continues it, so it starts a new line of thought as note 4 and is added to the entry note.Odd prices look cheaper. A price of $99 reads as a deal next to $100.Not placed yet.Odd prices look cheaper. A price of $99 reads as a deal next to $100.Behind note 1: It continues the idea that price signals quality. It takes the next free ID in that branch and a link back to the note it answers.Odd prices look cheaper. A price of $99 reads as a deal next to $100.Behind note 2: It continues the idea that buyers anchor on the first number. It takes the next free ID in that branch.It is about how the first number is read, so it goes behind note 2 as 2c.Odd prices look cheaper. A price of $99 reads as a deal next to $100.Behind note 3: It continues the idea that value pricing needs a metric. It takes the next free ID in that branch.Odd prices look cheaper. A price of $99 reads as a deal next to $100.New number 4: No existing note continues it, so it starts a new line of thought as note 4 and is added to the entry note.Usage fees track value. Charging per invoice processed rises and falls with what the buyer gets.Not placed yet.Usage fees track value. Charging per invoice processed rises and falls with what the buyer gets.Behind note 1: It continues the idea that price signals quality. It takes the next free ID in that branch and a link back to the note it answers.Usage fees track value. Charging per invoice processed rises and falls with what the buyer gets.Behind note 2: It continues the idea that buyers anchor on the first number. It takes the next free ID in that branch.Usage fees track value. Charging per invoice processed rises and falls with what the buyer gets.Behind note 3: It continues the idea that value pricing needs a metric. It takes the next free ID in that branch.Another countable metric, filed as 3c, with a link to 3b to compare the two.Usage fees track value. Charging per invoice processed rises and falls with what the buyer gets.New number 4: No existing note continues it, so it starts a new line of thought as note 4 and is added to the entry note.Buyers compare units. Buyers line up quotes by price per unit, whatever the unit is.Not placed yet.Buyers compare units. Buyers line up quotes by price per unit, whatever the unit is.Behind note 1: It continues the idea that price signals quality. It takes the next free ID in that branch and a link back to the note it answers.Buyers compare units. Buyers line up quotes by price per unit, whatever the unit is.Behind note 2: It continues the idea that buyers anchor on the first number. It takes the next free ID in that branch.Buyers compare units. Buyers line up quotes by price per unit, whatever the unit is.Behind note 3: It continues the idea that value pricing needs a metric. It takes the next free ID in that branch.It warns about 3a's per-seat trap from the buyer's side. Filed as 3a1, linked to 3a.Buyers compare units. Buyers line up quotes by price per unit, whatever the unit is.New number 4: No existing note continues it, so it starts a new line of thought as note 4 and is added to the entry note.Renewal is a second sale. A customer at renewal weighs the price again as if buying fresh.Not placed yet.Renewal is a second sale. A customer at renewal weighs the price again as if buying fresh.Behind note 1: It continues the idea that price signals quality. It takes the next free ID in that branch and a link back to the note it answers.Renewal is a second sale. A customer at renewal weighs the price again as if buying fresh.Behind note 2: It continues the idea that buyers anchor on the first number. It takes the next free ID in that branch.Renewal is a second sale. A customer at renewal weighs the price again as if buying fresh.Behind note 3: It continues the idea that value pricing needs a metric. It takes the next free ID in that branch.Renewal is a second sale. A customer at renewal weighs the price again as if buying fresh.New number 4: No existing note continues it, so it starts a new line of thought as note 4 and is added to the entry note.Nothing in the box continues this yet, so it starts line 4; a link to 2b notes that last year's discount is the renewal's anchor.

Your sort matched 0 of 5.Your sort matched 1 of 5.Your sort matched 2 of 5.Your sort matched 3 of 5.Your sort matched 4 of 5.Your sort matched 5 of 5.

Behind note 1
It continues the idea that price signals quality. It takes the next free ID in that branch and a link back to the note it answers.
Behind note 2
It continues the idea that buyers anchor on the first number. It takes the next free ID in that branch.
Behind note 3
It continues the idea that value pricing needs a metric. It takes the next free ID in that branch.
New number 4
No existing note continues it, so it starts a new line of thought as note 4 and is added to the entry note.

The sort

  • Free trials lower risk: Behind note 1. It answers 1a: a trial lowers the buyer's risk without lowering the price. Filed as 1a2, with a link to 1a.
  • Odd prices look cheaper: Behind note 2. It is about how the first number is read, so it goes behind note 2 as 2c.
  • Usage fees track value: Behind note 3. Another countable metric, filed as 3c, with a link to 3b to compare the two.
  • Buyers compare units: Behind note 3. It warns about 3a's per-seat trap from the buyer's side. Filed as 3a1, linked to 3a.
  • Renewal is a second sale: New number 4. Nothing in the box continues this yet, so it starts line 4; a link to 2b notes that last year's discount is the renewal's anchor.

An example

A pricing consultant had kept years of reading notes in folders by client and by book, and every new engagement started from a blank page, because nothing in the folders connected to anything else. She switched to a slip box: each note one idea in her own words, given an ID by where it was filed, and linked to the notes it touched. Within a year the pricing part of the box held about forty notes in three lines of thought, quality signals, anchoring, and value metrics, with links running across them.

When a client asked for a short paper on why its discounts were hurting renewals, she started at note 2b, discounts reset the anchor, and followed its links: to 1a on low prices reading as risk, through 3b on pricing by hours saved, and to the newer line on renewals. The chain of notes was the outline. The draft took an afternoon, and most of its sentences already existed, in notes written months apart for other reasons.

Why it works

Folders store notes by where they came from, which is the least useful thing to know about them later. A slip box stores each note by the thought it continues and links it to what it touches, so related ideas sit together however far apart they were read. Writing every note as one idea in one's own words forces understanding at the moment of reading, and the link forces a decision about how the new idea relates to the old ones.

Over time the links do work no single note can. Clusters form around the questions the owner keeps returning to, with no hierarchy designed in advance, and following links from any note turns up connections nobody planned. A piece of writing then starts from a chain of finished thoughts instead of a blank page.

The thinking behind it

Niklas Luhmann Niklas Luhmann, a systems theorist at Bielefeld University, kept a slip box of numbered, cross-referenced notes for decades and described it in Kommunikation mit Zettelkästen: Ein Erfahrungsbericht (1981) as a partner in communication. Notes are filed by number, so a note that continues another takes the next number behind it; each one is linked to related notes; and an index gives the ways in. Because the collection grows by connection, new combinations surface as it grows.

Sönke Ahrens Sönke Ahrens wrote How to Take Smart Notes: One Simple Technique to Boost Writing, Learning and Thinking (2017; second edition 2022), the popular guide that carried Luhmann's slip box to a wide readership. Its account follows Luhmann's own: one idea per note, filed by number and linked to what it touches. It is a practitioner's guide, not a research study, and its subtitle names what the method is meant to feed: writing, learning, and thinking.

How to run it

  1. Capture while reading. Jot a quick note with the source, the page, and the point that mattered.
  2. Rewrite each capture as one idea. Use full sentences in plain words of one's own, so the note makes sense months later without the source.
  3. File it behind the note it continues. Give it the next ID there, or a new number when it continues nothing.
  4. Link it to the notes it touches. Add the link in both notes, with a few words on why the two belong together.
  5. Keep an entry note. List where each line of thought starts, so it can be found again.
  6. Revisit and refine. Rewrite notes as understanding changes, and split any note that has grown a second idea.
  7. Write from chains. Start a piece by following links from one note and lining up the chain as an outline.

Where it goes wrong

The first failure is collecting instead of thinking. Highlights and pasted quotes pile up, nothing is rewritten, and the box becomes a second, larger reading list. Spot it when most notes would make no sense without opening the source, and recover by rewriting each new note before filing it.

The second is filing by topic folder, which rebuilds the hierarchy the method exists to avoid and hides the links across topics. The third is linking everything to everything. A link that says nothing about why two notes belong together cannot be followed later, so write the reason on the link, and skip the link when there is no reason.

When to use something else

  • Mind Mapping. When the need is to lay out one topic quickly for a single project, with no plan to keep the result for years.
  • Concept Map. When the relationships among a set of concepts need drawing and labeling on one page for others to read.

Where it sits in SOLVE eX

  • Any step: Tools that serve every step: habits of thought and checks on the thinking itself.

Go to the source

  • Kommunikation mit Zettelkästen: Ein Erfahrungsbericht, Westdeutscher Verlag, 1981
  • How to Take Smart Notes, 2017

Back to the catalog