Phenomenological Analysis

Thinking Tools1.1 Describing the SituationAlso known as Descriptive Phenomenology

Founded by Edmund Husserl (Ideas I, 1913), developed by Maurice Merleau-Ponty (Phenomenology of Perception, 1945), and made a step-by-step method by Amedeo Giorgi (The Descriptive Phenomenological Method in Psychology, 2009).

Describes what an experience is like for the people living it, setting theories and explanations aside until the structure of the experience is down on paper.

Eight lines from a study of first months as a manager, sorted into description and explanation

Each card is a line from the interviews or from the analyst's notes. One is placed as an example: select each other card, then its box, by whose words it is and whether it describes the experience or explains it. Only the top row builds the structure; explanations wait. Illustrative.

Items (select one, then a box)
  • Not placedPlacedKeep: the accountKeep: the descriptionTheir own theoryBracket it
  • Not placedPlacedKeep: the accountKeep: the descriptionTheir own theoryBracket it
  • Not placedPlacedKeep: the accountKeep: the descriptionTheir own theoryBracket it
  • Not placedPlacedKeep: the accountKeep: the descriptionTheir own theoryBracket it
  • Not placedPlacedKeep: the accountKeep: the descriptionTheir own theoryBracket it
  • Not placedPlacedKeep: the accountKeep: the descriptionTheir own theoryBracket it
  • Not placedPlacedKeep: the accountKeep: the descriptionTheir own theoryBracket it
  • Not placedPlacedKeep: the accountKeep: the descriptionTheir own theoryBracket it

What the line does

Describes itExplains why
Keep: the account
Keep: the description
Their own theory
Bracket it
The new manager'sThe analyst's

Whose words

Ten minutes in the car. "Most mornings that first month I sat in the car in the lot for ten minutes before going in."Not placed yet.Ten minutes in the car. "Most mornings that first month I sat in the car in the lot for ten minutes before going in."Keep: the account: The person's own description of what happened and how it felt: the raw material. Keep it in their words.A plain account of what she did, and the kind of detail the structure is built from.Ten minutes in the car. "Most mornings that first month I sat in the car in the lot for ten minutes before going in."Keep: the description: The analyst restating what was lived, plainly, with no cause attached. This is the analysis being built.Ten minutes in the car. "Most mornings that first month I sat in the car in the lot for ten minutes before going in."Their own theory: The person's explanation of their experience: record it as part of what they lived, but do not build the structure on it.Ten minutes in the car. "Most mornings that first month I sat in the car in the lot for ten minutes before going in."Bracket it: The analyst's explanation or diagnosis: set it aside until the structure of the experience is written down.I'm just an impostor. "I think I'm just an impostor and they all know it."Not placed yet.I'm just an impostor. "I think I'm just an impostor and they all know it."Keep: the account: The person's own description of what happened and how it felt: the raw material. Keep it in their words.I'm just an impostor. "I think I'm just an impostor and they all know it."Keep: the description: The analyst restating what was lived, plainly, with no cause attached. This is the analysis being built.I'm just an impostor. "I think I'm just an impostor and they all know it."Their own theory: The person's explanation of their experience: record it as part of what they lived, but do not build the structure on it.Her own explanation of the feeling. It belongs in the record, but the analysis describes the feeling, not her theory of it.I'm just an impostor. "I think I'm just an impostor and they all know it."Bracket it: The analyst's explanation or diagnosis: set it aside until the structure of the experience is written down.Impostor syndrome. The analyst's margin note on the same interview.Not placed yet.Impostor syndrome. The analyst's margin note on the same interview.Keep: the account: The person's own description of what happened and how it felt: the raw material. Keep it in their words.Impostor syndrome. The analyst's margin note on the same interview.Keep: the description: The analyst restating what was lived, plainly, with no cause attached. This is the analysis being built.Impostor syndrome. The analyst's margin note on the same interview.Their own theory: The person's explanation of their experience: record it as part of what they lived, but do not build the structure on it.Impostor syndrome. The analyst's margin note on the same interview.Bracket it: The analyst's explanation or diagnosis: set it aside until the structure of the experience is written down.A diagnosis imported from outside the account. Hold it back until the experience itself is described.The room went quiet. "When I walked into the team room, the talking stopped."Not placed yet.The room went quiet. "When I walked into the team room, the talking stopped."Keep: the account: The person's own description of what happened and how it felt: the raw material. Keep it in their words.What it was like, in his words: a moment where something shifted.The room went quiet. "When I walked into the team room, the talking stopped."Keep: the description: The analyst restating what was lived, plainly, with no cause attached. This is the analysis being built.The room went quiet. "When I walked into the team room, the talking stopped."Their own theory: The person's explanation of their experience: record it as part of what they lived, but do not build the structure on it.The room went quiet. "When I walked into the team room, the talking stopped."Bracket it: The analyst's explanation or diagnosis: set it aside until the structure of the experience is written down.Her days set by others. The analyst's summary of the second account.Not placed yet.Her days set by others. The analyst's summary of the second account.Keep: the account: The person's own description of what happened and how it felt: the raw material. Keep it in their words.Her days set by others. The analyst's summary of the second account.Keep: the description: The analyst restating what was lived, plainly, with no cause attached. This is the analysis being built.A plain restatement: the calendar filled with other people's requests, and her own work moved to the evenings.Her days set by others. The analyst's summary of the second account.Their own theory: The person's explanation of their experience: record it as part of what they lived, but do not build the structure on it.Her days set by others. The analyst's summary of the second account.Bracket it: The analyst's explanation or diagnosis: set it aside until the structure of the experience is written down.No leadership training. The analyst's note on the third account.Not placed yet.No leadership training. The analyst's note on the third account.Keep: the account: The person's own description of what happened and how it felt: the raw material. Keep it in their words.No leadership training. The analyst's note on the third account.Keep: the description: The analyst restating what was lived, plainly, with no cause attached. This is the analysis being built.No leadership training. The analyst's note on the third account.Their own theory: The person's explanation of their experience: record it as part of what they lived, but do not build the structure on it.No leadership training. The analyst's note on the third account.Bracket it: The analyst's explanation or diagnosis: set it aside until the structure of the experience is written down.A cause, and a remedy waiting to be sold. Bracket it until the structure is down.Lunch with peers ended. The analyst's summary across all three accounts.Not placed yet.Lunch with peers ended. The analyst's summary across all three accounts.Keep: the account: The person's own description of what happened and how it felt: the raw material. Keep it in their words.Lunch with peers ended. The analyst's summary across all three accounts.Keep: the description: The analyst restating what was lived, plainly, with no cause attached. This is the analysis being built.Found in all three accounts, described without a cause: part of the shared structure.Lunch with peers ended. The analyst's summary across all three accounts.Their own theory: The person's explanation of their experience: record it as part of what they lived, but do not build the structure on it.Lunch with peers ended. The analyst's summary across all three accounts.Bracket it: The analyst's explanation or diagnosis: set it aside until the structure of the experience is written down.Boss set me up to fail. "My boss set me up to fail by promoting me over them."Not placed yet.Boss set me up to fail. "My boss set me up to fail by promoting me over them."Keep: the account: The person's own description of what happened and how it felt: the raw material. Keep it in their words.Boss set me up to fail. "My boss set me up to fail by promoting me over them."Keep: the description: The analyst restating what was lived, plainly, with no cause attached. This is the analysis being built.Boss set me up to fail. "My boss set me up to fail by promoting me over them."Their own theory: The person's explanation of their experience: record it as part of what they lived, but do not build the structure on it.His explanation, recorded as what he believes. The structure is built from what happened, not from who he blames.Boss set me up to fail. "My boss set me up to fail by promoting me over them."Bracket it: The analyst's explanation or diagnosis: set it aside until the structure of the experience is written down.

Your sort matched 0 of 8.Your sort matched 1 of 8.Your sort matched 2 of 8.Your sort matched 3 of 8.Your sort matched 4 of 8.Your sort matched 5 of 8.Your sort matched 6 of 8.Your sort matched 7 of 8.Your sort matched 8 of 8.

Keep: the account
The person's own description of what happened and how it felt: the raw material. Keep it in their words.
Keep: the description
The analyst restating what was lived, plainly, with no cause attached. This is the analysis being built.
Their own theory
The person's explanation of their experience: record it as part of what they lived, but do not build the structure on it.
Bracket it
The analyst's explanation or diagnosis: set it aside until the structure of the experience is written down.

The sort

  • Ten minutes in the car: Keep: the account. A plain account of what she did, and the kind of detail the structure is built from.
  • I'm just an impostor: Their own theory. Her own explanation of the feeling. It belongs in the record, but the analysis describes the feeling, not her theory of it.
  • Impostor syndrome: Bracket it. A diagnosis imported from outside the account. Hold it back until the experience itself is described.
  • The room went quiet: Keep: the account. What it was like, in his words: a moment where something shifted.
  • Her days set by others: Keep: the description. A plain restatement: the calendar filled with other people's requests, and her own work moved to the evenings.
  • No leadership training: Bracket it. A cause, and a remedy waiting to be sold. Bracket it until the structure is down.
  • Lunch with peers ended: Keep: the description. Found in all three accounts, described without a cause: part of the shared structure.
  • Boss set me up to fail: Their own theory. His explanation, recorded as what he believes. The structure is built from what happened, not from who he blames.

An example

A retail chain promoted about sixty store staff a year to their first management job, and a third of them asked to step back down within a year. The learning team was ready to buy a leadership course. The head of people asked first what the first month actually felt like.

An analyst took long interviews with three new managers about one bounded experience, their first month in the job. She read each account whole, then marked every passage where something shifted, and described each passage plainly, in her own words, without saying why it happened. Her margin notes kept trying to explain: impostor syndrome, a lack of training. She moved those to a separate page and kept going.

The structure the three accounts shared had little to do with skill. Each manager lost an easy place among former peers, the lunches and the jokes, in the first week. Each found their days set by other people's requests. Each felt watched. The chain added a peer group of new managers from other stores before buying any course.

Why it works

Explanations arrive fast, and once one is in place it decides what gets noticed. An analyst who has already decided the problem is a skill gap hears every account as evidence of a skill gap and skips the details that do not fit. Holding explanations back for a while lets the experience show its own shape first.

The method makes that holding back a practice. Long first-person accounts supply the texture surveys flatten. Marking where something shifts finds the moments that matter to the person living it. Describing each moment plainly, then looking for what the accounts share, produces a structure built from the experience itself, and that structure often points to a different fix than the explanation the team walked in with.

The thinking behind it

Edmund Husserl Edmund Husserl founded phenomenology, the description of experience as it is lived, in works from Logical Investigations (1900) to Ideas I (1913). His method, the epoché or bracketing, suspends the natural attitude that takes the world's existence for granted, without doubting or denying it, so that the world can be studied as it appears to consciousness. Bracketing is the move this tool borrows: explanations are set aside, not refuted.

Maurice Merleau-Ponty Maurice Merleau-Ponty, a French phenomenologist, argued in Phenomenology of Perception (1945) that perception is the ground of experience, and that the lived body, not a detached mind, is where knowing begins. The perceiving body and the perceived world cannot be pulled apart, which is why a sound account of an experience includes what the person did and felt in the body.

Amedeo Giorgi Amedeo Giorgi, a founder of the Duquesne school of phenomenological psychology, turned the philosophy of Husserl and Merleau-Ponty into a research method, set out in The Descriptive Phenomenological Method in Psychology: A Modified Husserlian Approach (2009). Its method describes the structure of lived experience from participants' own accounts, step by step, which is the order of work this tool follows.

How to run it

  1. Name one bounded experience. Pick an experience with a time and a place, such as the first month as a manager, not management in general.
  2. Collect long first-person accounts. Ask three to six people to describe what happened and what it was like, in their own words, with follow-up questions that ask for more detail, never for reasons.
  3. Read each account whole. Read it through once for its overall sense before marking anything.
  4. Mark where something shifts. Go back through and mark each passage where the experience changes for the person.
  5. Describe each passage plainly. Restate what was lived in your own words, and move any explanation that comes to mind onto a separate page.
  6. Find the shared structure. Compare the descriptions across accounts and write down what they have in common.
  7. Only then bring back the explanations. Return to the set-aside page and test each explanation against the structure you found.

Where it goes wrong

The explanation sneaks in through the description. Words such as anxious, resistant, or disengaged sound descriptive and carry a theory with them. Replace each with what the person actually did or said.

The accounts are too short. A survey answer or a quick interview gives opinions about the experience, not the experience. Ask for one specific day, and keep asking what happened next.

The experience is too broad. Studying what management is like produces generalities. Bound the experience in time and place, so that every account describes the same kind of moment.

When to use something else

  • Empathy Map. When a team needs a quick shared picture of what users say, think, do, and feel, more than a careful study.
  • Thick Description. When the aim is to describe a practice in its cultural setting, observed over time, more than a single lived experience.
  • Customer Journey Mapping. When the experience is a sequence of steps with a product or service, and the work is finding where it breaks.

Where it sits in SOLVE eX

Go to the source

  • Ideas I (Ideen zu einer reinen Phänomenologie), 1913
  • Phenomenology of Perception, Gallimard, 1945
  • The Descriptive Phenomenological Method in Psychology: A Modified Husserlian Approach, Duquesne University Press, 2009

Back to the catalog