Henry Mintzberg

ThinkersBorn 1939Management scholar

Works

In Political Tactics

Ideas

The strategic candidates game. Mintzberg describes political games played inside organizations, and among those played to effect change, the strategic candidates game is the promotion of a proposed strategic change through the system by a sponsor or champion. Anyone with a candidate and some means of influence can play, and the game draws on alliances, expertise, budgets, and sponsorship.

The whistle-blowing game. In the whistle-blowing game, an insider, often low in the hierarchy, who sees behavior that violates a social norm or law uses privileged information to inform an outside party who can remedy it. Because the player bypasses the chain of authority and questions its legitimacy, retribution is a risk, so the contact is often made secretly.

What it explains

Mintzberg explains that politics is one of several systems of influence in an organization, alongside authority, ideology, and expertise, and that people promote change through recognizable games. Sponsoring a proposal through the system is the most common of them.

Political Tactics that draw on Henry Mintzberg (2)

In Organizational Structures

Known for

The five configurations of structure

Ideas

Simple structure. The configuration in which the strategic apex coordinates by direct supervision, with a minimally elaborated, highly centralized structure, found in small, young organizations, in simple and dynamic environments, under strong leaders, or in severe crises. Caveat: A synthesis of earlier research, not a test; Sine, Mitsuhashi, and Kirsch (2006) and Lee (2022) found that more formal structure or more hierarchy helped some new ventures.

Machine bureaucracy. The configuration that coordinates by work standards set in the technostructure, with highly specialized and formalized jobs, large functional operating units, and vertical centralization, found in simple, stable environments and older, larger, mass-production organizations. Caveat: The Aston group (Pugh and colleagues 1968, 1969) concluded that a single bureaucratic type is no longer useful because bureaucracy takes several empirical forms.

Entrepreneurial mode of strategy making. In the entrepreneurial mode of strategy making, bold decisions are taken by a powerful decision maker, beside the adaptive and planning modes. Caveat: Conceptual. Read in its abstract only.

Tracking strategy as a pattern in a stream of actions. Strategy is studied by reconstructing the realized pattern of a firm's decisions over decades, as in the 60-year study of a retail chain that grew large and formalized its structure. Caveat: One firm; the conclusions concern strategy formation more than structure.

Configurations of structure. Mintzberg synthesized the research into five parts of the organization, five coordinating mechanisms, the design parameters, and five configurations, each relying on one mechanism. Caveat: Doty, Glick, and Huber (1993) did not find that fit to his configurations predicted effectiveness.

Professional bureaucracy. The configuration that coordinates by standardizing the skills of its operating core: jobs highly specialized but little formalized, long training, grouping on functional and market bases at once, large operating units, and extensive decentralization both vertically and horizontally, found in complex but stable environments with simple technical systems. Caveat: A synthesis of earlier research, not a test; Doty, Glick, and Huber (1993) found no support for the claim that organizations resembling the ideal types are more effective.

Adhocracy. The configuration that coordinates mainly by mutual adjustment among all its parts, relying on support staff, with specialized and highly trained but little formalized jobs, small units combining functional and market bases in matrix structures, extensive liaison devices, and selective decentralization, found in complex, dynamic environments. Caveat: Doty, Glick, and Huber (1993) found no support for the ideal types' effectiveness claim; Parikh (2016) argues in a literature review that ambidexterity now covers what adhocracy offered.

Strategy formation in an adhocracy. Tracking the National Film Board of Canada's strategies over almost four decades, Mintzberg and McHugh focused on three themes: the emergent nature of its strategies, its cycles of behavior, and its quest for adhocracy. Caveat: One organization.

Care and cure as differentiated worlds. Glouberman and Mintzberg offer a framework for why the management of health care institutions, which combine the clinical methods of care and cure, becomes so convoluted. Caveat: Conceptual.

Hybrid configurations. Effective organizations are claimed to favor a logically consistent configuration, while contradictory pressures or transitions drive some to hybrids. Caveat: Doty, Glick, and Huber (1993) found no support for the claim that resembling the five ideal types makes organizations more effective.

The missionary organization. A configuration coordinated by standardization of norms, in which a strong ideology lets members act with little formal structure. Caveat: Conceptual, built from description rather than tests. Proposed in Structure in 5's (1980) as a candidate sixth configuration and developed in Mintzberg on Management (1989), drawn on here only in passages; This entry does not draw on Power In and Around Organizations (1983).

Power configurations. Named six power configurations (instrument, closed system, autocracy, missionary, meritocracy, and political arena) and mapped them to his structural configurations. Caveat: Conceptual.

Four forms that fit most organizations. Four forms fit most organizations, the personal enterprise, the programmed machine, the professional assembly, and the project pioneer, each with its own way to structure, manage, and craft strategy; many organizations come close to one form, others are hybrids of them or in transition among them, and a closing section turns to design doing beyond the four. Caveat: An article that names only these four forms and cites the 2023 book for them.

Seven forms and seven forces. Mintzberg's revision of Structure in Fives identifies seven forms and seven forces that drive organizations toward hybrids and across their life cycles: beside the four fundamental forms, the divisional form, the community ship, and the political arena are further forms, each tied to one of three further forces, among them the infusion of culture and the intrusion of conflict. Caveat: This entry does not draw on the book itself; the forms and forces come from the publisher's description and two reviews (Chahin 2023; Adinolfi and Rebora 2024).

Organizational Structures that draw on Henry Mintzberg (17)

Back to the thinkers